Shutdown Corner - NFL

Rookies in the NFL make too much money. As a player I should be excited for anyone making a big contract. Good for them, right? For the top 20 draft picks it sounds great to sign a larger contract than guys that have played in the league for 10 years -- larger contracts than players that have been in the Pro Bowl at the same position. What's more is they don't have to lace up a cleat in the NFL and they are already getting guaranteed bonuses of $15, $20, even $30 million. Right, Rosenhaus?

It's amazing that in such a lucrative business the owners are willing to pay so much for potential. The average guaranteed bonus of the first 32 picks of 2007 was $10.86 million. Of course, some of the players getting paid are going to become great football players, but what becomes the biggest concern year in and year out is how many players really do become great, and how soon.

"It's crazy to guarantee money to people who have never played a down in the NFL," says Todd Yoder (pictured), my teammate and eight-year veteran. "That's the way the system has gotten. If someone has potential to become an elite player you're gonna get more in the first contract than the average Joe Schmoe makes in his entire career."

Potential is where this all begins. Can someone jump a 40-inch vertical, or how many times can they push a bench press? A 4.4 40 can elevate the draft status of someone maybe in the second or third round straight to the top 20 picks. But can it translate to millions of dollars of value on the field?

The NFL Combine is comparable to a strip club with owners and coaches for customers. The better the man looks running around in his spandex the more dollar bills end up on his stage. The funny thing is the onlookers at the combine are probably more excited than the creepy old man in the corner at the strip bar.

I mean, can anyone honestly explain how Vernon Davis adds more value to a football team than Jeremy Shockey or Antonio Gates? His contract certainly says that he does, because he is averaging more money than both of them every year. If Davis can continue becoming a better football player then it might be agreed that he was worth the money.

In Jason Witten's second year he caught 87 balls for 980 yards. Davis caught 52 balls for 509 yards. Both are good stats for a tight end, but Davis is currently making $500,000 more a year than Witten. Even better, Davis made close to $4 million more in his second year than Witten did. A player making that kind of money should be a Pro Bowl-type player.

I fell in the same boat as Witten with my rookie contract -- $600,000 signing bonus and the league minimum for three years. It took me those three years to establish myself as a solid football player in the NFL. Not until then did I receive a large contract -- six years, $30 million. So when someone can jump into the league and earn more than that without playing a single down, it’s hard to stomach.

The point here is that if a rookie in any other profession could step on the scene and make more than someone with a proven track record, the business would turn upside down. Imagine a first year staff accountant making more money than a senior partner simply because his 10 key skills were top in his class. This is basically what's happening in the NFL. Players are making money simply based on the number they were taken. Something with this system needs to change.

Chris Cooley is a Pro Bowl tight end for the Washington Redskins and blogs every Wednesday here on Shutdown Corner. Read more from Cooley on his personal blog, where he gets awesome all the time.

digg delicious
more

173 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. NYG One hit wonders
    1. Posted by NYG One hit wonders Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Who is your favorite player Mary? Nice spam.
    Honestly the numbers and salaries are staggering, and not one of them has played a day in the NFL. It is just sick. I feel bad for the pro bowlers that have to deal with these high paid overconfident rookies.
  2. Or M
    2. Posted by Or M Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:23 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Liking a Redskin is very difficult to me. You have this man's seal of approval, though. Terrific point, well articulated and stated courageously. Vernon Davis has his crosshairs on you now... Not that it matters. :)
  3. NathanS
    3. Posted by NathanS Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:23 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    This is great writing, keep it up Cooley. Also, when are Southeast Jerome and Joe Whiteguy going to get their own crime-drama show?
  4. fatty
    4. Posted by fatty Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:59 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Cooley is the best tight end in the game and he absolutely correct about how f**ed up the state of the current rookie contracts are.
  5. Richie
    5. Posted by Richie Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:40 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    It seems like a rookie salary scale would be in the best interest of teams and veteran players. The only people who would be hurt are players who are not yet in the NFL (and don't have a voice in the CBA).
    The teams are hurt by paying money to players who have no value.
    The veterans are hurt by earning less as a proven player than an unproven player would make.
    There must be a reason why some kind of rookie scale is not part of the CBA. What could it be?
  6. BrokenToys
    6. Posted by BrokenToys Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Here is my plan for the NFL salaries.
    1) Pay scale for rookies with a maximum bonus allowed.
    2) One player per team, rookie or vet does NOT apply to each team's salary cap.
    3) All drafties earning over X dollars on their contracts are REQUIRED to pay for a non-sports scholarship to the school they played for.
    4) Any college athlete leaving before their senior year are REQUIRED to pay for TWO non-sports scholarships to their school.
    5) Any player holding out for a NEW contract while under contract will be publicly flogged. You signed it, honor it. Or sent to the CFL to see what a real salary looks like.
    6) If you make any public comment to the press on your team, you must do it in front of the player or players you are dissing. (or praising)
    7) All quarterbacks will be given management training, assertiveness training, and be taught how to act like a man. I will call this the McNabb rule.
    8) Any player earning enough to hire a driver (which is all of them) will be required to forfeit their salaries for that year if they are involved in any DUI offense, or speed violation. If you want to get drunk or high, hire a driver, dummies.
    9) Any defensive player celebrating a big hit after allowing a first down will be fined and well, heck, publicly floggged.
    10) Allow instant replay on all personal fouls to properly throw the flag on the player that started it.
  7. Andrew
    7. Posted by Andrew Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:56 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    WTG Cooley!!!! Everything you said was very true. Just not sure you should have said it but very brave.
  8. anthony v
    8. Posted by anthony v Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:31 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    well put broken toys except for #9 lol ...
  9. Peter T
    9. Posted by Peter T Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Sounds like your a Marxist Chris.
    Im just joshin you!!
  10. Patrick
    10. Posted by Patrick Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:01 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    So, why can't the system change? I don't think the owners would have any objection to a rookie salary cap. You just have to get the players' union on board. They'll shoot down even a suggestion of restricting player salaries, though, so good luck with that...
  11. Big E
    11. Posted by Big E Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I totally agree and i think Goodell is on to something when he said he wants to incoporate a rookie salary cap system like the NBA has, I think that would be wonderful because why should someone who has never played a down at the pro level should make more than someone who has... teams lose so much money when that player bust or gets injured. I also think Broken Tous has a great idea going there.
  12. Q
    12. Posted by Q Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:04 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    they need to have some kind of rookie contract cap... its unbelievable how some of these kids are gettin paid more than those that deserve it! look at matt leinart... 40 million and hes playing like a #2 or #3 on the charts!? plus hes still partying it up like hes some freshmen frat boy that doesnt understand where he is and how hard it was to get there?!
  13. John V
    13. Posted by John V Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    This is a nice piece, really well written and presented and what not. But I have a distinct lack of sympathy due to the fact that while Chris got a $600,000 signing bonus most of us get $0. In 15 years I'll make a total of $600,000 at my current pay (PhD not getting me very far) and 3 years at the minimum appears to earn another $930,000 total. Follow that up with 6 years for $30,000,000 and yeah, the last ounces of sympathy have left me :P
  14. ZZ
    14. Posted by ZZ Thu Sep 03, 2009 11:00 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Hey fatty, Cooley is NOT the best tight end in the game.
  15. Ende
    15. Posted by Ende Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I totally agree. Just look at how much Chicago lost in the past with such wonder boy draft picks like Cade McNown and Cedric Benson. It looked like Cade was actually playing for the other team, and Benson is a multi-millionaire for playing around 5 games a season.
  16. THE 2007 CHAMP IS HERE
    16. Posted by THE 2007 CHAMP IS HERE Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    yeah he got a 600,000 dollar signing bonus be he earned the 30 million he is getting now.. year in and year out he makes plays, and i havent heard him on sports center making it rain in strip clubs, or beating up people outside a club, not even one D.U.I. way to Chris tell it as it is.
  17. jazzbooksfood
    17. Posted by jazzbooksfood Thu Sep 03, 2009 6:54 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Chris Cooley is absolutely right. It's got nothing to do with how much Cooley makes relative to the average Joe Workingman, either. Yes, it's true that Joe Workingman isn't going to have "sympathy", but Cooley isn't asking for any.
    He's asking for a fundamentally broken, unfair system to be repaired, & seriously, any football fan ought to agree with him.
  18. Ryan L
    18. Posted by Ryan L Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:23 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I always wondered what veteren players thougth about that. You hear the owners and the union bickering about it, even Goodell; but this is the first I've heard from an actually player. Thanks for sharing it.
  19. ChristopherL
    19. Posted by ChristopherL Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:24 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Cooley is right on point. Why should some guy whose never proven himself get a ridiculous contract? Yes, there should be protections built in if the guys gets hurt, but that should be true for all the players. I see a couple of options to improve the system:
    1) create a standard rookiew salary based on the pick and possibly the position.
    2) create a base salary that is then incentive driven.
    Teams could use the money saved to hold onto their veterans or sign free agents.
  20. DanC
    20. Posted by DanC Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The official mancrush on Chris Cooley has commenced.
    Great article from a tough, hard-nosed player. Who knew ball players had such great diction?
    Also, I'm a Jets fan.
  21. steve k
    21. Posted by steve k Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:17 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    yes rookies make way to much money,craps they haven't played one down caught one td pass or sacked a qb or returned a kickoff there should be a salary cap for rookies til they can prove themselves .crap some rookies make more money than what veterans do thats been in nfl for years,
  22. secolo3
    22. Posted by secolo3 Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    A bunch of BS!
    In the real world some idiot who's daddy has a lot of money gets to go to Harvard, fall asleep in a job interview and still land a six figure job on Wall St. Someone else who works their A%# off goes to school on their own dime and gets to work for 10 years to equal what some idiot made in their first year.
    All the power to those gifted enough to make as much as possible! This is AMERICA! You make your own fortunes and if you have the ability to get somewhere in life based on who you know or what you can do before you have to prove it then that's what makes AMERICA great!
    Suck it up Cooley and played better to make more! PERIOD!
  23. Andrew
    23. Posted by Andrew Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I completely agree. This is getting ridiculous. Then, even worse, you have guys like JaMarcus Russell who have the audacity to hold out because they don't think they're getting paid enough when they haven't even played a single down in the NFL. What sort of leverage should a jerk like this have? NONE!
    There needs to be a pay scale for rookies and it needs to be below what pro-bowlers at their position make. If these rookies don't like it, then let them sign a one year contract. If they prove themselves in year one (a la Adrian Peterson) then they would be free to resign a huge contract entering their second season. If they suck (like 80% of them do) then the team can release them and they can try to find work again like the rest of us (for whatever someone will pay them rather than huge signing bonuses just because they were a first round pick). Why should they get money for five more years when it is obvious they cannot perform their job? When a person in corporate America starts a job and fails to perform, he is fired.
    Another benefit this might serve is to persuade kids to stay in college longer because they know they will have to prove themselves for at least one year in the NFL before they actually start making huge money.
  24. Matt L
    24. Posted by Matt L Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Chris, I hope you become an analyst someday. Your honest take on things and your guts to offend people is very refreshing.
  25. chris b
    25. Posted by chris b Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:23 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    it is insane how much these guys are getting paid. alot of teams dont even want the first pick in the draft because of money. why did the patriots trade out of 7? money, its simple. they need to put a cap on what they are paying these guys, and maybe start giving some of the money to the nfl vets and retired legends !

Shutdown Corner

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

MJD

Shutdown Corner is an NFL blog edited by Matthew J. Darnell. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Shutdown Corner Recent Readers