Shutdown Corner - NFL

Wed Sep 17, 2008 4:49 pm EDT

Maybe we should call him Jon Quitna

See what I did there? I substituted a "Qu" for the "K" in "Kitna," this making it seem like Jon Kitna might be a quitter. And here's why I'd do such a thing.

With just a couple of minutes to play in the Lions game against the Packers, Jon Kitna threw an interception. To be more precise, he threw his 3rd interception, and as Nick Collins was taking it to the house for six, Kitna was unbuckling his chin strap, taking his helmet off, and moping to the sidelines.

You can sort of see what happened if you skip ahead to the 4:09 mark here. Kitna throws the pickle, Collins darts to the endzone, and the next shot is of Kitna with his helmet already off, walking in the other direction.

You might argue that instead, Kitna should have been making an effort to tackle Collins. And if you've ever played football, you've heard constantly that you play "until the whistle blows." Pro Football Talk excoriates him for his behavior, and a columnist in the Daily Tribune isn't too happy about it, either.

I'm not as inclined to hammer him for it. First, if his teammates and coaches aren't upset about it (and they're not), then why should I be? Second, what did he have, about a 10% chance of even getting a hand on Nick Collins, and a 1% chance of actually making the tackle? It wasn't going to happen. And that touchdown made it a 23-point game with 2:00 to play.

"Play to the whistle blows" is something that sounds nice in Disney movies starring Matthew McConaughey, but is it really practical advice? Or is it just something Pop Warner coaches tell little kids, so they don't stand there playing with their bully button while the ball carrier runs right past them? Honestly, is there a point to a lumbering 350-lb. defensive lineman running sprinting downfield, even when a guy like Darren Sproles has a 40-yard lead on him? Of course not.

There's a practical time for giving up on a play, and Jon Kitna's enough of a veteran to know when that is.

digg delicious
more

19 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. .................................................!
    1. Posted by .................................................! Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    There is a point, and that point is "if there's a fumble". Or, witness the Bengals not running down Joe Flacco and making him look like Mike Vick in week 1. That TD doesn't happen if those 350-pound lineman bust their butts downfield.
    Also, Kitna's the team leader (naturally, as both QB and bible study chairman) and his mopey attitude on that play is indicative of the thousands of tiny loserisms that pervade in a losing culture, like the Lions have.
    Didn't read any of the PFT or other analysis of this but I imagine that's what they're saying.
  2. BMT
    2. Posted by BMT Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:04 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The Lions need to cut Kitna. He was turnover prone with the Bengals, Seahawks, Bengals again, and now the Lions. He's past 35 and not getting better. CUT HIM, PLEASE.
  3. Michigander21
    3. Posted by Michigander21 Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:35 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    How is it that a story about Kitna is what makes a national blog? Kitna stinks. That said, he has a lot of company. The Lions orginization stinks from ownership down through players. Kitna has tried to be the team leader. After a couple years of pure losing and witnessing stupid orginizational moves, how could he possibly care anymore?
    1. He reports to TWO offensive coordinators. One for running plays and one for passing plays. No conflict of interest there.
    2. The offensive line is terrible so they pick an O lineman with the first pick. Problem is it was a nobody that even the draft analysts were scrambling to look up. It would have been pure comedy if it weren't my team.
    3. He has two highly touted star Wide Recievers. But they both run the wrong routes regularly and drop balls constantly.
    This is just the beginning. Any Lions fan could fill pages with this stuff. I am not defending Kitna at all. I am just pointing out that he is no different from the rest of the orginization, total losers. It is time for the Ford family to sell the team to anyone with any competence, 50 years of failure is enough.
  4. sHuShAnE
    4. Posted by sHuShAnE Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:53 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    And then he gets injured trying to make a tackel he had zero chance of making, and we're all having the exact opposite argument of "How stupid could Kitna be?"
  5. Mr. Z
    5. Posted by Mr. Z Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    His body language says he has an attitude problem. Maybe that is not the case, but it sure looked like it. Of course, it could just be extreme frustration and that would be understandable.
  6. Pat
    6. Posted by Pat Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    MJD is a pair of shoes.
    Sorry, I've had that in my pocket all day. Totally irrelevant, but I couldn't foresee Fred Smoot doing anything blog-worthy in the foreseeable future, and I knew I would forget to do that if I waited for the MNF liveblog.
    So there you have it. Breaking news, MJD is a pair of shoes.
  7. Pat
    7. Posted by Pat Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    #3, can't really contest most of the stuff you said, and i certainly can't defend anyone in the lions organization. that said, the lions used their first overall pick on gosder cherilus, i believe. admittedly, he's not a top offensive line prospect. but coming out of bc and protecting matt ryan's blind side last year, people had definitely heard about him. he was worthy of a first-round pick, and at that point in the draft, there probably weren't many better options for the o line. you can't tell me that you wouldn't want to see detroit get a little better in the trenches, so i don't feel it's fair to criticize them on that one, especially so early in cherilus' career. otherwise, nice rant.
  8. matthew g
    8. Posted by matthew g Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    First of all, he's getting paid ALOT of money to play the game. If there is a 1% chance of tackling the guy then he needs to do that. Secondly the defender could of fumbled the ball or pulled a DeShaun Jackson.
  9. King Crackhead
    9. Posted by King Crackhead Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:31 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I can't believe you're standing up for Jon Kitna. The only reason this guy is still in the league is because he's part of the Christian clique of coaches and players that take care of their own. He throws a pick for every TD, is the complete opposite of clutch and has a horribly inaccurate arm to go along with his 5 cent brain. Kitna sucks and a good word should never be said about him.
  10. pumped_cobra
    10. Posted by pumped_cobra Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:22 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    What is it with the press bashing Kitna. It's the same with the Busch brothers. maybe it's because they are an easy mark.
    Mr. Writer, how about s how me an article where you ripped Brett Farce for doing the same thing. Farce obviously forces a ball that is intercepted and he walks off the field, "Well, gee wiz, hey, STFU, I'm Brett Farce, I have a ring" attitude as he walks off the field.
    It's a team sport sonny.
  11. Silent Storm
    11. Posted by Silent Storm Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:39 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Is it practical advice?
    Ask Ben Roethlisberger that, when the subject of the AFC second round playoff game vs the Colts in 2005 comes up.
    He saved the game, when Jerome Bettis fumbled and an Indy player started running it back the other way. If he gave up the way Kitna did, they would never have made it to Super Bowl XL.
  12. daddymag
    12. Posted by daddymag Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    best quit on a play i ever saw, flipper anderson got deion on a hitch-and-go one time. deion bit on the pump fake, the second flipper got behind him he quit playing. he knew it was six. he walked off the field before flipper even got to the end zone.
  13. mikez34
    13. Posted by mikez34 Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:20 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Hopefully you aren't as proud of yourself for the name change as Skip Bayless always seems to be.
  14. Aaron
    14. Posted by Aaron Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:17 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Kitna is the worst. He's the leader of probably the worst team the nfl has ever seen- or at least this decade for sure. Calvin Johnson, and the Losers. No O-line, no defense (outside of a decent LB), no ball-carrier, no qb, 1 WR (maybe 2).... and jason hansons leg is about to fall off.
    go lions. haha. go...straight off a cliff.
  15. Aaron
    15. Posted by Aaron Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:17 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    also, isnt removing your helmet on the field a penalty?
  16. Erik K
    16. Posted by Erik K Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:52 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't understand your post here. Are you calling Kitna a quitter or not. It seems like you were going to, but by the end of it, you sounded like you were defending him. I don't blame him. Have you seen how defensive linemen run to "block" the quarterback on an interception return?
    Also, please don't take this wrong. I love reading your blog and you do a great job.
  17. wasteasunday
    17. Posted by wasteasunday Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    When the Lions are on it's important for people in Michigan to find something useful to do. My wife's minivan got new rotors and brake shoes last Sunday. Boycott Ford Motor Company. Do not speak of or acknowledge the current 50 year lack of a pro football TEAM in our state.(some exceptional PLAYERS are o.k. to watch, none current) Football, the greatest spectator sport ever, is not available at the pro level here. Go to a prep game, or check out a MAC school. Adopt a favorite pro team from another place on the Great Lakes. Do what you need to for your football fix, but PLEASE DO NOT CONTINUE TO PAY INTO THE PROBLEM. Shame on anyone who buys a ticket at Ford Field. You are the real problem, not Jon Kittena.
  18. touchmynono
    18. Posted by touchmynono Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    First of all the Detroit lions are cursed. I don't know what they did to deserve this but they did it. How can you lose the best running back in the 90's (Barry Sanders) to early retirement? How? unless he saw that this team was gonna go no where for the next 20years and said I quit lol. Jon Kitna is not the answer at quaterback, they have to draft a quaterback and bring him along. Oh and check his character too dont just go for #1, most of them arent worth it. Second , get a winning attitude in their. If you have guys that dont wanna win cut them or trade em. I would say more but im tired and no one reading this really cares about the lions anyway. :) If the lions had half the heart of the Steelers they would atleast win 10 games each year.
  19. MS
    19. Posted by MS Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:29 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Please Mr. Ford.... Sell this team!! You are and have been an OBVIOUS loser for so many years!!! Some teams need a new quarterback, a stronger offensive or defensive line, a key player in general, we Lions fans need a NEW OWNER!!!!!
    You SUCK!!!!

Shutdown Corner

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

MJD

Shutdown Corner is an NFL blog edited by Matthew J. Darnell. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Shutdown Corner Recent Readers