Thu Oct 22, 2009 12:39 pm EDT
There
are currently eight NFL teams that play in domes (three of them being
retractable). Of those eight, four are undefeated when playing at home, and
three are undefeated, period. This prompted the Wall Street Journal to ask the
question: Is
it time for the NFL to ban domes?
Obviously, no one's going to ban domes, but there is some evidence that dome teams have an advantage in the regular season. You can read the WSJ article for the statistical details, but it basically boils down to this: Dome teams can be dominant in the regular season, and most of the best scoring offenses in NFL history have been dome teams. When the playoffs roll around, however, you probably don't want to be a dome team.
Of course, two of the worst teams in the NFL, the Rams and Lions, play indoors, so it doesn't work out for everyone. In order for it to be an advantage, you've got to build your team for it: speed, precision and timing, particularly in the passing game. See the Indianapolis Colts and New Orleans Saints for examples. Depending on the building, crowd noise can be a huge factor, too.
The bad news is that eventually, you're going to have to venture out of that dome, and your team that's built for a perfect surface, 70 degrees, and immunity to weather might have to play in Pittsburgh in January. It will be cold, precipitating, and if you attempt to cut, a chunk of Heinz Field roughly the size of a cheerleader will come loose. Best of luck, dome team.
Anyway, it's a fun philosophical football discussion to have: If you were an owner, would you build a dome, or would you play outdoors? There are a lot of factors. You know, a lot of ins, a lot of outs, a lot of what-have-yous. If you ever have that discussion with me, I'll be building my fake team in an outdoor stadium. I don't care if it's in unexplored Yukon territory, I'm not doing anything that puts me at a disadvantage in the playoffs.
Of course, none of that matters, because none of that has anything to do with why domes really exist, which is money. You'll draw more fans in Detroit or Minnesota if you're not asking them to spend four hours outdoors when it's four degrees. You'll draw more fans in Arizona if you don't insist that your fans roast themselves for four hours. Domes are also easier to sell to cities and taxpayers, as they're more likely able to be used for things other than football.
Shutdown Corner is an NFL blog edited by Matthew J. Darnell. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Fantasy: Gentlemen's League: Thanksgiving showdown
Posted Nov 27 2009
Monday Day Night Football: Saints vs. Patriots
Posted Nov 25 2009
Posted Nov 24 2009
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by E. Brennan
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Andy Behrens
48 Comments
1 - 25 of 48
Report Abuse
I love hanging out on the corner....... is that bad?
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
I personally loved the last two Superbowls - both pretty high scoring games that really depended on who would get the last possession. Let's have another one! Support the Manning bowl, please.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
So let's hear it for New Orleans' push for home-field advantage! Florida won't be a difficult Super Bowl anyway!
Report Abuse
As a hockey player, I can tell you ice conditions do play a factor, but it factors for both teams. As an offensive player, I know that if there's a soft spot in the ice, I might be able to time it to where the defenseman get a skate in it and it slows them down enough for me to make a move around. But at the same time, that defenseman can work an offensive player into that spot where the puck hits and and stops the rush.
Field conditions work both ways.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Most all players played somewhere it was cold, High school, College or Pro, eventually they almost all get some cold weather exposure.
Seems this guy is just trying to find a story, which I read.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Atlanta
Arizona
Dallas
Detroit
Houston
Indianapolis
Minnesota
New Orleans
St. Louis
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Someone obviously forget to give Tom Brady this memo last week.
Report Abuse
Interesting that out of the pure dome stadiums, already three have been abandoned (the original Astrodome, the Silverdome, and the Hooiser Dome) and one is likely to be abandoned soon (the Metrodome). That should speak volumes - the retractable roof stadiums are kind of a compromise - and like any compromise they are well, compromised.
Interesting note about Minnesota - when the Gophers opened their new stadium this year, they considered building another dome until they looked at the average temperature in Minnesota in the fall - they concluded that it rarely, if ever was the case that conditions were so bad they couldn't play outside. Now, the NFL has a longer season than most, but if Green Bay, Chicago, Cleveland, and Buffalo can sell out games (especially since Cleveland and Buffalo aren't even good) in the middle of winter, anyone can.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
WAY TO GO GOOF !
Why dont they do a poll on since those domes have been buildt .The wins ?
They should give EVERY CITY with a team a chance to have a SB there. I mean shoot they play playoffs outside and it snows or rains whoopy do. OLD TIME FOOTBALL IS DEAD !
Brady Rule
Hines rule
How about the LET THEM PLAY RULE !
Report Abuse
1 - 25 of 48