Shutdown Corner - NFL

You'll get no argument from me that the government has more important things to worry about than professional football. The war, the economy, health care, all of that stuff. It's all infinitely more important than football. Obviously.

However, 100 years from now, when your children's children's children are reading their digital history books, I doubt there's going to be any chapter that reads, "The United States lost the war on terror and crumbled as a nation, and all of that could have been avoided if only Arlen Specter had not spent that hour-and-a-half with NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell."

I honestly think that the issue at hand is a big enough deal to warrant a Senator's involvement. Again, I agree that the government has more important things to worry about than football. But it's not like the entire Senate is taking two weeks to debate a pass interference call. It's not like we've got a government shutdown so all of our politicians can work on passing a bill that prohibits the Lions from taking another wide receiver in the 1st round of the draft.

We're talking about a major corporation selling a fraudulent product. The NFL is a huge corporate monolith that sells a product to the public. And if there's a chance that that product is fraudulent, and is not the honest and fair competition the NFL purports it to be, I say that's a big deal.

If you're selling something--especially if you enjoy an antitrust exemption granted by the government--that something has to be what you say it is.

Imagine there was a major food company, and the government said to them, "Yes, it's OK if you're the only major food company in the country, and you shut everyone else down." And say that food company was selling cereal that claimed to be 100% whole grain, but was actually composed of 30% pencil shavings and 20% scrap metal. You'd want to know, right? You'd want to know that what they were peddling wasn't what they claimed it to be.

Granted, watching someone cheat at football isn't quite as damaging as eating a half-a-pound of pencil shavings every morning, but I still want to know when I'm being lied to.

And I think the level of government involvement here is appropriate. So far, it's been one 90-minute meeting with one Senator. It's not like baseball, where we're dedicating a whole day of public hearings and wasting hours of everyone's time because we want to hear about Roger Clemens' ass-bleeding and his wife showing off her fake jubblies, with no new information coming out.

It's been one Senator, and one meeting. That's all we've had so far. And that one meeting produced at least a few facts that we didn't already know.

If I could choose how Arlen Specter spent his time, and the choices were A) find the best way to get our troops home safely, B) make health care available to everyone, or C) find out just how much the Patriots cheated, obviously, I'd choose A or B.

However, A and B really weren't options, were they? Can the Senator do that by himself? I'd like to think that if Specter could accomplish either of those in 90 minutes, he'd have done it by now.

The more realistic choices for how Specter spent that time would be A) find out just how much the Patriots cheated, or B) nap. And in that case, I'll take A.

digg delicious
more

544 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Brave Sir Robin
    1. Posted by Brave Sir Robin Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:39 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't know, I think you're underestimating the value of naps.
  2. Ralph
    2. Posted by Ralph Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    well said, sir.
  3. WhiskerBiscuits
    3. Posted by WhiskerBiscuits Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Indeed - very well said.
  4. Robert
    4. Posted by Robert Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:57 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    You destroy evidence to hide something plain and simple. Goddell knew the tapes would prove the Patriots cheated since 2000. When you have video on your opponent and your opponent doesn't have video on your team its an enormous advantage. All you have to do watch the formations and you know the play that will be ran. Its much easier to defend a play that you know is coming. Goddell should be fired along with Bellicheck.
  5. Philip S
    5. Posted by Philip S Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I think someone had a good point about all these hearings - why don't we just waterboard Roger Clemens and Tom Brady? Hell, we could put that on pay per view and I'm pretty sure we'd pay for a solid two to three hours in Iraq.
  6. XXX
    6. Posted by XXX Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:28 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    had the actual videotapes? needs more information?
    $$$ has always had more credibility than actual evidence. right OJ, R. Blake etc etc etc...
    oops!! did i just say that???!!!
    truth, justice and the almighty dollar, the american way!!!
  7. Dagblastit
    7. Posted by Dagblastit Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm sorry, but the more I hear about this, the more that comes out, the more it makes me feel that Bellichick and the Pats got off too easy on this.
    It makes me ask, "what else have they been doing that's against the league rules?" and why hasn't Belichick been suspended for a year or even banned? Taking a few 100,000 from a team as rich as the Pat's is a slap in the face, making them lose a first round draft choice when they have a better one up there is a farce. Wanna really hurt them? Take Belichick and suspend him for a year or two, take away their first days draft including those choices they got through trade and place a heavier salary cap on them for the next two years. Put the message out to the franchises that cheating will bring extremly harsh penalties and maybe nobody else will take that chance.
  8. FairlyHonestBob
    8. Posted by FairlyHonestBob Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:28 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Same [profane]e, different day.
  9. William F.
    9. Posted by William F. Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I totally agree with dabglastit. If the NFL rules on gambling results in a player or players being banned. Why is cheating which is also a rule treated differently. This team has won super bowls during a period that implies they spied on teams. Yet the NFL commissioner chooses to get rid of the evidence and fine the team a few dollars.It simply amazes me on the inconsistency among the Pro sports commissioners on how they deal with various infractions/rule violations. hmmmmmmmmmmm I wonder how the punishment is determined.
  10. Justacio
    10. Posted by Justacio Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    i totally agree with MJD's point about some government time being well spent on this. but i still feel like we (the fans and even politicians) are being a little naive here. i know there have been some NFL coaches and players who have spoken out on this, but in my mind there just hasn't been enough outrage within the league to convince me that other teams weren't also guilty of the same thing (although maybe not as brazenly as the Pats sideline video taping). are we really that sure the Pats were the only ones doing this? if not, then i say we move on and simply make sure it doesn't happen again.
  11. Patrick B
    11. Posted by Patrick B Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:08 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    So a business decides how to handle it's internal problems and a Senator decides to step in because he doesn't like how it's handled. There has been multiple accounts of illegal activities throughout the NFL's history (49's salary cap infringement, Shula's contract tampering, illgeal preseason practices) but a Senator has never gotten involved for those situations. He's specifically targetting the Patriots, and not investigating the entire league to find out if any other teams have engaged in these activities. If he wants a clean honest game, then why not go the distance and check on steroid use, or other allegations that have come up over the years?
  12. Jeblet
    12. Posted by Jeblet Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Why is this not the number one sports story today not only in the NFL but in all of sports?? I heard it on a local radio station yesterday in a town victimized by the Patriots twice a year. Belichick gets caught (and conceeds his guilt) once and it's a huge national story. He admits to doing it maybe 100 times and the national news media buries the story?? Follow the money...
  13. JZ
    13. Posted by JZ Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Arlen Specter is a dumb schmuck. (First of all, I'm not even a Pats fan.) I say that he is a dumb schmuck because it is so clear that he is investigating this so diligently because he is a die-hard Eagles fan and he is still bitter that they lost in the Super Bowl to the Pats. Also, I read somewhere that Specter maintains some type of financial interest in Comcast. Yes, the same Comcast that had the fight with the NFL Network at the end of the season regarding making good games available to the public. So, don't you think Specter feels like he has an axe to grind with the NFL? Of course he does. He looks like a big buffoon investigating this. The Pats were fined, tapes destroyed..what's done is done. If it happened again then maybe it justifies some involvement, but he looks ridiculous doing what he's doing now.
  14. patshaterhater
    14. Posted by patshaterhater Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:52 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    You guys are all jealous. Get off your high horses. Congress should mind their own house first. How many of these idiots are swayed by mysterios contributions to their campaign funds. It's not like they're saints. Pats aren't the only ones "cheating". Clemens hearing was a big waste of time as well (though thoroughly entertaining).
  15. patshaterhater
    15. Posted by patshaterhater Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:52 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    you guys are all jealous. get off your high horses. congress should mind their own house first. how many of these idiots are swayed by mysterios contributions to their campaign funds. it's not like they're saints. pats aren't the only ones "cheating". clemens hearing was a big waste of time as well (though thoroughly entertaining).
  16. Thomas
    16. Posted by Thomas Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    the NFL needs to kick Belichick out of the NFL, strip the team of it's cheating gained titles, including the super bowl titles, and clean out the scum like this out of the NFL. playing stupid only works for blonds. he knew he was cheating since 2000. clean up the NFL. Brady's records should be eliminated from the league, because any quarterback will get great numbers when they know where the defensive player will be. There is a STRONG stench of POO, and it's in New England.
  17. Mike J
    17. Posted by Mike J Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:18 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Someone answer me this. If I take a test,I cheat on it but don't get caught and pass the test am I still considered a cheater? Or do I have to be caught to be considered a cheater? Anyone get my dirft?
  18. JT
    18. Posted by JT Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:57 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Really what the big deal, yes they taped the other team. The Pats got caught and punished for there acts. I think the smart thing would be to move on and make it known that cheating of any kind will be punished heavily. I do not think all of the Pats glory came from cheating at least i hope not.
  19. greeksjc
    19. Posted by greeksjc Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The Anti-trust exemption is no big deal and threats to rescind it by Congress would unlikely affect the NFL. Other leagues (like the World Football League) have failed in the past to compete with the NFL. Hence, if the accusations are true, the Patriots should be penalized, but by the League. A precedent was set this year with the fines and the loss of a first-round pick, when the Pats were caught cheating. If the findings are that they taped for the prior six years, similar fines and losses of future first-round draft picks should be implemented for every year the Pats cheated. Then we'll see if the Pats win any more Superbowls this decade. This can be handled by the commissioner without the involvement of Congress.
  20. Anonymous
    20. Posted by Anonymous Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:17 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Way off, MJD. Even if he can't single-handedly solve any of the more pressing problems of the nation, every minute that he wastes investigating the NFL is a minute that he could be spending contributing to finding a solution to any of those other problems. Your analogy between the quality of the NFL product and the quality of a food product is laughable, at best. You're more than welcome to your opinion. But I highly doubt that most Americans (let alone participants in your blogs) will agree with you.
    Please, find something better to do with your time, Specter. This country has bigger issues that require your attention than whether or not the NFL is crooked.
  21. patshaterhater
    21. Posted by patshaterhater Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:52 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I think it's all a big waste of time, including the clemens hearings. Although both are thoroughly entertaining, there are about a billion more pressing issues, and yes, some of them could probably be addressed by himself in 90 minutes. He should mind his own house first. I bet a $1,000,000 contribution to his campaign fund would get him to declare that the Patriots are saints. Stupid politicians.
  22. chowder
    22. Posted by chowder Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:47 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Specter is a pin-head, he is mad because his Eagles got beat by the Pats. This is the same guy that let a murderer loose years back, and the guy took off and lived in France. Typical blow-hard!
  23. Daniel B
    23. Posted by Daniel B Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    would the good senator from PA, and big-time Eagles fan, have pursued this if it was Andy Reid instead of Bill Belichick? ... HAH !!! ... i want everyone, and that really does mean EVERYONE, to ask themselves: if our founding fathers were around today, do you think they'd like what they saw? ... you're damn right they wouldn't !!! ... our government has grown into a 3-headed monster a long time ago, and all this is B.S. ... Arlen Sphincter is no different than a mafioso threatening the NFL with exhortion and pulling it's anti-trust exemption ... i'm ripping mad that my tax dollars are being wasted on this witch hunt ... total B.S. !!! ... this is why term limits are necessary !!!
  24. BroncoJimmy
    24. Posted by BroncoJimmy Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:36 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Why doesn't Specter call in almost all the politicans that lie? What is politicans had to tell the truth? For a change do something important rather than looking for headlines.

Shutdown Corner

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

MJD

Shutdown Corner is an NFL blog edited by Matthew J. Darnell. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Shutdown Corner Recent Readers