Wed Oct 28, 2009 4:59 pm EDT
We love lists here on Puck Daddy, and John Grigg of The Hockey News has a pot-stirrer today called "Top 10: Things that changed the game"; published in conjunction with the 50th anniversary of Jacques Plante becoming the first goaltender to wear a mask.
(The goalie mask anniversary is Sunday. We plan on celebrating by watching a "Friday The 13th" marathon and eating overcooked hamburgers until our teeth break.)
The game-changing list, via The Hockey News Web site:
10. The elimination of the rover and the introduction of forward pass
9. The Summit Series
8. The Miracle on Ice
7. The World Hockey Association
6. Wayne Gretzky
5. The 2004-05 Lockout
4. The NHLPA
3. Expansion
2. Europeans
1. The Entry Draft
Obviously, head over and read the justification for each entry, because Grigg has some solid arguments for each one. It's an odd collection at first glance, because the focus should be on "10 things that changed the game" but some of them are clearly more influenced by "things that changed the NHL," like the WHA. The top three would be solid in any order; the NHLPA's probably a little high, but that might be a generational gripe.
The 2004-05 Lockout at No. 5? Huh. The Miracle on Ice at No. 8? Double-huh.
There's no question the lockout ushered in an "NHL 2.0" of new economics and new rules. (Grigg doesn't even mention the shootout, which remains a fundamental and reprehensible change.) Here's Grigg:
The lockout single-handedly altered the face of the NHL. The economics of the game were drastically altered, in both the way franchises worked together and how they worked with the players; the salary cap was instituted; the on-ice game was changed with the elimination of the red line and a new standard for enforcing rules; and the NHLPA is still reeling from the effects of the power vacuum created by the ouster of former executive director Bob Goodenow.
The problem is that we're less than a decade removed from it, and we have another CBA negotiation on the horizon. Verdict: Too soon.
Blasphemous as it may seem, the Miracle on Ice at No. 8 is about right.
Grigg is right that it "awoke a nation to the game," but what did it change fundamentally? Gretzky had more to do with U.S. expansion, which in turn "awoke" more hockey markets than 1980 did. Plus, we have professional players in the Olympics 30 years after the amateurs stunned the Soviets.
It's one of the greatest hockey moments of all-time; perhaps the greatest. But did the Miracle on Ice change the game like goalie mask, the forward pass and the entry draft did?
Puck Daddy is an NHL blog edited by Greg Wyshynski. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Washington 4, Montreal 3 (Nov. 28)
Posted Nov 27 2009
Dallas 4, Tampa Bay 3 (Nov. 28)
Posted Nov 27 2009
Vancouver 7, Edmonton 3 (Nov. 28)
Posted Nov 27 2009
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by E. Brennan
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Andy Behrens
136 Comments
1 - 24 of 136
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
WIN
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
now, its waaaaaay before any of our times, but that rover and forward pass rule is huge, think about the difference in how the game is played!
how about the butterfly style of goaltending. put Ovechkin in the NHL 30+ yrs ago and he'd score 15 goals/game!
End of the day, $$ has had the biggest effect on the game. Yes, i think Orr was one of the greatest ever. but put him and his build into todays game... does he do the same thing? Players are bigger, stronger, faster and this is b/c they TRAIN for hockey, which is b/c they get paid more, which means they don't have to work another job. This isnt your grandfathers NHL by any means, and its not even your dad's NHL. God knows we wont see very many wendel clark's, theo fleury's, cam neely's anymore!
money speaks!
Report Abuse
As for the 2004-05 lockout, the economics of the game were changed, but the most obvious effect on the game came from all of the idiotic rule changes that have castrated the once great sport, making it easy for weak players to succeed. It's all about skating now. I want my old NHL back!!
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
OH... and by the way. If you count Canada's mens and women's teams - we've won gold 9 times in olympic history, Soviet Union 7 times, and US 3. Uh huh...
Report Abuse
#5 & #7 are part of the reason I'm ashamed to be half Canadian. All they ever do is b|tch and moan or talk sh|t about other people. Canadians really need to shut the fu
Report Abuse
#5 and #7 are part of the reason I'm ashamed to be half Canadian. All they ever do is b|tch and moan or talk sh|t about other people. Canadians really need to shut the fu
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
No. 108, maybe.
What discernible impact did it have other than we're stuck listening to crappy hockey players tell bad stories on the rubber-chicken circuit for 30 years.
To put it ahead of the Summit Series tells me whoever wrote that tripe doesn't have a clue, or has his Mike Eruzione ginch wound around his neck.
Report Abuse
Later, eh.
Report Abuse
I'm in Pittsburgh now...GO PENS!
And Kings....I rooted for Marcel Dionne, Charlie Simmer, Dave Taylor, Butch Goring, Rogie Vachon etc...
Report Abuse
1 - 24 of 136