Smith now 49ers starting quarterback

  • Print

SANTA CLARA, Calif. (AP)—Alex Smith is getting a big chance to resurrect his career. All but forgotten, the former No. 1 overall pick is the San Francisco 49ers’ new starting quarterback—again.

“I don’t know if I’d say surprised. I don’t know if I was anticipating it, either,” Smith said Monday after getting the news from coach Mike Singletary. “It’s the opportunity I’ve been waiting for; happy.”

Singletary made the announcement Monday after also sitting down with Shaun Hill(notes), who was benched after the first half of the Niners’ a 24-21 loss at Houston on Sunday.

Smith, who hadn’t played in nearly two years, came in and gave the offense a much-needed jolt of energy and efficiency, and he nearly led San Francisco (3-3) back from a 21-0 deficit.

“As far as will Shaun Hill be back and all this other stuff, we’re not going to be a flavor-of-the-month kind of thing where, ‘Let’s see, this guy will be this week, this guy will be next week,”’ Singletary said. “I wanted to make the decision based upon who I feel gives us the best chance to win.”

Smith completed his first six passes and finished 15 of 22 for 206 yards and three touchdown passes to tight end Vernon Davis(notes). Davis is the first 49er since Terrell Owens(notes) in 2001 to have three TD catches in a game.

The 49ers play at Indianapolis on Sunday, coincidentally the same team Smith debuted against in 2005. This will be his first start since Nov. 12, 2007.

“I think right now overall Alex Smith really just kind of fit the bill in terms of doing the things that we need to get done,” Singletary said.

Smith, the No. 1 draft pick out of Utah in 2005, missed all of last season after reinjuring his surgically repaired throwing shoulder three days before the season opener. He was set to be the backup to J.T. O’Sullivan(notes).

When this season began, Singletary decided Hill was the best man behind center for San Francisco, a franchise desperate to end a streak of six straight losing seasons.

The 25-year-old Smith has shown signs in practice of being more than ready to handle this role. It was Smith who spent several days during the recent bye week working with receiver and top draft pick Michael Crabtree(notes) to get him up to speed on the offense before his debut against the Texans. Crabtree, who finally signed his six-year deal Oct. 7, had five catches in an impressive first game.

Singletary, who insisted his decision wasn’t “premeditated,” sensed a positive vibe from everybody—save maybe for Hill—with Smith’s calm, confidence presence on the field. Not that Singletary didn’t have a feeling Smith could take charge of his unit and lead the team again after all he’s been through.

Singletary has seen Smith’s strides in recent months.

“Let him develop that hunger, let him get excited, ‘Well if I get an opportunity again.’ Let him develop some confidence, ‘I think I can do that,”’ Singletary said of the time Smith needed to evolve. “Rather than just putting him in at the beginning of the season and if you don’t have success right away, then it’s, ‘Same old Alex.’ I don’t think it’s the same old Alex. I think Alex has matured, I think he’s grown and I think he’s ready to play. We’re going to find out. We’ll find out next week.”

Not that Smith needed any more motivation: He knew he’d better take advantage if he ever got another opportunity. He knows he’s done more to earn his spot this time around than as a rookie.

He doesn’t plan to change now. And he no longer thinks about his shoulder.

“I’ve been out for two years now. I don’t know if I was getting any hungrier,” Smith said. “I’ve kind of been waiting. It’s been frustrating and I’ve got a chance to get back out there and make the most of it.”

Hill began the season as a starter for the first time in his eight-year NFL career and led the 49ers to a 3-1 start. He lost his job Monday a year to the day after Singletary benched O’Sullivan in favor of Hill during the coach’s debut against the Seahawks.

Hill struggled in the first half Sunday, when San Francisco had only 50 total yards and he was 6 of 11 for 45 yards.

“It’s frustrating. It’s upsetting,” Hill said. “It’s not going to keep me down. Nothing ever has, nothing ever will. It’s the same thing he went through and it didn’t hold him down, either.”

Texans defensive end Mario Williams(notes) said he didn’t know who Smith was when the QB came out to start the second half. That’s how far he had fallen off the NFL radar.

“When I look at Alex, I really didn’t know what we were going to get when he went in,” Singletary said. “I was hoping we’d get what we’ve seen out here in practice, and that’s what we got. I was excited to see that, the excitement and the enthusiasm on the sideline, the excitement and enthusiasm on the defensive side of the ball, the receivers, the running backs, everybody.”

Updated Oct 26, 7:29 pm EDT
digg del.icio.us
more

308 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. PitBull
    308. Posted by PitBull Tue Oct 27 11:40pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    wait F.a.g. on the play
    I have a buddy that's wife knows football.. she ant so hot!!! kindof burley.........
  2. PitBull
    307. Posted by PitBull Tue Oct 27 11:34pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    But if you want I will log back in as my Wife and whisper sweet nutn's to you... cuz you are going to need it after the Cards rematch!!!!!! or at a minimum a tums.....But I dont blame you a Girl that knows FootBall what a catch!!!!!!
  3. PitBull
    306. Posted by PitBull Tue Oct 27 11:28pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Q
    hahaha to funny I figured you would need to say something ultra manly lol
    Thanks but no thanks....
  4. Nicholas
    305. Posted by Nicholas Tue Oct 27 9:16pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I still rock the Smith Jersey!!! He's had a terrible upbringing, No O line, No wide outs 4 differnt O corrdinators. A ruff start. He has what he needs now a chance and maturity. with a little bit of talent around him now he should do well!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 9ers all day!!!!
  5. Q
    304. Posted by Q Tue Oct 27 8:23pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Yo PitBull,

    That was really gross.. finding out you're a Man..

    But maybe you'd like to watch me with Tonya sometime..?!
  6. 49er Faithful
    303. Posted by 49er Faithful Tue Oct 27 6:56pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    You know what's kind of overlooked and no one has mentioned is that during that ATL game it was VERY interesting to note that Crabtree was seen on the sidelines talking to Alex Smith.... and during that week and the bye week they were practicing together.... now I'm not saying that Crabs had anything to do w/ this..... but as a WR wouldn't you want someone that feels comfortable throwing to you at QB than someone who already has his favorite targets?????

    With that said I hope Alex doesn't always lock in on Crabs as his target and instead just looks at his options or reads and sees what options are available. If its Crabs then throw it to him and I'm sure he'll take it to the house before the season is over but for now just focus on moving the chains!!

    Alex I have faith in you this time. The first time around it seemed like too much was placed on him without being given any tools to work with!! This time hopefully he has something to work with.... However, one thing that hasn't changed is the O-LINE!!

    Man somehow SF's gotta do better in protecting the QB and opening holes for Gore!!!!! Someone earlier said it.... why not WRAGGE!!
  7. monty
    302. Posted by monty Tue Oct 27 6:54pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    All I am saying did anyone see Frank Gore WIDE WIDE OPEN nobody in front of him on the last play of the game....TYPICAL ALEX HE THROWS TO A FRIGGIN CROWD.....five Texans were around his ball, no niner near the ball at all....BAD timing, bad decision typical Alexscuse...

    One mistake is all it takes to lose in the NFL

    Smith is not the answer

    Offensive Coordinator is terrible, 3 winning seasons out of 12
    Offensive Line is swiss cheese
    Pass Rusher is not anywhere on this team

    These are GLARING concerns....
  8. MatthewM
    301. Posted by MatthewM Tue Oct 27 6:46pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Alright, I bleed red and gold but I'm going to give it to ya'll straight and objective. Is Smith better than Hill? If by better you mean he can pass more accurately and make more NFL throws? Then yes he definitely is.

    Smith's problem has always been mental (possibly brought on by being throw to the wolves as a rook, other than David Carr I've never seen a QB get hit so much his first couple of years). In the past he's had a tendency to make bad passing decisions and put the ball on the turf.

    He looked real sharp in the game last Sunday, but I'm not sold on whether his success came from the Texan D loosening up a bit having a big lead, the Texan D not scheming for the spread offense they set Smith up in, or that he's better than Hill. In any case, we have to start Smith, Coach Singletary doesn't have a choice. The guy came in and threw three TD's (all to Vernon...) and Hill hasn't thrown one last week or in the first half.

    The real problem is the defense specifically the secondary... Owen Daniels shredding us for 100yds and 2 Td's at half? Roddy White is one thing but we have to be able to cover a tight end. Alarming to say the least.

    Big Mike, we got a little bit of pressure on Schaub and got to him a bit but he's a Pro Bowl type guy, our secondary has got to take care of business. Crappy play calling in the first half and no coverage lost us that game.
  9. JM Silk
    300. Posted by JM Silk Tue Oct 27 6:35pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't know if this is a good time to put Alex in. Not that he doesn't deserve it, but the timing. The 49ers will lose their 3rd straight game when they lose to the Colts this weekend. I hope his confidence doesn't go down because of how he's going to play. Let's face it, the Colts will eat him alive. With today's news that Pachos out because of injury, the Offensive line just got weaker. The "O" line was already in trouble, and now with a starter gone, it makes it that much worse. Let's see how he plays now that the opposing team knows that he is going to be the starter and the have a game plan on how to stop him. And another thing, Jimmy Raye has to be very creative this week to even have a chance to beat the Colts...
  10. joseph
    299. Posted by joseph Tue Oct 27 6:15pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    To post 295 - Alex Smith was behind JT and Shaun mostly because he had a injured shoulder the last two years. Not that he played well when he did but I think that was also a reflection of how bad the team around him was. If you payed attention to the game at all on sunday you would have noticed that the offense opened up with 4 and 5 receiver sets because of Alex's stronger arm which resulted in 21 points. To early to say he's going to be the guy but you have to admit that that was the best he has looked since hes been in the league. He made one mistake at the end of the game. Big f!@k'n deal. If he was playing for four quarters do you think that they still would of lost the game ? Alex has experience now, he's healthy, and he has more weapons then he has ever had. If he doesn't win now it will be on him. No excuses. Hope it works out for him and the Niners. GO NINERS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  11. Big Mike
    298. Posted by Big Mike Tue Oct 27 6:01pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I have always endorsed Alex Smith and if the field has finally slowed down for him look out NFL. But with that battered offensive line, thank God he can move around and throw on the run. S Hill could never do that, his foot had to be flat before he released the ball. I hope Singletary doesn't rely on Chilo this week-GEEZ GIVE TONY WRAGGE A CHANCE---rather than a overrated 2nd year player. Alex that was the Texans defense and Indy hasn't lost a game because they have a bad D. Alex last time you made yourself look like a fool against the Colts your rookie year-time for some redemption.


    ALSO WHERE IS THE PASS RUSH--CAN ANY OF OUR D LINEMAN STEP UP? PLEASE
  12. PitBull
    297. Posted by PitBull Tue Oct 27 5:35pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    villocents, and Q post 291.....
    Nah I will keep my bet..CARDS D was not jelling in the 1st game due to the new scheme and D coordinator...
    And Q I am not your type I am 5'10" 240 with 22" guns and I have twigs and Berry s..lol
    I do often post on my wife's account aka TONYA when Iforget to log her out and me in...lol
  13. erich
    296. Posted by erich Tue Oct 27 4:56pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I watch each 49er game and many times this year i have wanted hill pulled. He's painful to watch.

    I was so impressed by the velocity of Smiths throws. I never saw him just let it fly like this. And how about the command he showed? I was simply floored by this perfrmance and really wana know why they didn't turn to him last week vs ATL. Alex is just 25 years old and sunday may be the turning point of his career. I sure hope so.
  14. <i>villocents</i>
    295. Posted by villocents Tue Oct 27 4:25pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    # 226 (Tonya)

    go get your bet back! i will be at that game telling your old QB to go back and back groceries! you aint getting no wins from us this year, tweedy bird!
  15. monty
    294. Posted by monty Tue Oct 27 3:54pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Hey did you bozo's not see the last play of the game???

    He missed Gore on the sidelines all alone (Gore was flapping and waving his arms like crazy but Smith didn't see it at all!) , that would have gone for 20+ yards INSTEAD Smith threw into a crowd of Texans, there were 4-5 Texans right where he threw the ball!!!! TERRIBLE TERRIBLE

    Smith will stink it up...Niners season is done folks, give it up....

    Until they get a decent:

    Offensive Coordinator: Raye sucks
    Offensive Line: Its swiss cheese
    Pass Rusher: there is none

    There is a long season left and these 3 glaring problems still exhist, on top of that the schedule is getting tougher....

    I hope to see Nate Davis before long...
  16. Johnny
    293. Posted by Johnny Tue Oct 27 3:49pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I've been a 49ers fan since joe montana. The reason why they lost 2 striaght is because of carelessness!!!! Alex Smith had one good game, Wow!!! Doesnt mean he's the savior of the team. What they need to do is put Nate Davis in as Qb. And, I bet you the job will get done. Davis play like Steve Young. Another Steve young like as qb on 49ers will get the job done. Alex Smith not ready. Keep Hill till you can find a better QB. The Colts gonna kick our a$$ like the falcolns did, but worst I tell you. We shouldn't never lose to the Teaxes.
  17. who the hell?
    292. Posted by who the hell? Tue Oct 27 3:14pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Alex had a good game. 1 good game, after being selected number one a few years ago...and he finally has 1 good game - and you are all ready to crown him as the savior? Don't you think there was a reason why JT and Shaun played ahead of Alex for these past years? Don't you think if he could play like this, he would have been starting already?

    Alex Smith can throw the ball, unfortunately, he likes to throw the ball whether a player is covered or if the player has on a different jersey. I know what he can do when you allow him to throw, but he doesn't have the discipline to do it over the course of an entire game. Shaun might not have the dynamic abilities to play QB, but he's not going to kill you by fumbling, throwing interceptions, or throwing downfield on 3rd and short, when the underguy is open for an easy first down.

    Besides, Singletary likes running the ball and using standard sets, which wouldn't play towards Alex Smith's abilities. Basically, Singletary has to change who he is in order to accomodate the new quarterback. Sounds like the Niners (and Singletary) are still searching for an identity.
  18. Lind
    290. Posted by Lind Tue Oct 27 3:00pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    This is the sign that the world is coming 2 an end. Confess all your sins. Alex Smith should be in jail for fraud and theft, he stole 80 mil for the Niners.
  19. Monquitta
    289. Posted by Monquitta Tue Oct 27 2:40pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I agree with 276. I am a real 49ers fan. I have been by these boys for 20yrs. good bad and ugly. I hope Singletary knows what he is doing and the rest of the team step up and help the qb out. The qb can't do it all by himslf. GO 49ers.
  20. Q
    288. Posted by Q Tue Oct 27 2:20pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Tonya... #s 227, 229, 233... Um.. err.. Are you married..?

    Don't Fret ..49er/Hill Fan... Indy will crunch Smith, and Hill will be back out there leading the team down the field like he did before.

    Like he did against the Seattle SeaGals, and the Lambs, like he did in Minnesota, and yes, sorry Tonya my Luv... Like He Did in Da ZONA..! (btw all super tough away venues!)

    Folks, least not forget the Sunday night game in Arizona last year. Where Hill did an end around to the left side, got hit by three huge Zona defenders (Helmit Ripped Off Of Head), and still lunged four extra yards for the first down.

    If I see the ball slip outta Smith's hand (while going back to pass) one more time.. EVER.. I'm throwing my boot threw the television..!

    Hill's My Guy..!

    Niners Fan..
  21. Stephan G
    287. Posted by Stephan G Tue Oct 27 2:13pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    and to think.. they coulda had rogers
  22. 49er Faithful
    286. Posted by 49er Faithful Tue Oct 27 1:35pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    PS I think SF's special teams and defense scored 21 of those 35 points!!!!!!!!!!!
  23. 49er Faithful
    285. Posted by 49er Faithful Tue Oct 27 1:34pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I wonder if Jimmy Raye ever played Madden? Some of the offensive schemes this year have been really poor. There has not been one game so far this season that I've said WOW what a great game plan. Even in the 35-0 game against STL that game plan was weak..... I think SF was only up 7-0 against the winnless Rams at the half!!!!

    Jimmy Ray sucks man. One day we need a QB that will need to say the hell w/ the play-call, look at the defense and call a freakin audible like Manning does on 9/10 plays!!!!!!!!!
  24. CL337
    284. Posted by CL337 Tue Oct 27 1:31pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I never gave up on A. Smith he was the former #1 pick after all and I also knew eventually he'll start again. There has to be a reason for that. How are you gonna pick a 3rd round draft pick like Hill over a former 1st rounder like Smith? Last sunday showed us that. Shaun Hill held the ball too long and couldn't convert a 3rd down many time or complete a good pass on this sucky Texans team. Alex showed us the excitment again. As for the last few years it's not Alex's fault. Nolan didn't know what he was doing. Didn't have any supporting cast and he was stupid enough to actually believed J.T.O could be a starter. That's why he lost his job. Singletary is a good coach I believe that the teams trust him enough to listen. He just have that charisma. Go 49ers!
Sign in to post a comment, or sign up for a free account

Video Spotlight