Tue Mar 04, 2008 5:05 pm EST
It's
impossible to rank the greatest records in sports history. There are just too
many variables, too many skills that are difficult to compare, and too many eras
to compare them across.
That shouldn't stop anyone from trying, though. It's tremendous fodder for bar
conversations and arguments with drunk friends.
So here's an argument I'd like to present:
If anyone attempts to make a list of the greatest accomplishments/records in
sports, and Cal Ripken's consecutive game streak appears anywhere on that list,
Brett Favre's record of 253 consecutive starts at quarterback has to appear
ahead of it.
No disrespect intended to Ripken, but a quarterback will have more opportunities
to get injured in one series than a baseball player will in a couple of months.
I don't mean to trivialize the physicality involved in baseball, but ... well,
actually, I do. It's a fine sport, but compared to the NFL, it might as well be
synchronized swimming.
For Ripken's record, it was more about mental toughness and attitude than it was
an actual ability to take a beating. Both Ripken's and Favre's records stretched
across 16 seasons. I'd say that makes Favre's mental toughness equal to that of
Ripken's, and as far as physical toughness goes, there's really no comparing the
two. I doubt Ripken ever felt the morning after a game how Favre feels on your
typical Monday morning.
There are other arguments to be made in opposition of Favre having the most
impressive longevity record in sports. There are two NFL players with longer
consecutive game streaks. One of them is a punter (Jeff Feagles), so let's go
ahead and throw that out. The other is Jim Marshall, who played in 282 straight
games as a defensive end from 1961-1979.
From '61-'79, however, the game wasn't as fast, physical, or dangerous. Today's
players are immeasurably bigger, stronger, faster, and chemically enhanced, and
they're also running around throwing more cut blocks at people's knees. Jim
Marshall's mark is incredible, for sure, but I'll take 253 starts from a QB
today over 282 games from a defensive end in the '60s and '70s.
For 253 games, Brett Favre might as well have taken the field wearing a sign
that said, "Please, freakishly athletic and angry 300-pound men, try your
hardest to hospitalize me." He's been doing it non-stop since 1992, when he
stepped in and started a Week 4 game against the Steelers.
If you've got a fantasy football team, you know how big of a role injuries play
in the NFL. The game is so fast and unforgiving. For a guy to make himself a
target for every linebacker or defensive lineman on the field about 40 times a
game, and do that 253 straight times ... it's mind-boggling.
In order to catch Favre, Peyton Manning, the next guy on the list, is going to
have to play through the age 37 without missing another start. He's currently at
160. The most consecutive games any other quarterback has ever started was 116
by Ron Jaworski.
Shutdown Corner is an NFL blog edited by Matthew J. Darnell. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Fantasy: Gentlemen's League - Good vs. Evil
Posted Nov 20 2009
Posted Nov 19 2009
Posted Nov 19 2009
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by E. Brennan
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Andy Behrens
31 Comments
1 - 25 of 31
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
THANKS BRETT FOR ALL YOU DONE IN GREENBAY
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
But as a father of two great synchronized swimmers, one of whom "plays" with intense pain every time she swims, I could take offense on their behalf.
But I'd rather take the PR plug you gave synchronized swimming by including it as a sport. After all, any PR is good PR as long as they spell your name right!
ps: Its too late for Bart Starr to come back...so Brett, please give it 1 more go. Tom Selleck did it for Magnum PI.
Report Abuse
162 Games a year 16 Games a year
6-7 Months a year 3 Months a year
Travels 2-3 times a week Travels 1 time a week
Plays in 100degree pluss heat Plays in cold
Plays Offense and Defense Plays Offense Only (Half game)
Lets also mention that baseball players and infielders in particular do alot of running and diving which leads to a high chance of injuries. Pulled muscles and sprains are common. I am by no means stating Brett's strsak is meaningless. I mean that was a very impressive run. The best in the game, but I truly believe it does not compare to what Cal has done. Peace out!!
Report Abuse
Football is a CONTACT SPORT and is second only to UFC in terms of amount of contact. I'm sorry but saying that a baseball player COULD get "sprained muscles" doesn't compare to Favre constantly getting drilled by people 2-3 times larger than the biggest steroid-juiced baseball player in the major leagues as well as playing through numerous hand, shoulder, leg, and foot injuries.
Did Ripken ever play with more than a hangnail? It seems like he just had a good balance of training, stretching, and luck where Favre got hit in ways that no one could ever predict and got the same injuries as every other QB but played through them.
As for lineman playing for a long time, yes it is fairly impressive but remember that they see 95% of their contact coming where QBs only see maybe 60%.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
1 - 25 of 31