Shutdown Corner - NFL

Thu Mar 26, 2009 12:47 am EDT

The NFL continues the re-writing of the rule book

After five safety-oriented rule changes were made on Tuesday, the NFL followed with six more rules changes on Wednesday that seem to address common sense. Let's take a look at all 11, starting with the common sense rules put on the books yesterday.

• Loose balls that could have been the result of a fumble or an incomplete pass are now subject to video review. Or, as it will forever be known, "The Hochuli Rule." In case it's slipped your mind, here's the play that caused it all. Hochuli blew the initial call, and couldn't go to the replay to get it right. Ed felt bad about it and his dog was moved to letter-writing, but now, with everything said and done, it turned out to be a no harm, no foul situation. The universe righted itself in Week 17, the better team won the division, the rule has been changed and the case is now officially closed.

• Video replay can be used to determine if a loose ball stayed in bounds or hit the sideline. This one stems from some weirdness in the NFC championship game when a kickoff was ruled to have gone out of bounds when it never had. I guess it's comforting to have the replay in place now, so we can correct any such errors, but you know what I'd have done to begin with? I'd have instructed officials that they shouldn't rule that a ball went out of bounds unless they actually saw a ball go out of bounds. Seems like we could've saved everyone some trouble here.

• No more rekicks after an illegal onsides kick (someone on the kicking team touches the ball before it travels the necessary 10 yards, etc.). It immediately becomes the other team's ball. File this one under the common sense category. If you mess up an onside kick, you shouldn't be rewarded with a second chance to gain possession. If you mess it up, it's over, and the other team gets the ball. As it should.

• The draft order has been reworked to reflect playoff results, not regular-season results. The most commonly-cited instance here is that the Chargers beat the Colts in the '08 playoffs, and thus, advanced farther than they did, but the Chargers, after having gone 8-8 in the regular season, still pick way ahead of the Colts, who went 12-4 in the regular season. I'm a little torn on this one, as I'm not sure that the regular season record isn't the best way to determine a team's actual quality, but it's not a big deal. I can go either way on this one.

And file these last two under "things you probably never would have noticed if they weren't specifically pointed out to you."

• There's a new waiver period during the first two weeks of training camp, and the postseason waiver period will begin after the NFL's final game, whether it's the Pro Bowl or the Super Bowl.

• If a fumble or lateral goes out of bounds, the clock will stop only until the referee signals ready for play.

And now, let's take a second to go back to the five safety rule changes (or four rule changes, and one "clarification," as the league would tell you) passed yesterday, which have been slightly controversial. A lot of people feel like the NFL is taking too much contact out of the game, and not letting players play. I don't agree, I like the rule changes, and I say we go through them one-by-one.

• Forming a "wedge" on a kickoff return is no longer legal. If three or more players line up shoulder-to-shoulder within two yards of each other, it will be a penalty. Traditionally, kickoff return teams line up about four guys in a wedge in front of a kick returner, and tell them to stay lined up, run as fast as they can, and clear a path for the ball carrier. Meanwhile, the kicking team will send players down the field, running as fast as they can, with instructions only to hit the players in the wedge as hard as they can. If that sounds extremely violent to you, it's because it is. The owners determined it was causing too many injuries. I know that big hits happen on a football field, and that's fine, but we should probably avoid situations where we purposely set up people to hit each other with as much force and contact as two massive human beings possibly can muster.

• On onside kicks, the kicking team can't have more than five players bunched together. After reviewing tape, owners also concluded that too many guys were getting hurt on onside kicks. And it makes sense. You've got one group of guys that will be just standing there, waiting for the football, and a group of other guys running directly at them, just trying to take them out, one-by-one. That danger's still there, but it's been lessened.

• A blindside block cannot be delivered with a helmet, shoulder or forearm to an opponent's head or neck. That'll be a 15-yard penalty. I don't get the controversy at all about this one. You can still crack back on somebody, just don't lead with your head, and don't aim at another guy's head. I love the rule. Heads and necks are important. Let's keep them intact.

• Contact to the head of a defenseless receiver will also draw a 15-yard penalty. I kind of thought that was already a rule. But if it wasn't, it should be, and I'm good with it.

• A defensive player on the ground may no longer lunge or dive at the quarterback's lower legs. And last but not least, "The Brady Rule," 100 percent influenced by Bernard Pollard's (formerly) perfectly legal hit that sidelined Tom Brady for a full year. If I have a problem with any of the new rules, it's this one, but still, I see where the NFL is coming from. If you're going to sack a quarterback now, you've just got to do it while you're standing. Quarterbacks are the most vital ingredient to good football, so if it keeps more good quarterbacks healthy, I consider it a good thing.

What it comes down to it for me, with all of these safety-based rule changes, is that I'm sick of seeing guys carted off on stretchers. If it lessens the number of times that I see ambulances and neck stabilizers on football fields, even by the tiniest little margin, then I'm going to support it. That's the worst thing about football. The closer we can get that number to zero, the better off everyone's going to be.

digg delicious
more

2147 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. The Unsilent Majority
    1. Posted by The Unsilent Majority Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:01 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    If someone broke Philip Rivers' leg in half in the first game of the season, you'd want that rule instituted as well. So shush.
  2. Irish Bastard
    2. Posted by Irish Bastard Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:33 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    When was the last time you seen the wedge ?
    A blindside block cannot be delivered with a helmet, shoulder, or forearm to an opponent's head or neck. That'll be a 15-yard penalty. - So are you allowed to grab the flags they will be wearing ? A defensive player on the ground may no longer lunge or dive at the quarterback's lower legs .
    This one is the biggest HORSE S... rule of all so if a OL pulls a DL doen he cant hit poor Baby Brady unless hes up ?
    Let me ask this .Why didnt they put this rule in when Palmer got knocked out ?
    Please I dont want to hear it wasnt in the begining of the season either ,Palmers was playoff time ,Which is more important than 1 st gamw.
  3. Irish Bastard
    3. Posted by Irish Bastard Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:33 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Having 4 guys line up next to each other is what I would call a wedge, If you look at the real wedge its more like a V back in the day .
  4. Tim V
    4. Posted by Tim V Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Oh please, wedges happen all the time. Look at almost any game and you'll see it. As for the wedge rule, I don't like it. I can imagine a lot of situations where penalties are called because players wander to close to each other on accident. I could be wrong though, but I just see more controversy than good happening.
  5. samzelver1
    5. Posted by samzelver1 Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:02 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    It used to be that you needed a couple good QBs to get through a season. That was good. Its not like Brady's career is done. Remember how his career got started? oh yeah, somebody hit the starter (legally) and he went down. ditto everybody else who wasn't a first rounder.
  6. samzelver1
    6. Posted by samzelver1 Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:02 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    And its contact to the head of a defenseless DB thats a penalty now. MJD is correct that it has been a penalty for while now to hit a defenseless receiver.
  7. Coach Isiah Thompson
    7. Posted by Coach Isiah Thompson Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    15 yard penalty for roughing up Rodney!
  8. common.sense2007
    8. Posted by common.sense2007 Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:28 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    As for the Brady rule...why don't we just put a Tutu on the QB's and have them play flag football while the rest of the men on the field play real game. The days of Turkey Jones pile driving Terry Bradshaw need to be gone, but let's not make one player on the field a prima donna who gets to run an additional 10 yards down the sideline because defensive players are afraid to push him out of bounds for fear of a roughing the prima donna penalty!
  9. BorrowedTime
    9. Posted by BorrowedTime Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The NFL is taking the team out of the sport. They want to promote and prop up individuals on each team to make it appealing to the average schmuck. How about making it affordable for the AVERAGE guy to go to the game and have to take out a second or third mortgage on your house. I
  10. BorrowedTime
    10. Posted by BorrowedTime Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Stupid computer or user, anyway. Let me finish and make sense of my last mess. Cheaper ticket prices, put more of an emphasis on the team rather than the individual and don't mess up the game by putting in so many rules.
  11. Greg W
    11. Posted by Greg W Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:13 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't like the Brady rule. Mostly because it only made it to the rulebook because it happened to Brady. If Jon Kitna went out like that last season instead of him, everyone would just say "Good, he sucks anyway." and move on. It's a physical game, quarterbacks can get injured, even handsome, popular ones. Get over it and let the game remain physical.
  12. BigBlueShoe
    12. Posted by BigBlueShoe Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Like it or not, the NFL makes money because of players like Tom Brady. And when players like him go down in Week One, that's money lost for the NFL.
  13. Bill
    13. Posted by Bill Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:08 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    So if a defensive player gets knocked down, he is just supposed to lay there or try to stand back up before he continues to the QB. I realize there are rules needed for safety purposes but this is incredibly stupid. Agree with #2 as it was basically the same.
  14. Scott E
    14. Posted by Scott E Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't know how you would enforce the Brady Rule. Think about it. you are a DL on the ground. The act of lunging forward puts your arms in the air, feet still on the ground. Now, what angle do you have to be at in order to legally hit the QB? 45 degrees, 70 degrees, straight up??? What if you are aiming for his midsection and get blocked toward his legs or he moves backwards causing you to hit him lower? They should call this the Howie rule, cuz its just another excuse to run an additional irritating and extremely lame Chevy truck commercial while the officials stop play for yet another reason.
    They should have rules that make the game flow better.
  15. 1Badboy825 sls / Navlumj
    15. Posted by 1Badboy825 sls / Navlumj Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Maybe all the players can dance around the field and bring eachother flowers and chocolates like nice boys.
    Goddell and Bob Kraft strike again of course you know there had to be a rule to protect Tom Brady.
    This is Football not Pansieball...this is why guy's who are in the twilight of their career comeback and play 1 or 2 more years... Injuries... it's unfortunate when someone gets hurt but it's part of the business it keeps some players who are at the end employed for another season or two . 5 more years and you won't even be allowed to give the QB a dirty look. Football in the future is going to be like Basketball No defense and both teams scoring at will... the last team with the ball will win every time. Goddell is Bob Kraft and jerry Jones Puppet
  16. BorrowedTime
    16. Posted by BorrowedTime Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Like it or not football is a violent sport if you can't handle a hit take up another sport like ballet!
  17. daddymag
    17. Posted by daddymag Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Plain and simple, they made rules to take violent contact out of the game. We can't stop the boys from gettin' bigger and faster, and the armor companies just want to make more armor, and the roid-nutrition companies buy league sponsorship... all we can do is not let them hit each other anymore. I suppose it was inevitable.
  18. Max_Powers
    18. Posted by Max_Powers Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:33 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I have no problem with these rules. They won't be enforced correctly anyway. . . I'm more interested in the actual officials' training.
  19. Drew
    19. Posted by Drew Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    might as well have the QBs wear those special practice jerseys again.
    The Brady thing was 1 hit, but what about when it happened to Trent Green?
    it's football.
    what if a trip to the Super Bowl was on the line, you're telling me that Pollard is supposed to get up inorder to get Brady? What if Brady scrambles, Pollard can't touch him or a flag? what about tripping him up?
    what a joke....Goodell is making a mockery of the NFL. Europe, longer schedule....wow.
  20. Drew
    20. Posted by Drew Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    it's amazing, you can clock Sidney Crosby while attempting to score a goal there is no call, but if you touch any QB while you're on the ground, it's a penalty?
    wow....................Goodell i think is trying to bring Tecmo Bowl to real life.
  21. Drew
    21. Posted by Drew Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    and the Hochuli rule should have been done YEARS ago.
    people always talked about but never did anything until poor Hock blew the call.
  22. Kev K
    22. Posted by Kev K Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:53 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    This is BS
  23. Kev K
    23. Posted by Kev K Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:53 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Bs
  24. Kev K
    24. Posted by Kev K Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:53 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    brady is a whimp anyhow!
  25. jcd08215
    25. Posted by jcd08215 Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    just like what Palomalo said " it's turning into a pansy game"

Shutdown Corner

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

MJD

Shutdown Corner is an NFL blog edited by Matthew J. Darnell. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Shutdown Corner Recent Readers