Wed Nov 04, 2009 7:32 pm EST

Is Hines Ward(notes) simply a guy who likes to play hard or a cheap shot artist? According to NFL players, it's the latter.
Sports Illustrated asked 296 players who they thought was the dirtiest player in the league and the Pittsburgh Steelers receiver was a resounding victor, earning nearly double the votes of the next highest player.
I was always on Ward's side when it came to the dirty/hard argument, but his block on Keith Rivers last year swayed me to the other side. It's a gray area though; if Ward was on my favorite team I'd defend him to the death.
Below is a partial list of vote-getters, their percentage of the vote and a brief description of their dirtiness. You'll find that there is literally nothing surprising about the results of the poll, other than that Vince Young(notes) got a vote. (What, he throws his clipboard at people?)
1. Hines Ward (11.6 percent): One of two players on this list to have a rule informally named after themselves, Ward is known for lighting up defenders with a bit too much gusto after an interception or fumble.
2. Albert Haynesworth(notes) (6.0 percent): We can safely assume that Haynesworth earned the vote of Andre Gurode.
4. Roy Williams (5.1 percent): Even though the horse collar rule was made to protect the league's quarterbacks from the former Dallas Cowboys "star", I had never really thought that Williams was dirty. I just figured he did it because he couldn't tackle.
7. Richie Incognito(notes) (3.7 percent): You know that famous baseball-related bar trivia question that asks how many ways a batter can reach first base? Incognito's dossier reads like a list of all the possible ways to accrue a personal foul.
Even though he retired last spring, former Chargers safety Rodney Harrison(notes) received three votes, thus showing that dirtiness can live on in perpetuity.
Shutdown Corner is an NFL blog edited by Matthew J. Darnell. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Raw video: Saints march through New Orleans
Posted Feb 9 2010
Jerry Rice: Hall of Famer in Miami
Posted Feb 10 2010
Tiki Barber tells kids: Go do things
Posted Feb 9 2010
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Brooks Peck
Edited by Andy Behrens
158 Comments
1 - 24 of 158
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
What a joke . Whos 3,5,6 ?
Punters ? JK
As Sir Jack Lambert said about QBs PUT DRESSES ON THEM (meaning QBs ) Well Sir Jack maybe the D-Players should put them on too or wear red jerseys when they play so these hard hitting WRs dont hit them ! lol
Report Abuse
Steelers baby, please expose the Broncos on Monday night. Gonna be a good one!
Report Abuse
I feel badly for Rivers and I am not a Steelers fan. But Ward's hit was clean. That's football.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
The infamous Keith Rivers hit...way I look at it? Ward did exactly what Keith Rivers was TRYING to do to Ward's teammate: hit him as hard as he possibly could. Unfortunately for Rivers, he had a glass jaw.
Someone on local radio made this point: "Why is it that we accept the commonly repeated phrase, 'Receivers have to have their head on a swivel?' Why don't defensive players also have to have their head on a swivel? Seems to me that Ward is just dishing out what he's been taking for years."
Mind you, I live in the Detroit market, so it's not like the guy on my local radio is a Steelers fan. And I thought he made a superb point.
Report Abuse
He is? I watch a lot of NFL related TV and I don't think I've EVER heard a single analyst, "expert," or talking head make that claim.
Then again, I see from your photo that you're a Cardinals fan. Maybe Boldin is "concidered" the toughest receiver in the "leauge" by Cardinal fans.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
I guess when a receiver breaks a linebackers jaw someone is going to lable something on him. I don't agree with article i think other players are just not as talented as Hines. Put a diper on the 396 WHINERS and if they misbehave let Hines spank them. LOL "
Actually 296 players, but I agree with you. 296 players is what? 5 1/2 teams of 32? Where were the players from? Cincy, Balt, Clvd, and other teams the Steelers played in the last 12 months? Take a poll on all 32 teams then post the results.
" 10. Posted by Kris B Wed Nov 04, 2009 8:39 pm EST Report Abuse
gary, I don`t agree with you at all. Boldin is concidered the toughest receiver in the leauge, and he`s not concidered dirty, why cause he doesen`t take cheap shots at defenceless players like Ward.....Ward is THE DIRTIEST player in the leauge, and only a STEALers fan would defend him...... "
And your post just turned into meaning absolutely NOTHING when you typed STEAL. You don't agree with Gary because you are a jealous HATER of the 6 time SB champs
"23. Posted by jamesbyname63 Thu Nov 05, 2009 12:25 am EST Report Abuse
Ward is dirty, and a gloater... the hit he put on Rivers was above the neck with his forearm/elbow right into the side of his head. Now, why should that be legal when he could have easily made a very effective block to the torso, especially because Rivers didn't see him coming? It's obvious that Ward is out to play dirty, when you look at the way TRULY great blockers go about their job with precision and technique, and then you watch him play...? Ward, like alot of the the steelers has no class or humility whatsoever. There's nothing more annoying than someone who makes as much money as he does going about it with so little dignity. I love the sport, but I hate the egos, and no I would not appreciate it if we had a player that carried himself the way he does. Steelers have no class, and never have- just look at their quarterback who's always sporting his hat backwards..just like Tony Romo.. what is Ben, like 30 now? What a dork... "
"Ward, like alot of the the steelers has no class or humility whatsoever. There's nothing more annoying than someone who makes as much money as he does going about it with so little dignity."
Like alot of the Steelers? Well, there's nothing more annoying than someone who hates on the Steelers becaus ethey are JEALOUS of their success. Maybe you shoul have a little dignity when it comes to if you don't have nothing positive to say keep your trap shut. Don't worry about hoe Ben or Tony wear their hats. Maybe you should get out of the closet and take a look at other young mean their age. Again, nothing positive to say.........Now who's the dork?
1 - 24 of 158