Latest NFL injury news:

Smash-mouth football a dying art in pass-happy NFL

AP - Sports
Woodyard set to return to Denver's defense

View gallery

On Peyton Manning's first drive of his first game as a visiting player in Indianapolis, the Denver Broncos faced third down and 1 yard to go. Manning handed the football to Knowshon Moreno, who was stopped short. Denver punted.

On Manning's third drive, again he faced third-and-1, again he gave the ball to Moreno, and again the play was stuffed. Again, Denver punted.

''Hit a little rut there,'' Manning said hours later, after the Colts gave his Broncos their first loss of the season.

Other NFL offenses failed on similar plays Sunday, and it happens week after week: In the most critical of short-yardage situations, teams are converting at the lowest rate since at least 1995. The days of smash-mouth football, of bruising backs pushing piles forward with the help of run-blocking offensive linemen, are gone. Teams that have perfected the pass are not as equipped as they used to be for getting a key yard - or even inches - on the ground.

''The concept of running the football,'' former NFL coach Marty Schottenheimer said, ''has kind of taken a back seat.''

One of his 1980s Browns teams had two 1,000-yard rushers in the same season. One of his 1990s Chiefs clubs led the league in yards rushing. His tenure with the Chargers in the early 2000s featured LaDainian Tomlinson.

Times have changed.

''People have decided that the best, most efficient, way to go about it is to go ahead and spread the field out and try to get the quarterback a chance to do a pre-snap read,'' Schottenheimer said. ''And essentially, the play is called after the quarterback has stood there and looked at the defense and its deployment and figured out where to throw.''

Increasingly, teams can't gain what they want on the ground on third or fourth down with 2 or fewer yards needed for a first down or a touchdown. And increasingly, they're passing on those plays.

In all of those situations - third-and-2-or-less, fourth-and-2-or-less, including goal-to-go - NFL teams were successful 58.5 percent of the time through games of Oct. 14, according to STATS. That is a lower rate on such plays than for any full season since 1995 (that's how far STATS data goes back).

The rate in 1995 was 65.1 percent. In 2008, it was 63.7, and has been declining steadily since.

''My only answer,'' Steelers defensive coordinator Dick LeBeau said, ''would be they don't quite run as much as they used to.''

That, of course, is true. Games this season are averaging 53.2 running attempts, the fewest in the Super Bowl era, and 213.7 yards rushing, the third-fewest. Passing, meanwhile, is on pace for records of 72.3 throws and 489.2 net yards passing per game.

In 1987, for example, offenses were far more balanced, with 62.8 runs and 64.2 passes per game.

''We're more of a throwing league. ... Whatever you do more, you're likely to get a little better at,'' LeBeau said.

Plus, he noted, ''It's easier to throw the ball over somebody's head for 40 yards than it is to pound down the field 3 at a time.''

Dan Reeves, who coached in four Super Bowls, pointed out various rules changes that promoted passing, from restrictions on defensive backs to reductions on practicing in pads.

''Blocking and tackling are fundamentals you can't teach without pads,'' Reeves said, ''but one of the things you can do is work on timing in the passing game.''

In short-yardage situations, teams pass more than they used to: This season, the breakdown is about 55 percent runs, 45 percent passes on third- or fourth-and-short. Back in 1995, it was 63 percent runs, 37 percent passes, STATS said.

In 1995, the success rates on those runs was 71 percent. It dropped a bit below 66 percent the past two seasons, meaning teams are failing about one out of every three tries.

Take a look at Sunday. At the end of the second quarter against the Jaguars, the Chargers threw on three consecutive plays that began at or inside the 1, then tried a quarterback draw. They did not score, and time expired. The Rams had a fourth-and-goal from inches out against the Panthers and attempted a play-action pass. It fell incomplete, and when the Panthers took possession, they tried running the ball but got knocked backward, resulting in a safety. Kansas City's Jamaal Charles, third in the NFL in rushing, was thwarted by the Texans on a third-and-goal from inches away in the fourth quarter, and when the Chiefs tried a play-action pass on fourth down, it was incomplete.

A week earlier, the Ravens had first-and-goal at the 4 against the Packers, tried four runs by Ray Rice or Bernard Pierce, and turned the ball over on downs in a 19-17 loss. The Bills had first-and-goal at the 2 against the Bengals, and proceeded to run for 1 yard, run for no gain, run for no gain and get sacked on fourth down on the way to an overtime loss.

This is not to say zero teams can run. But they're rare and tend to create running room via zone-read options: Chip Kelly's Eagles when Michael Vick is healthy; the Seahawks with Russell Wilson; the 49ers with Colin Kaepernick. Those are the top three teams in yards rushing per game. The Redskins, led by Robert Griffin III, are second to Philadelphia in average gain.

''We like throwing the ball, too,'' Seattle coach Pete Carroll said, ''but we really want to run the football.''

Especially when it's time to extend a drive while trailing. Or run out the clock when ahead. Or bulling the ball in on fourth-and-goal from the 1.

''Teams that, week-in and week-out, do a good job of running the football still have a better chance of winning because it wears a defense out and it gives your defense a chance to rest. It's hard to do that with the passing game,'' Reeves said. ''There's still a premium on running the football. Is it as much as it used to be? No, it's not.''


AP Sports Writers Will Graves in Pittsburgh, Tim Booth in Seattle, Tom Canavan in New Jersey, Janie McCauley in San Francisco and AP Pro Football Writer Rob Maaddi in Philadelphia contributed to this report.


Follow Howard Fendrich on Twitter at


AP NFL website:

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Football
View Comments (4)

Recommended for You

  • Former Titans kicker Bironas killed in car crash

    Rob Bironas, who worked his way through odd jobs and the Arena Football League before becoming one of the NFL's most accurate kickers, died in a car crash. The former Tennessee Titans player died Saturday night when he lost control on a curve in his 2009 GMC Yukon Denali and crashed after 11 p.m.…

    The Associated Press32 mins ago
    Sun, Sep 21
    10:00 AM PDT
    Tennessee at Cincinnati
    Preview Game
  • Why did suspended Jameis Winston suit up for game? Because he's a kid

    It is the look that Florida State head coach Jimbo Fisher made when he confronted his supposedly suspended star quarterback before Saturday night's game against the Clemson Tigers. Jameis Winston, you see, was not acting very suspended. Fisher's back is to the camera and Winston appears to be…

    Christian Science Monitor
  • Despite shedding 20 pounds in 24 hours, Mark Hunt delivers massive KO

    A UFC source who asked not to be identified told Yahoo Sports a day before the weigh-in at UFC Fight Night 52 at the Saitama Super Arena in Tokyo that Mark Hunt had to cut 19 pounds to make the heavyweight limit of 265. Hunt, who was 284 the day before the weigh in, worked the weight off and…

  • View

    Photos of the day - September 20, 2014 (36 photos)

    A security man guards during the Miss Egypt competition pre-final at the Saladin Citadel in Cairo, potatoes display images of U.S. President Barack Obama (3rd R) and his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin created by cartoon artists at a food fair in Krasnoyarsk

    Yahoo News
  • Sprint car driver killed in Wisconsin

    BEAVER DAM, Wis. (AP) -- Sprint car driver Scott Semmelmann was killed in a wreck during practice for a race Saturday night at Beaver Dam Raceway. Beaver Dam Raceway general manager Carolyn Mueller and Bumper to Bumper IRA Outlaw Sprint Car Series President

    The Associated Press
  • RealGM: Zoran Dragic in advanced discussions to leave BC Unicaja for NBA

    Slovenian basketball player Zoran Dragic, a 25 year old 6'5" shooting guard, has said several times that he wants to go to the NBA if a team can make a solid offer and get him out of his current contract with BC Unicaja, Malaga. When Marc Stein first reported the Phoenix Suns heavy interest in…

    SB Nation
  • Tennis-Injury ends Azarenka's season

    Victoria Azarenka will miss rest of the tennis season as she tries to make a full recovery from injuries that plagued her year, the former world number one said on Sunday. The two-time grand slam champion withdrew from this week's Wuhan Open in China with a foot injury and later announced she would…

  • Former NFL kicker Bironas dies in Nashville car wreck

    Former Tennessee Titans’ kicker Rob Bironas died late Saturday in a single-vehicle car crash in Nashville, police said on Sunday. Bironas, 36, lost control of the SUV he was driving at a high rate of speed around a curve in the road, the Metropolitan Nashville Police Department said in a statement.…

  • Rumor: Evan Turner will be officially signed by Sept. 30

    To the surprise of no one, Evan Turner will officially (finally) be signed and introduced as a member of the Boston Celtics, ...soon.  This isn't really news actually, but it is nice to hear some confirmation of what we already knew. Source says #Celtics signing of Evan Turner will be…

    SB Nation
  • Man charged with killing NFL player Peterson's son released on bond: report

    (Reuters) - A South Dakota man charged last year with killing NFL star Adrian Peterson's 2-year-old son has been released on $2 million bond, U.S. media reported on Saturday. Joseph Patterson was released from a South Dakota jail on Friday

  • Lions-Packers inactives: Ziggy Ansah, George Johnson are active

    The Detroit Lions had a few defensive linemen declared as questionable for Sunday's game, but they're all active. Going into Sunday's game against the Green Bay Packers, there was some concern that the Detroit Lions would be without defensive ends

    SB Nation
    Sun, Sep 21
    10:00 AM PDT
    Green Bay at Detroit
    Preview Game
  • Roman Reigns rushed to hospital for emergency surgery; out of WWE Night of Champions

    WWE issued the following statement via their website and mobile app just a short time ago. NASHVILLE, Tenn. - has learned that Roman Reigns has undergone emergency surgery for an incarcerated hernia. Reigns had been in Nashville to promote

    SB Nation
  • View

    Roger Goodell apologizes during press conference (12 photos)

    NEW YORK (AP) -- Commissioner Roger Goodell says the NFL wants to implement new personal conduct policies by the Super Bowl. At a news conference Friday, Goodell made his first public statements in more than a week about the rash of NFL players involved

    Yahoo Sports
  • UFC Fight Night 52 results recap: Miesha Tate vs Rin Nakai fight review and analysis

    Miesha Tate and Rin Nakai engaged in a grueling grappling match last night (Sept. 20, 2014) at UFC Fight Night 52 on Fight Pass inside Saitama Super Arena in Japan. Ultimate Fighting Championship (UFC) Bantamweight women, Miesha Tate and Rin Nakai, took center stage last night (Sept. 20, 2014) at…

    SB Nation54 mins ago
  • Leicester City 5-3 Manchester United: Reds throw away a two goal lead in miserable fashion

    United found themselves on the wrong end of one of the Premier League's most inexpicable comebacks, as Louis van Gaal's men made themselves look ridiculous. United arrived in Leicaster hoping to win two games in a row for only the second time in 2014; For a few, brief seconds, it looked as though…

    SB Nation
  • Matt Schuab deactivated for Patriots game, non injury related

    Derek Carr beat out Matt Schaub for the starting QB job in Oakland to start the season, and now Schaub isn't even going to be the back up QB this week. With this move being made as a non-injury related move it means that Schaub is healthy but they have still chosen to deactivate him in favor of…

    SB Nation
  • Lance Stephenson did NOT try to ruin Roy Hibbert's wedding day

    The Pacers center married his fiancee is true. Lance Stephenson making vicious comments about his former teammate is not true. In the early evening on Saturday, we learned that Pacers center Roy Hibbert married his long-time fiancee, Valerie a little over a year after their initial plans to tie the…

    SB Nation
  • Manny Pacquiao thinks Mayweather lost rematch with Maidana

    Manny Pacquiao has either gone insane or he's getting funnier. Maybe he's talking just to talk, and maybe he's trying to get under Floyd Mayweather's skin, but Manny Pacquiao says he feels that Marcos Maidana won his September 13 rematch with Mayweather, which makes for one person who possibly has…

    SB Nation