Shutdown Corner - NFL

Boy, this Brandon Marshall(notes) thing escalated quickly. This really got out of hand fast. Just a few days ago, Brandon Marshall's discontent rated about a three-and-a-half on the interesting scale, and was something you maybe wanted to keep an eye on for later.

Yesterday, though, things jumped up a notch. All the sudden, Marshall's agent says the team has agreed to trade him, and Marshall's saying his goodbyes to the city of Denver on his website. Somewhere, Jay Cutler's(notes) watching this unfold and thinking, "I wish it was that easy when I did it."

Here's Marshall's farewell to the troops:

To whom it may concern. Life is filled with change, and where I am in my life now change is probably best. It’s hard leaving an organization ran by one of the best owners in all of sports, and someone who’s been there for me through my ups and downs. The hardest thing was hearing Mr. B wish me luck in the future, but we both came to the conclusion that this is probably the best thing for me to grow on and off the field.

I thank the Denver fans who embraced my emotion and play on the field and showing me love every time I step outside my door.

I should note, though, that head coach Josh McDaniels says he expects to see Marshall at training camp. So either someone's not telling the truth, or there's a bit of a disconnect between Broncos ownership and McDaniels. I would really hope, for the Broncos' sake, that the latter isn't true, given the magnitude of these decisions.

Anyway, it seems like Marshall is pretty close to gone, which I still think is a bad deal for the Broncos (here's some disagreement). With a guy like Marshall, whose on-field production is unmatched, but who also has shown an inability to co-exist with our nation's laws, you just can't get equal value for him in a trade. History has proven that dabbling in criminal behavior seriously lowers your trade value.

Look at it this way: If the Broncos pay Marshall and hang onto him, one of two things happens: He either stays healthy and out of handcuffs and is an extremely productive player, or he ends up suspended or in court again, in which case, the Broncos don't get the value they should.

If the Broncos trade Marshall, though, they also don't get the value they should. Period.

So the only possible way to maximize what you get from him is to roll the dice, keep him around, and hope you get the best out of him. In any other scenario, the Broncos lose.

digg delicious
more

132 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. jerloma
    1. Posted by jerloma Wed Jun 17, 2009 9:53 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    His on-field production is unmatched? There's about a dozen guys who might take issue with that.
  2. freezy
    2. Posted by freezy Wed Jun 17, 2009 9:54 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    hed have a bad year anyway with kyle orton as the qb....i wouldnt be surprised to see him in a bears uniform next season to team up with cutler again - maybe for a first or second round pick...
  3. experienced Commish
    3. Posted by experienced Commish Wed Jun 17, 2009 9:55 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Just swap him for Anquan and mke them both happy!
  4. bob hope
    4. Posted by bob hope Wed Jun 17, 2009 10:08 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I got an idea...trade him. History has proven that bad people make bad teammates and that makes for a bad team. It's ridiculous to think that throwing more money at him is gonna change him. If what he's earning now wasn't inspiration enough to clean up his act than he doesn't deserve any more money. NFL players are some of the biggest scum bags these days.
  5. The Man
    5. Posted by The Man Wed Jun 17, 2009 10:10 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I really hope the Redskins make a play for him. They could really use a big target for Zorn's offense. Can you imagine how productive Santana Moss would be as a #2? This would be one case where I'd actually be happy that Snyder is willing to deal draft picks.
  6. dennis b
    6. Posted by dennis b Wed Jun 17, 2009 10:14 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    THANKS A BUNCH BOWLEN! this offseason has been the biggest clusterf**ck i can remember i can ever remember seeing in denver.
    BOWLEN HAS SET US BACK AT LEAST 5-7 YRS!
    THANKS FOR NOTHING JERK!
  7. Scott E
    7. Posted by Scott E Wed Jun 17, 2009 10:15 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    #3 - Anquan is far more valuable then this turd. His picture says it all (except for the violent I feel the need to punch a female part). LOL
  8. Jay M
    8. Posted by Jay M Wed Jun 17, 2009 10:18 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    trade him to the Jets
  9. Scott E
    9. Posted by Scott E Wed Jun 17, 2009 10:20 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    #5 - We would still need a QB. I would rather see if the receivers we have pan out this year than take a chance on this guy. I really don't want to see him come out on the high side of this. Bronco management needs to clean house of these losers and I bet they will be in good shape in just a couple of years, not 5-7 dennis b.
  10. Whitney H
    10. Posted by Whitney H Wed Jun 17, 2009 10:20 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Fumbles. 18 on target, dropped passes. Have a nice life, suspension, jail time or whatever brandon. we dont want you, or t.o., or ocho cinco, or any other punk ass receiver that thinks he's bigger than the game.
  11. Daniel S
    11. Posted by Daniel S Wed Jun 17, 2009 10:22 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Here's a thought - trade him, reallocate some of that money you would have paid him to one or multiple other players, and then you GET EQUAL TRADE VALUE.
    Is this difficult? jeebus.
  12. heat1039
    12. Posted by heat1039 Wed Jun 17, 2009 10:32 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    im sorry mcdaniels but your not doing a very good job, lets see what you have done with my broncos since you showed up... traded a 4000+ yard passer, looking to trade our #1 reciever, refuse to pay someone who deserves money AND havent made any forward progress with the team. Way to go buddy
  13. madgame69
    13. Posted by madgame69 Wed Jun 17, 2009 10:34 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Hey dennis b....you can take your fair weather fan act to Chicago or where ever that girlfriend beater Marshall lands. Cutler didn't want to play here. Marshall doesn't want to play here. Ok guys, then get the "f**k" out and don't let the door hit you in the @ss on the way out. If those two whiney little b**ches don't want to be part of the the Broncos TEAM, then we don't want them here. These two situations should prove to everyone just how far things had slipped away from Shanahan. Shanahan would never have put up with this type of Primadona attitude, when he really had a controlling grasp of the Broncos. The personal character these two jokers have displayed (or not displayed), shows just how far the best coach in Denver Broncos history had let things slip away. The Broncos record this year may not reflect it, but they will be a better team in 2009 than they were in 2008.
  14. renko30
    14. Posted by renko30 Wed Jun 17, 2009 10:36 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    @ MJD - Nice job sneaking those Anchorman quotes in there in the first couple of paragraphs. All it needed was the line about killing a guy with a trident.
  15. Cephlon E
    15. Posted by Cephlon E Wed Jun 17, 2009 10:41 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Talk about spring cleaning. If he does get traded it will be to the NFC.
  16. Buck
    16. Posted by Buck Wed Jun 17, 2009 10:41 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I wonder where Leroy W is right now...now that the Broncos apparently made no move for Greg Ellis (the subject of Leroy's man-crush), and now, Bowlen is running the best remaining offensive player out of town. Bowlen and McDaniels have officially taken this team from 're-tooling' mode, into all-out 'rebuilding' mode. They've set us back a LOT more than 5-7 years...try 45-50 years, when lopsided losing records were the norm for the Broncos...and they will be for a few years to come.
  17. battousai
    17. Posted by battousai Wed Jun 17, 2009 11:00 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Just trade him for m.vick
  18. JohnnyFootballHero
    18. Posted by JohnnyFootballHero Wed Jun 17, 2009 11:11 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    ccsnyder69 -dude, don't take it so personally. it's not that cutler and marshall don't want to be in denver playing for the broncos, it's that they don't want to play for mcdaniels. do you see the difference? because it's a big one.
    mcdaniels is the problem here - these guys aren't trying to stick it to broncos fans, they want out of a lousy work situation. you need to redirect your anger at the problem rather than the outcomes. marshall is right to be upset about his contract and he knows after the way mcdaniels dealt with cutler that he too could find his way to another contender. let's face it - denver's D makes them a few years away from being SB contenders. washington and chicago both have better odds.
  19. Bret Farrve
    19. Posted by Bret Farrve Wed Jun 17, 2009 11:12 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Great! who is gonna catch my passes when i come to denver?
  20. jeremyvillano
    20. Posted by jeremyvillano Wed Jun 17, 2009 11:13 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Buck: "They've set us back a LOT more than 5-7 years...try 45-50 years, when lopsided losing records were the norm for the Broncos...and they will be for a few years to come."
    Thanks for illustrating why coaches and GMs don't take advice from fans. BTW, the Broncos were founded in 1960, so technically speaking, as of today, they didn't exist 50 years ago.
    In 2008, Marshall lead the league in drops, and had only 6 TDs despite being the #1 receiver in a pass happy offense (and ultimately ranked 16th in scoring). He also had 4 fumbles, losing 3. He continues to suffer from nerve damage in his arm (which he says caused the drops, which means the drops will continue), is still recovering from hip surgery, and may still be suspended for his latest of 13 run ins with Johnny Law. I'd say the Baby TO analogy was accurate, except that TO scored a lot more for an equal level of non-stop headache. And that's just SO FAR. What happens next month? Next season?
    For the members of the Shanahan Cult: Mike used to say what made TD great was that the man had his best games in the biggest games. Marshall appears to be the opposite. I'll be sad to see him go (if he does), but he's also still got a lot to learn and grow, which may or may not happen.
    P.S. The trades to Chicago are funny. With what picks? The rumor is the asking price is a 1st and a 3rd. The trades for Boldin are likely equally off-base. Why would the Cards pay Marshall to be a #2 (more like #1b) what they are unwilling to pay Boldin to do the same?
  21. battousai
    21. Posted by battousai Wed Jun 17, 2009 11:15 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    We let go of any ok players so lets buy the bad guys that done there time like plaxico or vick
  22. brick
    22. Posted by brick Wed Jun 17, 2009 11:18 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Wow, I don't think that Brandon is negotiating from a position of strength. Bronco management/ownership is in total disarray. Why would McWantabeabigboycoach want him now? All the Broncos are going to be within a year is a tax write off for Bowlen. The Bronco organization isn't just sinking fast, all that left now is an oil slick.
  23. Mike D
    23. Posted by Mike D Wed Jun 17, 2009 11:18 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Come too the giants!!! the jets are finding themselves with a rookie qb. the giants have the best o-line in the nfl, a top 5 d-fense in the nfl, a superbowl winning qb, a 260 lb 1000 yd rusher, and 4 young receivers. i say the giants trade hixon, manningham, and a first round draft. then you have marshall, nicks, smith, barden, and moss. line up marshall and barden on the outside and run nicks in the slot!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! woooooooooooo hoooooooooooo! i can see it now......superbowl champs 2009!!! go g-men!!!!!!!
  24. tomkc07
    24. Posted by tomkc07 Wed Jun 17, 2009 11:24 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Nice work with the Anchorman references. Go bleep yourself, San Diego!
  25. PaPInstripes
    25. Posted by PaPInstripes Wed Jun 17, 2009 11:31 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Have a question...help me out.....if Cutler wanted out of Denver and got his wish...and if Marshall wants out of Denver and gets his wish...who will want out of Denver next...???? But even more importantly.....WHY do these guys want out of Denver ?????

Shutdown Corner

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

MJD

Shutdown Corner is an NFL blog edited by Matthew J. Darnell. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Shutdown Corner Recent Readers