Shutdown Corner - NFL

When Michael Vick found a new employer, the battleground was immediately marked off for the inevitable battle between animal rights protesters and whoever they decide to get mad at. The battleground will be Philadelphia, and to a lesser extent, the eight cities the Eagles will briefly visit over the course of the season.

There will be different groups conducting different protests for different reasons, and they'll all take different approaches. Some will be more inflammatory and destructive than others. Some people are mad as hell that Vick is back in the NFL, and they want to make someone's life miserable because of it.

My advice to those people, and anyone who feels the need to protest Michael Vick's(notes) presence in the NFL, is this: Don't do it that way. Don't take an attacking, vengeful, scorched-earth approach to this. For one thing, it's not going to work, and for another, it's not where your focus should be.

There's absolutely nothing you can do that's going to make Eagles fans turn against the Eagles. That's not happening. Maybe a few fringe fans fall by the wayside with the Vick signing, but anyone with more than a passing interest in the team -- and I'm speaking of the tens of thousands of people who eagerly pay for overpriced tickets, and the tens of thousands more who would if there were more tickets available -- aren't going anywhere, for any reason. If you're not a huge football fan, please take my word for this: The NFL has a grip on people like you cannot believe. For a great many people, the NFL is right up there with air, food, water and shelter.

No matter what you do, The Linc is going to be filled every Sunday. Any attempt at a boycott will be laughably futile. That's a guarantee. The only things that make people stop coming to football games are losing streaks. Dog murder will not have nearly the impact on the gate as the won/loss record. I'm not condoning it. I'm just letting you know.

So don't make this a battle against people who love the Eagles and will tolerate Vick's presence. Again, you're not going to win that battle, and more importantly, those people aren't the enemy. They don't have anything to do with the real goal here (or what should be the real goal), which is drawing attention to dogfighting and doing our best to eliminate it in the future.

That's what's important, isn't it? That we curb the practice of dogfighting?

Put your focus there. You can try to lead boycotts, you can yell and scream at Vick, you can try to make fans feel bad about following the Eagles and you can be as vindictive as you want. But how does that help? Does that bring any dogs back to life? Does it do anything but cause conflict between people?

Put your focus on the future and try to accomplish something that can save dog lives for years to come. The biggest advantage you have here is that your message is 100% in the right: Dogfighting is wrong, criminal, evil and intolerable. I think you'll find that the overwhelming majority of football fans -- even Michael Vick fans -- agree with you.

By all means, use Michael Vick to draw attention to your cause. Make an anti-dogfighting message Vick's major contribution to the world for the rest of his life, whether he wants it to be or not. Vick, no matter where he goes or what he does, is going to be a lightning rod for attention. Jump on that.

Take that attention, and use it to reach young people who might find themselves right now in same situation where Vick was when he was a kid: in an environment that tolerates dogfighting.

If you take that attention, though, and use it to rail against people who have given Michael Vick a second chance, or people who don't agree that Vick should never play football again, you're wasting it. That doesn't do anyone any good. The future of Michael Vick the football player shouldn't be of the slightest interest to you.

What's truly important are the lives and health of any dogs who might be looking at a future of fighting one another. Put your focus on the kids who are susceptible to getting caught up in it.

That's what Michael Vick's doing. Don't let him do it better than you.

Elsewhere on the Yahoo! Sports Blogs:
Surprise: Michael Vick signs deal with Philadelphia Eagles
Jen Utley isn't afraid to hound Eagles' signing of Michael Vick
Belichick to NFL: I'm afraid the Death Star is fully operational

Sign up now for Fantasy Football '09 -- now with free live scoring

digg delicious
more

1493 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Dawn B
    1. Posted by Dawn B Fri Aug 14, 2009 10:31 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    You are wrong! I have been an hardcore Eagles fan for years. I am done over the hiring of VIck. I will never again attend a game or purchase Eagles merchandise. When their merchandise sales fall, they will then know that they have made the wrong decision. There are many people that are much more talented than Vick. This was the wrong decision by the team.
  2. Robert C
    2. Posted by Robert C Fri Aug 14, 2009 10:32 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Very well said.
    But will they listen? I doubt it.
  3. Louise L.
    3. Posted by Louise L. Fri Aug 14, 2009 10:34 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    There are many fans like me who will not forget and who will not be fans as long as he plays. We are not the ones who will be standing outside of the stadium with picket signs, we aren't the ones who will loudly protest. We will be the ones who don't spend our money on sponsors products or services and will send those dollars to animal charities. I cannot believe that he would have stopped his heinous acts if he hadn't been caught and I saw him smirk in interviews so I don't believe he really thinks what he did is wrong.
  4. Doglover
    4. Posted by Doglover Fri Aug 14, 2009 10:37 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Here, here. I'm an Eagles fan, and I'll continue to be an Eagles fan. I have 2 pit mixes from the shelter and I'm happy that the Eagles gave PHilly the opportunity to continue to use Vick as the poster child against dog-fighting and animal cruelty. After all, if Vick hadn't gotten caught, he'd still be fighting dogs to this day. This is about HIM and how dispicable his actions are. The whole football thing is simply about which city gets the opportunity to let Vick know how sick he and his kind are.
  5. go phillies
    5. Posted by go phillies Fri Aug 14, 2009 10:37 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    capybaraxx, u r dumb...give me your season tickets and merchandise......i will gladly accept that.
  6. kennymarlowe
    6. Posted by kennymarlowe Fri Aug 14, 2009 10:38 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    first off i think this is stupid.. its one guy and he messed up and already paid for let it go.. also i think its is pathetic peta cares more about a animal life than a human life.. also those wothout sin cast the forst stone!!
  7. Mike
    7. Posted by Mike Fri Aug 14, 2009 10:39 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    i can't believe you ever called yourself an eagles fan if you will leave them in the blink of an eye. you obviously don't know what it means to be a sports fan in this city. while you do nothing every sunday this fall, i will enjoy watching my birds do battle. just like i always have.
  8. Brian H
    8. Posted by Brian H Fri Aug 14, 2009 10:40 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    what a great read
  9. Robert C
    9. Posted by Robert C Fri Aug 14, 2009 10:40 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Vick would have been better off beating women and children...he would get much more sympathy from the world. And that my friends is very sad, so very very sad.
    Does anyone even want to consider the possibility that Vick may actually have realized the error of his ways and the end result is that he influences a bunch of kids and they grow up and don't fight dogs.
    There could be a huge positive out of this whole situation, but people don't want to realize it. They just want Vick to fry baby fry.
    And ever think of how many NFL guys probably shut down their own dogfighting rings because of Vick getting busted? Another positive.
  10. Doglover
    10. Posted by Doglover Fri Aug 14, 2009 10:40 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    And to 'gl' -- the people who are sympathetic to Vick would do things like that to other human beings -- let alone dogs. It begs the question, who's the 'animal'?
  11. BasketballFan88
    11. Posted by BasketballFan88 Fri Aug 14, 2009 10:44 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    capy... is one of those fringe fans lol. Unless you prove that the stadium goes empty capy the author said that a few fringe fans will fall off the wayside.
    NFL can withstand probably the worst of the worst without much marketing damage. Any groups protesting vick's offensive behavior most likely will be wasting their time.
  12. Hambone
    12. Posted by Hambone Fri Aug 14, 2009 10:44 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    If people want to hold Michael Vick up as the symbol of the horrific nature of dogfighting, isn't it better that he keeps playing? Otherwise, won't it all just fade away?
  13. Ricky
    13. Posted by Ricky Fri Aug 14, 2009 10:48 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    not to be so sympathetic to your situation...i would never stop supporting my team no matter how dumb of a dissension they could have mad (true fan). Vicks not even that bad of a guy just mad poor wait moronic choices. Screw PETA I'll stand outside and protest them. Let the man play mcnabb need him anyways maybe he could teach that old dog some new tricks....
  14. Dave
    14. Posted by Dave Fri Aug 14, 2009 10:49 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    If you acknowledge that Eagles games will likely be sold out, why do you think the tickets are overpriced? If anything they are probably underpriced given the demand
  15. brian b
    15. Posted by brian b Fri Aug 14, 2009 10:51 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Police officers train dogs to tear the flesh off of a man. Often times the dog ends up getting shot because the cop is too scared to go in and do their job. Is this not barbaric?
  16. Dallas A
    16. Posted by Dallas A Fri Aug 14, 2009 10:51 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    "SOME" of you people are NUTTS!!! There are parts of the world where dog is dinner, like it or not. The man violated a law that is broken like glass on the road & no one pays much attention to it. Philly is one of the most unclean places in the country (I'm been there---once) and the people define MEAN. I'll never go back unless forced because it is sooo scary. U hate your OWN & you get mad about this.. HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA.. Get real
  17. Anthony P
    17. Posted by Anthony P Fri Aug 14, 2009 10:51 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm an Eagles fan, I don't like the signing with regards to Vick the person in the past, but would we welcome someone like Stallworth back when in reality, no matter how drunk the two were, he still killed someone.
  18. ToddF
    18. Posted by ToddF Fri Aug 14, 2009 10:57 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    The NFL is right up there with air, food, water and shelter? Wow, how insightful. Well here's some insight right back at ya. For many more people, morality is right up there with air, food, water and shelter, too. And for us, morality ranks much higher than the NFL.
    Because you clearly have no convictions -- unless we're looking into your own criminal record -- please don't lecture those of us who love dogs and despise brutal thugs like Vick on where we should put our focus. Vick is the poster child for abuse, for violence, for hate and for thuggery. Vick has yet to demonstrate any regret and has yet to demonstrate any active attempts at atonement.
    And so, Vick deserves to be one of many points of focus, as do any morally bankrupt, politically correct idiots who support Vick and choose to condone his behavior -- and yes, by defending him you ARE condoning his behavior.
    What's even more pathetic is that I suspect you're not even convinced of the soundness of your own argument. I think you're writing in defense of Vick's thuggery and the Eagles' appalling decision merely to stir up controversy for your own hackneyed writing and to push your left-wing, PC ideas down our throats. I sincerely doubt you'd be defending him if he were white.
  19. Scott E
    19. Posted by Scott E Fri Aug 14, 2009 11:00 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Excellent take on things, MJD. Psychologically, Philly is the best spot for Vick. Although, physically, on paper I thought their offense was really starting to look pretty solid. I'm wondering down the road if Wildcat formations and their derivatives will be a lasting contribution to NFL offensive schemes. If that is not the case, Philly might be wasting their time with Vick unless he turns out to be a heck of a punt returner. If McNabb goes down, though, he could save their season as QB. Time will tell.
  20. celticsin1
    20. Posted by celticsin1 Fri Aug 14, 2009 11:00 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    i've been an eagles fan my whole life no more, the signing of vick just goes to show you that money really does rule our world, and it's sad that people in our world don't really think what vick did was wrong, i don't think his punishment fit the crime, i live at the jersey shore and there's a trash bag full of eagles stuff if someone wants it, i'm not just banning the eagles, i'm banning the nfl, he should not be alowed to ever play football again, this world is full of sicko's and vick is leader
  21. benjamin p
    21. Posted by benjamin p Fri Aug 14, 2009 11:00 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    and remember petakillsanimals.com anytime you catch yourself thinking that most of these protesters aren't vapid hypocrites
  22. sean
    22. Posted by sean Fri Aug 14, 2009 11:01 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm so sick and tired of this. Peta came out with a statement as soon as the signing occured. what else do you want the man to do. He served his time. It's like everytime they mention his name an appology has to come out of it. How much apologizing do you have to do. I see so many other players in other sports get a slap on thw wrist, No I'm not condoning what he did and yes it was wrong. But he did not kill a human being. he got 23 months for killing dogs. I love dogs I have a dog. But are we ready getting carried away with this? Philly is taking a chance and he has help and guidance on his side. Time will tell, but you must first give the a person an opportunity to make that chance for the better and not everytime his name is mention you treat him like a terrorist.
  23. JOHN
    23. Posted by JOHN Fri Aug 14, 2009 11:01 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Tuff luck peta!!!!! ya'll don't run anything in the nfl. if you don't like it pack your dogs and fly out the country!! thank you eagles for standing up for the right thing!!!!
  24. Mark
    24. Posted by Mark Fri Aug 14, 2009 11:03 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    think of this as well... vick doing what he did, and getting caught for it... saved more dogs lives than he killed.

Shutdown Corner

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

MJD

Shutdown Corner is an NFL blog edited by Matthew J. Darnell. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Shutdown Corner Recent Readers