Puck Daddy - NHL

In the 381 minutes and 13 seconds the Pittsburgh Penguins and Washington Capitals have played during their instant classic Eastern Conference semifinal series -- which ends with Game 7 tonight in D.C. -- stars Sidney Crosby(notes) and Alexander Ovechkin(notes) have only appeared on the ice together for just 28:57.

This isn't Ali and Frazier in the same ring, or Magic and Bird on the same court for most of the game. Their rivalry in this series is more akin to the one between Pacino and De Niro in Michael Mann's "Heat": The protagonist and antagonist are only face to face in two scenes, yet the intensity of their opposition propels the entire narrative.

The contrasting styles of the two players have been on display all series: The offensive flamboyance and physical play of Ovechkin against Crosby's incredible passing radar and fearless grit while hanging in goalie Simeon Varlamov's(notes) crease.

From Game 1 on, it's been their consistent gamesmanship that's cemented their personal rivalry and captivated sports fans; from die-hard puckheads all the way to Charles Barkley at the other end of the spectrum. Every shift demands attention, because there's no telling what these stars are going to do next.

In the glamour stats, Ovechkin leads in goals (7 to Crosby's 6) and assists (6 to Crosby's 4) for an overall lead in points (13 to Crosby's 10). He's also a plus-6 to Crosby's plus-3, for whatever that stat is worth.

But those numbers are only part of a larger statistic picture, which in turn only tells part of the story in this series: There's also game-by-game impact for Ovechkin and Crosby, like how they score and when they score.

Coming up, we look at Crosby vs. Ovechkin in the first six games of the series. But first, from what you've witnessed and based on the facts, which player has had the better series heading into tonight's Game 7?


Heading into Game 7, which player has had the better series?


Here's a look back at Crosby and Ovechkin through six. 

In weighing their performances, we also took into account that they play different positions; hence, Crosby contributes in the face-off circle more than Ovechkin would. The stats are from the official game summaries from each contest; see the end of the post for a key to the abbreviations.

Game 1: Washington 3, Pittsburgh 2 (May 2, Verizon Center)

Crosby opened the scoring at 4:09 of the first period on a wrist shot against Simeon Varlamov, who would later rob him with a now-legendary stick save. Ovechkin gave the Capitals the lead on a 5-on-3 power play, although Pittsburgh would later tie the game. While the merits of Ovechkin's 17 shots can be debated, Game 1 was a close battle between the two stars. Advantage: Even.

Game 2: Washington 4, Pittsburgh 3 (May 4, Verizon Center)

The one for the time capsule, as Crosby and Ovechkin trade the first career postseason hat tricks for both players. (A few too many hats fell for Sidney's liking.) Crosby opened the scoring with a power-play goal, Ovechkin answered, and then Crosby tallied again to give Pittsburgh the lead. With the score tied at 2-2 in the third, Ovechkin scored on the power play and then completed the hat trick 2:19 later to blow the roof off the arena. Crosby's hat trick would be completed on the power-play and with an extra attacker at 19:29.

Statistically and from an impact standpoint, it was Ovechkin's game; a dominating performance that actually elicited a "death threat" from a disgruntled Penguins fan on a message board. Ovechkin's effort in relation to Crosby led Mike Wise of the Washington Post to write: "The beauty, technical superiority and all-around productivity of Sid the Kid cannot yet match the unbridled aggression and fury of Ovie the Beast." Advantage: Ovechkin.

Game 3: Pittsburgh 3, Washington 2, OT (May 6, Mellon Arena)

Ovechkin scored 83 seconds into the game on a strange bounce and misplay by goalie Marc-Andre Fleury(notes) (video). He would later assist on Nicklas Backstrom's(notes) critical power-play goal to tie the game in the third. Crosby earned his two assists by getting a primary helper on Evgeni Malkin's(notes) power-play goal and then winning the faceoff on a set play in overtime, which led to Kris Letang's(notes) game-winning goal. Both players' numbers were affected by the parade of Capitals to the penalty box during the game. Advantage: Even.

Game 4: Pittsburgh 5, Washington 3 (May 8, Mellon Arena)

By far Ovechkin's most underwhelming game of the series, and one in which he injured Penguins defenseman Sergei Gonchar's(notes) knee with an irresponsible hit. His lone point came as a secondary assist on a Chris Clark(notes) goal in the second period. Crosby had the primary assist on Bill Guerin's(notes) tie-breaking goal in the first, and then potted his ninth of the playoffs at 4:16 of the third period. Not the best night for either player, but one was clearly better than the other. Advantage: Crosby.

Game 5: Pittsburgh 4, Washington 3, OT (May 9, Verizon Center)

And then it was Crosby's turn to have his weakest performance of the series, at least on paper: Zero points, a minus-2 and less than 40 percent in the faceoff circle. Although the captain did factor in on the game-winning goal by Malkin, going to the net hard to draw a pass that deflected off of Capitals defenseman Tom Poti(notes) for the goal.

Ovechkin rebounded impressively with two big game-tying goals (video), including one at 15:52 of the third period . He also had a secondary assist. Advantage: Ovechkin.

Game 6: Washington 5, Pittsburgh 4, OT (May 12, Mellon Arena)

Another instant classic with the Capitals facing elimination, and one in which Ovechkin's supporting cast power Washington to victory. He had three assists on the night (one primary, two secondary), including two on linemate Viktor Kozlov's(notes) goals, but Ovechkin didn't find the back of the net himself for only the second time in the series. Ovechkin silenced the already quiet crowd as he left the ice, but it was his teammates that did the talking. 

Crosby, meanwhile, assisted on Bill Guerin's first-period goal and scored a hard-working goal in the crease, on a second-effort, to tie the game at 15:42 of the third -- before David Steckel's deflection goal ended the game in overtime. Crosby skated well all night, creating several chances that were squandered by teammates. He had one less point than Ovechkin, but his goal was critical. Advantage: Crosby.

• • •

Agree to disagree on the assessments, but our scorecard has it two games for Ovechkin, two for Crosby and two ties. Games 2 and 5 were Ovechkin's signature moments; Crosby simply wouldn't allow the Penguins to lose in regulation in Game 6.

These teams, this series, this rivalry ... they've already given hockey fans more than we could have begged for during the first six games. And yet we have but one request for Game 7 tonight in D.C.:

Let one of these guys decide the series tonight. (Preferably without the benefit of a controversial penalty or a quirky deflection.)

Key: G=Goals A=Assists P=Points +/-=Plus/Minus PN=Number of Penalties PIM=Penalty Minutes TOI=Time On Ice SHF=# of Shifts AVG=Average Time/Shift S=Shots on Goal A/B=Attempts Blocked MS=Missed Shots HT=Hits Given GV=Giveaways TK=Takeaways BS=Blocked Shots FW=Faceoffs Won FL=Faceoffs Lost F%=Faceoff Win Percentage PP=Power Play SH=Short Handed EV=Even Strength OT=Overtime TOT=Total.

digg delicious
more

267 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. redemption_value
    1. Posted by redemption_value Wed May 13, 2009 10:58 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Fluery has to have "thee great game" to give the Pens the edge. Sid and Geno are relentless and will need to be tonight but Fluery has to really stand up. He has to see this game as defining himself on the larger stage of history. Who is he going to be. He has to get the Tiger Woods playing against history mentality. A "will not be denied" game.
  2. Brad_HT
    2. Posted by Brad_HT Wed May 13, 2009 11:02 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    first?
    Crosby clearly has had more of an impact, even if its just in the leadership role
  3. Pensfan
    3. Posted by Pensfan Wed May 13, 2009 11:03 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm a Pens fan, and even I see that Ovie is having a better series. I think, however Crosby's goals have been more critical. But the fact that Ovie's hat trick overshadowed Sid's and that he has more points says it all. But I don't really care who plays better. I just care who wins the game tonight. Thus my inability to do any work today....this is my first game 7 as a die-hard Pens fan (I wasn 11 yrs old in 2001), and I can't take it!!
  4. btumpak
    4. Posted by btumpak Wed May 13, 2009 11:04 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    solid recap of the series. pretty much on point. tonight will decide.
    game se7en.
  5. david p
    5. Posted by david p Wed May 13, 2009 11:05 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    while they have been fairly equal. alex ovechkin has had the better series.
  6. JohnB
    6. Posted by JohnB Wed May 13, 2009 11:05 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Yeah, I was hoping for a push option there. Both guys have been great.
  7. Pensfan
    7. Posted by Pensfan Wed May 13, 2009 11:06 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    @1, I'm not worried about Fleury. The last two times the Pens face elimination (in Games 5 and 6 of the SCF) he played OUT OF HIS MIND! He was the sole reason we won game 5 (he blocked 55 of 58 shots) and he was the only reason we lost by 1 goal in Game 6. And all of this was after he had an awful beginning to the series. I expect to see Fleury the superstar tonight.
  8. Bleed
    8. Posted by Bleed Wed May 13, 2009 11:08 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    they've both played amazing this series
  9. Wyshynski
    9. Posted by Wyshynski Wed May 13, 2009 11:11 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    @ JohnB --
    There can be only one!
  10. BC Caps
    10. Posted by BC Caps Wed May 13, 2009 11:12 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Nice timing on the article. I just posted on the 3-stars one asking why Crosby's ahead of Ovechkin in the Conn Smythe watch. Maybe you should check what that award is for. Imaging taking each player away from his team and then think what would happen. Who would be missed more? (By the team, not you personally)
  11. NostraChronus
    11. Posted by NostraChronus Wed May 13, 2009 11:15 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    not only is this not Ali versus Frazier or Magic versus Bird, it's only the second round.
  12. Jon A
    12. Posted by Jon A Wed May 13, 2009 11:16 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm sorry, personally I hate it when people make comments like this, but you just can't ignore...Crosby's face looks like a 10-year old. I know that means nothing regarding skills, but I just can't get over how baby-faced he is.
  13. DarkHorseCards
    13. Posted by DarkHorseCards Wed May 13, 2009 11:17 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    the lesser-reported "playoff beard" stat is definitely leaning in ov's favor.
  14. dingledangle
    14. Posted by dingledangle Wed May 13, 2009 11:17 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    i prefer ovie, but sid has had more clutch goals this series
    actually, i prefer fedorov, but that's irrelevant...
  15. .................................................!
    15. Posted by .................................................! Wed May 13, 2009 11:18 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Ovechkin by a hair, which has been split into two, because Crosby is also an absolute beast. This coming from a Caps fan.
  16. ontherockz72
    16. Posted by ontherockz72 Wed May 13, 2009 11:19 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Great series! Great for hockey! Great players!
    GO BRUINS!!!!!
    You ever hear of this young kid the Bruins have?? Milan Lucic, I believe is his name.
  17. Wilf
    17. Posted by Wilf Wed May 13, 2009 11:20 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    On the subject of offensive performance, you've got to give the nod to Ovechkin, says this Penguins fan, simply because he's managed to produce so much offense despite being game-planned against. Rob Scuderi's probably cut his opportunities in half, and still he's scoring at a brisk pace. Sid hasn't had the same focused game plan against his line, in part because the Caps can't really put an operation shutdown on two lines.
    Of course, Ovechkin doesn't play any defense, so his contributions there really aren't worth talking about, though it's tough to argue when his plus/minus is a little better. Crosby's done some great work down low in the defensive end.
  18. miah
    18. Posted by miah Wed May 13, 2009 11:21 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    BC Caps, by your estimation, the one that SHOULD be leading the Conn Smythe is not OV or Sid, but Varlamov. He is the ONLY reason that OV has had more than 4 games to put up the numbers he has. They wouldn't have won a game w/o him.
  19. habs1rule
    19. Posted by habs1rule Wed May 13, 2009 11:22 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Ovies, by a little..Since they're cancelling each other out, the series rest on the shoulders of the "Foot soldiers'. somebody on a third or fourth line scores the winner, just watch.. Mateau Matteau, Matteau!!
  20. SeanO
    20. Posted by SeanO Wed May 13, 2009 11:22 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    edge goes to the fact that ovie has a playoff beard....crosby just cut hair off the top and glued it on
  21. themizzi
    21. Posted by themizzi Wed May 13, 2009 11:23 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Ovechkin is better, much more fun to watch, does everything.
    Crosby crashes the net well and makes good passes, doesnt hit, and whines the entire time. He's not better.
  22. Bleed
    22. Posted by Bleed Wed May 13, 2009 11:23 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    @jon a: it's ok, because ovechkin looks like he'd be trying to give "candy" to a 10 year old from the back of his van... nothing about his skill, just saying
    saving money with geico, so easy ovechkin can do it
  23. miah
    23. Posted by miah Wed May 13, 2009 11:23 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Jon A, since when was facial hair an indicator of a persons greatness or character (or lack thereof). In other words, who gives a crap?
  24. miah
    24. Posted by miah Wed May 13, 2009 11:25 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Also, our Wysh's have been granted...another Crosby vs. OV article...but this time it's actually meaningful!
  25. Phil Wood
    25. Posted by Phil Wood Wed May 13, 2009 11:26 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Oh god - you did not just pull a Highlander reference did you Wysh? You just sank into the deep nether regions of pure geekdom. That said, I hold monthy conferences there. ;-)
    It's tough to pick. Crosby has shown such competitiveness and leadership. Flashy he is not, but the amount of strength and skill that goes into being the guy behind and at the net can never be understated. He has twice scored by batting the puck out of the air in these playoffs - remarkable. But, I think some of the success here has to go that his team has also woken up and that can also be attributed to him.
    Ovechkin however has been the pulse of his team. If you take both players off, I don't think Washington has the swagger of Pittsburgh. Varlamov has saved them many nights, but AO has got them going with his flashy play. Stats or no, I think Ovechkin has been better and the only blemish is game four.
    However, we still have game 7.

Puck Daddy

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Greg Wyshynski

Puck Daddy is an NHL blog edited by Greg Wyshynski. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Puck Daddy Recent Readers

Watch Live Hockey Online with GameCenter Live™