Thu Feb 19, 2009 10:40 am EST
You
know what I like about the NFL's overtime system? It's still football. The same
things you've been doing for the last 60 minutes, you're going to have to
continue to do if you want to win. It's not some bastardized form of the game,
like we see in hockey or college football.
Never in a football game does anyone just hand you the football at the opponent's 25-yard-line. You've got to earn it. You've got to force a turnover at that part of the field, you'll need a big special teams play, or you'll have to drive the ball down there. That's how it goes.
At no point will anyone ever pat you on the head and say, "Hey there, Timmy! Would you like to be knocking on the door of the opponent's red zone? Follow me, special friend!" That's not football, that's charity. That's something they'd do in a pee-wee league game if the sad and pathetic team couldn't score. Don't let it near the NFL.
Now, at the same time, I'll admit that the current overtime system isn't perfect. I think it's good. Not great, not perfect ... but good. The NFL's competition committee is looking at a potential rule change this week.
I see it like Tony Dungy sees it. Regardless of the coin toss, if you want to win, your team's going to have to play good football, be it offensively or defensively.
My one issue with the current system is that it's a little too easy to play for a field goal. If you get a decent kick return, you're looking at maybe 30 or so yards before you can get your kicker in range. I'd rather see an honest drive, and if a team has to settle for a field goal, so be it, but rarely in the course of a football game does a team make it their goal to get three.
How do we accomplish that? Eight-minute overtime. Eight minutes, and no timeouts for either side. Here's why eight's my number. I want to avoid the games getting too long, so I don't want to see a full quarter. Eight's a little over halfway.
More importantly, eight minutes is also about the unofficial cut-off for "Damn, that was a long drive." If your defense can't get the other team off the field in eight minutes, you don't deserve a possession. At the very least, I feel more comfortable telling a team they don't deserve a possession under those circumstances than I would telling a team they don't deserve a possession because they let Peyton Manning gain 35 yards on a drive and get into field goal range.
I don't think eight minutes asks a defense to do anything too spectacular. And if they can't handle it, the offense is going to get a chance.
And after eight minutes, if no one has scored, then we go to another coin flip for sudden death, or we just call it a tie. Really, what's so bad about a tie? Ties are interesting. They shake up the standings a little bit. I don't think there's anything wrong with a good tie every now and then.
But if you're a tie-hater, I guess I can understand that, and we'll accommodate you by adding the sudden death overtime back on to the top of the eight-minute overtime. You lose then, and you don't get to complain, because you had your chance in the eight-minute overtime.
To me, if the competition committee insists on discussing this, those are the two options: set a fixed amount of time for an overtime to last, or leave things as they are. Please do not give us a gimmicky, stat-inflating, unnatural deal like they have in college football.
Shutdown Corner is an NFL blog edited by Matthew J. Darnell. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Fantasy: Gentlemen's League: Thanksgiving showdown
Posted Nov 26 2009
NFL: Struggling teams - Who's to blame?
Posted Nov 24 2009
Posted Nov 24 2009
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by E. Brennan
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Andy Behrens
101 Comments
1 - 25 of 101
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
The college overtime rules are perfect..........
This article is completely garbage
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
The first kicker to miss that team lost. Then kickers will get more respect ....lmao...who am I kidding..lol.
Just kidiing about the kicking thing.
Just play a 5th quarter and keep going if no ones ahead after that .
The college OT needs to stay in college,this is the same groupe that cant even get the ranking right . BCS = BSC.
Report Abuse
Personally, the more I think about this, the more I like sudden death at six better than just sudden death.
But while we're on the subject of potential NFL rule changes, why do we still have extra point kicks? Soooooo boring. Plus there's a commercial break bookending it, and, really? How many have actually been blocked. I say the +1 is a gimme and if you take the risk and go for more you get +3, not +2, if you get in. Or maybe you have to go for +2, and if you don't get it you get -2?
Report Abuse
The problem with the college system is that it favors the second team with the ball. The second team knows that a field goal will be enough or that they must go for it on 4th down because they have to have a touchdown. The first team with the ball does not have this luxury of knowledge.
I favor the proposal in which the kickoff in overtime is from the 40 yard line, not the 30. This will require the first team with the ball to drive longer. Then the game is won or lost more honestly.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
move kick-off up 10 yards and don't allow a field goal attempt on a team's first possession
This way the offense has to go for a TD on the first drive almost ensuring (unless the other team plays really bad D and therefore deserves to lose) that both teams will get at least one offensive possession.
Report Abuse
It's still natural football as it was played in the first 4 quarters, it rewards good defense, and it makes kicking important, but not the most important thing in the world, like it is now.
One quarter, 2 timeouts each, and if it ends in a tie, it's a damn tie.
Report Abuse
If the first team can only pull in a field goal. The second team has to do better to stay in the game, because a tie doesn't cut it. More complicated, but more fun to watch.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
1 - 25 of 101