Position Scarcity: The Mondesi Line

Andy Behrens
Yahoo! SportsMarch 21, 2007

It's our fault, not yours. We did this. Fantasy experts have been repeating the same tired dogma about positional scarcity for so long that maybe you've forgotten how incredibly simple these games really are. Here's your goal: in roto leagues, you want the most points in the most categories. In head-to-head leagues, you want to beat the week's opponent in as many categories as possible. That's it. If you have any other goals, you've overanalyzed the game.

Do you get bonus points for having a top-five shortstop? No, you don't. How about for having a top-tier catcher? Nope. Second base? Again, no.

Home runs from middle infielders have precisely the same impact on total points as home runs from outfielders. Let's call this the transitive property of fantasy sports. It doesn't matter which sport we're talking about, either. A yard is a yard, a rebound is a rebound, and a home run is a home run. It's surprisingly easy to forget this, too. And it's our fault, not yours. We're entirely to blame.

Am I saying that you should just ignore positional scarcity at your draft? Heck no. I'd lose my expert accreditation if I did that. Brandon Funston would show up at my apartment and rip the epaulets off my jacket. But I'd like to make one thing brutally clear: when looking at the difference between two players at any position, you should care about the magnitude of the difference. Too many owners concern themselves with ranks and tiers and ignore the stats behind them. That's a big mistake. One of the easiest ways to lose a league is to spend a high pick on, say, the number three guy at a "scarce" position when he's only marginally better than the number 15 guy.

For an example of this phenomenon, let's look at a bunch of second basemen:

Chase Utley Phi 11.1 1.3
Chone Figgins LAA 45.3 4.2
Robinson Cano NYY 50.5 4.7
Brian Roberts Bal 56 5.1
Dan Uggla Fla 67.8 6.1
Rickie Weeks Mil 83.8 7.5
Julio Lugo Bos 88.5 7.8
Jeff Kent LAD 113.3 9.9
Josh Barfield Cle 124.5 10.8
Freddy Sanchez Pit 132.9 11.5
Howie Kendrick LAA 138.8 12
Tadahito Iguchi CWS 148.9 12.9
Brandon Phillips Cin 159.5 13.8
Ryan Freel Cin 173 14.9
Ray Durham SF 189.2 16.2
Ian Kinsler Tex 196 16.8
Marcus Giles SD 199.3 17
Jorge Cantu TB 201.5 17.3
Mark DeRosa ChC 203.1 17.4
Jose Vidro Sea 213.4 18.3
Craig Biggio Hou 214.3 18.3
Ty Wigginton TB 217.3 18.6
Placido Polanco Det 219.3 18.7
Orlando Hudson Ari 221.6 19
Luis Castillo Min 226.8 19.3
Chris Burke Hou 226.9 19.3

For a moment, we'll ignore the fact that drafting Mark DeRosa ahead of Ty Wigginton is just criminally wrong. Same with DeRosa and Chris Burke. Seriously: it's criminally wrong. Like you should go to fantasy prison and share a cell with the dude who uses the full 1:30 for every draft pick. It's a punishable offense. But again, we're ignoring that.

Instead, let's look at four sets of fantasy stats from last season:

Player A – 563 AB, 85 R, 10 HR, 55 RBI, 36 SB, .286 AVG
Player B – 536 AB, 65 R, 17 HR, 75 RBI, 25 SB, .276 AVG
Player C – 423 AB, 65 R, 14 HR, 55 RBI, 11 SB, .286 AVG
Player D – 366 AB, 55 R, 9 HR, 40 RBI, 11 SB, .282 AVG

Those players will all be full-time starters in 2007. If that's all you knew about them, how would you rank those guys? Would they all belong to the same tier?

What if I told you that Player A was going to be 30 at the end of the season? Player B will be 26, Player C will be 25, and Player D will be 27. Would that matter to you? How about if I said that Player A hits in a moderately pitcher-friendly park, while B, C and D all play in home parks that are decisively hitter-friendly? How do you feel now? Does that affect your rankings?

The players are Brian Roberts, Brandon Phillips, Ian Kinsler, and Burke. I don't think any one of them projects as discernibly better than the other three. Give them all an equal number of plate appearances, and their numbers will be relatively similar. Kinsler may have the greatest upside, but it's debatable. What I find particularly interesting is that Roberts is getting drafted in the fifth round, while Phillips falls to the 14th, Kinsler to the 17th, and Burke to the 19th (and he often goes un-drafted, which is nuts. He's going to play the outfield, where he's less likely to get hurt, and he'll hit in front of Carlos Lee and Lance Berkman).

The only category in which Roberts is likely to exceed the mean in a 12-team mixed league is stolen bases, yet no one would call him an elite base-stealer. He's only reached 30 steals once in his career. Even if you think 30 steals are hugely valuable, why not just wait eight rounds for Willy Taveras (average pick 163.8)? Or why not grab Chone Figgins one round earlier than Roberts? That's an elite base-stealer. Figgins has swiped 114 bags over the past two seasons. Roberts isn't in that class speed-wise.

There he is, though, getting drafted in the fifth round. And why? Because talent is scarce at second base and people want a top-five player, even if the difference between that guy and a player you can get in the next-to-last round is negligible.

It's really not my intention to pick on Brian Roberts. He's fine. But there's no way the difference between Roberts and Phillips, Kinsler or Burke is worth a fifth round draft pick. It's insane. The same argument applies to Yankees second baseman Robinson Cano. His entire value in 2006 was in his batting average. In a 12-team mixed roto league, he would have been below the mean in every other hitting category. Could he improve in the counting stats? Sure, he's part of an absurd lineup. But I wouldn't rely on Cano or anyone else to hit .342 again. Regression to the mean is a powerful thing, and it's overwhelmingly likely to catch up with Cano, a .278/.331/.425 hitter during his minor league career.

Of course, second base isn't the only position where a recklessly misapplied tiering strategy can result in heinous picks. Ivan Rodriguez (74 R, 13 HR, 69 RBI, .300 AVG) goes five rounds ahead of Russell Martin (65 R, 10 HR, 65 RBI, .282 AVG); Huston Street (37 SV, 67 K, 3.31 ERA, 1.09 WHIP) goes five rounds before Takashi Saito (24 SV, 107 K, 2.07 ERA, 0.91 WHIP). The differences between those players won't be worth the cost.

For me, every position has an imaginary line below which I don't care who I own, because any of a dozen players will deliver comparable stats. Let's call it the Raul Mondesi line, in honor of the worst player I was ever excited to draft. This year that line gets drawn beneath Brian McCann at catcher, Nick Swisher at first, Felipe Lopez at short, Ryan Zimmerman at third, Nick Markakis in the outfield, Ervin Santana at starter, and Billy Wagner at closer. I'm also drawing the Mondesi immediately below the top second baseman, Chase Utley.

Everyone agrees that Utley is the premier player at his position. But I don't think that we – by which I mean the international community of fantasy experts – have done a particularly good job of expressing just how much better he is than the rest of the field. If we had, then Roberts and Cano wouldn't be so highly valued.

Here's how I'd arrange the tiers at second base:

Tier 1 – Chase Utley
Tier 2 – Nobody
Tier 3 – Nobody
Tier 4 – Chone Figgins and Howie Kendrick
Tier 5 – Just about every other starter in MLB who qualifies at second except …
Tier 6 – Mark DeRosa and Craig Biggio.

Utley was orders of magnitude better than everybody else in 2006. In fact, if the best possible player pool had been drafted in a standard Yahoo! public configuration, Utley would be one of only three players to exceed the league average in all five hitting categories – not his position average, but the league average. (Because you should care about this sort of thing, the other two players were Carlos Lee and David Wright). I find it much easier to make a case for Utley being the top overall pick in a draft than for him to be a second rounder. He's great, unlike everyone else who qualifies at second. Those guys are all flawed, and it isn't terribly important whether you get the fifth best or the 20th.

What's truly scarce in fantasy is a player who finishes significantly above the league average in multiple categories. That's how you need to invest those early picks, not on sub-league average players who you think might slightly outperform other sub-league average players. Because what matters in the end are the numbers you compile, not where you get them.

  • Iowa State DB Nigel Tribune arrested for OWI

    Iowa State dB Nigel Tribune (34) has started 26 games in three seasons. A starter on Iowa State’s defense was arrested over the weekend. According to the Des Moines Register, defensive back Nigel Tribune was booked for OWI early Sunday morning in Ames.

    Dr. Saturday
  • Mark Hunt rips UFC for not punishing Brock Lesnar, Jon Jones after failed drug tests

    The UFC opted not to fine Brock Lesnar for his positive drug tests before and after his fight with mark hunt. Brock Lesnar and Jon Jones sure do have a lot in common lately. Both were booked for UFC 200.

  • Walden University - PhD in Psychology

    Walden University - PhD in Psychology

    Earn your PhD in Psychology and make a positive impact within your community, organization, and profession. Request free information!

    Walden University
  • Chris Bosh and the Heat are in another debate over his health

    Chris Bosh saw a second straight season end early due to blood clots last February, but the story of his 2015-16 hardly ended there. While Bosh and the Miami Heat largely kept their disagreements out of the press, reports indicated that player and team were at odds over when he should return to the court. Bosh apparently wanted to play in the postseason (where the Heat took the Toronto Raptors to seven games in the Eastern Conference Semifinals), but the team did not want to risk his health.

    Ball Don't Lie
  • Jeremy Lin talks Knicks tenure, Melo and Courtney Lee

    Jeremy Lin will forever be a staple in the heart of New York City and Madison Square Garden. And while he's tried to develop a reputation as a dependable NBA player following the outbreak of Linsanity for the last several years, similar questions are resurfacing as Lin goes through the motions with the Big Apple media as the newest member of the Brooklyn Nets. "I was really, really sad. I was sad the way everything went down, 'cause nothing happened the way I thought it was going to. I had wished that they had offered me a contract just in the beginning," Lin told Steve Serby of the New York Post in a recent Q&A of his Knickerbocker ending. Of course, the Knicks opted not to offer Lin a contract.

  • Pirates fan makes a perfect barehanded grab

    On Sunday at PNC Park, one Pittsburgh Pirates fan performed a public service for everyone watching. On the 3-2 pitch, catcher Elias Diaz hit the ball foul, and it careened toward the stands on the first base side. It sailed over the Phillies’ dugout, and it was headed right for a Pirates fan sitting with his son.

    Big League Stew
  • Downsize with Style in Fredericksburg

    Downsize with Style in Fredericksburg

    Own a new home at Lee’s Parke Villages - Main-level living and incredible community amenities from the upper $200s. Schedule a Visit Today!

    Ryan Homes
  • Harvick remains atop Sprint Cup standings, Edwards drops two spots

    Kevin Harvick maintained his lead in the NASCAR Sprint Cup Series points standings after Sunday’s Combat Wounded Coalition 400 at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Harvick leads Brad Keselowski by 20 points, while Kurt Busch is in third place, 44 points behind Harvick. Joey Logano (-65) is fourth, while Sunday’s race winner, Kyle Busch (-70) is fifth. Carl Edwards took the biggest points hit of drivers in the top 10. Edwards was involved in a late-race crash and dropped from fourth to sixth place, 78 points now behind Harvick. Also of note, Kyle Larson moved into contention for the upcoming Chase for the Sprint Cup. Larson climbed four spots to 15th in the standings. Here’s how the standings look

    NASCAR Talk
  • The Rangers are expecting a better Kevin Hayes next season

    While speaking about Kevin Hayes on a conference call, Jeff Gorton said that he expects Hayes to come into this season with a chip on his shoulder and "play really well." Gorton said that Hayes is a 6-5 center who has shown at times "how good he can be in this league." He said that Hayes' second year was similar in some ways to a lot of players who have a good first year and struggle the next year to meet expectations. Alain Vigneault said after the season that Hayes is part of the Rangers future but needs to step up. It's been said that Hayes is someone who needs to engage more on a consistent basis. For more on Hayes, click HERE, HERE, HERE, HERE.

  • Trevor Daley surprises young hockey players, firefighters with Stanley Cup visit

    Trevor Daley had his day with the Stanley Cup on Saturday, taking it through Toronto, surprising young hockey players at a local rink and firefighters at a local station. He also held a private viewing party for family and friends inside a local bar, as per the Toronto Sun. Daley’s post-season came to an end in the Eastern Conference Final when he suffered a broken ankle. His absence tested the depth of the Penguins blue line as the playoffs pressed on, but Pittsburgh was ultimately able to power its way to a championship. When Sidney Crosby handed off the Stanley Cup, the first player it went to was Daley, whose mother was battling cancer. “He had been through some different playoffs, but getting

  • A Commuter’s Ideal Spot in Silver Spring

    A Commuter’s Ideal Spot in Silver Spring

    Norbeck Crossing offers newly designed luxury elevator residences less than a mile from the Metro Red Line and the ICC. From the mid $200s.

    CalAtlantic Homes
  • NHRA: John Force, Tony Schumacher earn first wins in over a year

    John Force and Tony Schumacher earn their first wins in over a year Sunday at Denver.

  • Les Miles issues statement on wreck that claimed lives of MSU, Nebraska punters, injured LSU’s kicker

    A tragedy that struck the Michigan State and Nebraska football communities has also touched LSU’s. On their way home from a kicking camp overnight, Nebraska punter Sam Foltz and former Michigan State punter Mike Sadler were killed in a car accident in Wisconsin this weekend.  Additionally, LSU placekicker Colby Delahoussaye was injured in the crash that claimed the players’ lives. Delahoussaye has since been released from an area hospital after sustaining burns to his legs and lacerations that required stitches.  LSU issued a press release revealing a couple of details surrounding the accident: The car crash occurred at 11:43 p.m. on Saturday on Beaver Lake Road. According to the Waukesha County

    NBC Sports: CollegeFootballTalk
  • Baseball Hall revamps veterans’ committees

    COOPERSTOWN, N.Y. (AP) Baseball’s Hall of Fame has again revamped its veterans’ committees, attempting to increase consideration for more contemporary players, managers, umpires and executives. Under the change announced Saturday by the Hall’s board of directors, there will be separate committees for Today’s Game (1988-2016), Modern Baseball (1970-87), Golden Days (1950-69) and Early Baseball (1871-1949). Today’s Game and Modern Baseball will vote twice every five years, Golden Days once every five years and Early Baseball once every 10 years. “There are twice as many players in the Hall of Fame who debuted before 1950 as compared to afterward, and yet there are nearly double the eligible candidates

  • Stay Off the Strip in Vegas and Save Money Today

    Stay Off the Strip in Vegas and Save Money Today

    Enjoy 7 distinctly different hotels, each with their own flair and save up to 20% on your stay plus food credits. Book today & save on your Vegas trip

    Boyd Gaming
  • Ronaldo shows no sign of injury while hanging with Conor McGregor

    Cristiano Ronaldo may not be ready for the UEFA Super Cup, but he’s no longer limping around. To explore the Real Madrid superstar’s Instagram is to see Ronaldo, sometimes clothed, hanging out with celebrities. In the last couple weeks we’ve seen him with Eva Longoria, Jennifer Lopez, and now his “bro” Conor McGregor. Wait, what? Yeah, Ronaldo is friends with the MMA star, and showed no ill form (and no brace of any kind) in several posed photos with McGregor. Although admittedly, McGregor’s IG game is a bit better: The Irish fighter posted a photo of himself sunning in his briefs with the caption, “I’m gonna get him on the Forbes list by next year. But I’m gonna get him on the tan by next week.”

  • The science of sweat: Giants use technology to stay hydrated in the heat

    NEW YORK – Giants manager Bruce Bochy remembers a time when ballplayers would combat the heat by putting cabbage leaves under their hats. Methods are a little more sophisticated these days. The Giants might play in a crisper drawer at AT&T Park, but they can’t escape hothouse ballparks when they play outside their division in the summer months. This weekend at Yankee Stadium, temperatures reached the upper 90s with the usual East Coast humidity. Every player on the field was a Sultan of Sweat. And that’s where Geoff Head, the Giants’ sports science specialist, comes in. When it comes to hydration, Head’s head is soaking with knowledge. Head collected sweat samples from each player both pre- and

  • Johnny Cueto annoyed with Royals after White House snub

    Johnny Cueto played a key role in the Royals World Series win, but wasn’t invited to the White House celebration. According to the San Jose Mercury News, Johnny Cueto, who pitched a shutout for Kansas City in Game 2 of the World Series before joining the San Francisco Giants in the offseason, was also not extended an invitation to the event. And, like Gomes, he’s not happy about it.

    Big League Stew
  • KitchenAid® Black Stainless Appliances

    KitchenAid® Black Stainless Appliances

    Behold, the first-ever black stainless steel kitchen. The new exclusive color that's as bold as you are. Visit the KitchenAid site to view appliances.

  • Ohio State has epic Friday Night Lights weekend

    While you were setting up plans for the weekend, Urban Meyer and crew had their hands full with dozens of top prospects during their annual Friday Night Lights camp. If you took more than a few minutes to eat a cheeseburger or take a sip of lemonade you might have missed Ohio State once again dominating the recruiting trail. Don’t worry, Land-Grant Holy Land has your back. Get caught up with the weekend that was: Buckeyes pick up 3 commitments When you get a large group of prospects in Columbus, Ohio for a camp chances are someone will leave the Ohio State campus verbally committed to suit up for the Buckeyes. This time was no different. To kick off the weekend festivities for OSU, the Big Ten

    Land-Grant Holy Land
  • Bayern players impressed with Ancelotti

    Franck Ribery and David Alaba say they are enjoying life with Bayern's new coach

    Omnisport Video
  • Blues GM: We may take ‘half a step back,’ while young veterans grow into leadership roles

    After a few early exits from the Stanley Cup playoffs, the St. Louis Blues were finally able to make a long run. Granted, they didn’t win the Stanley Cup or make it to the final, but they did manage to reach the Western Conference Final. Unfortunately for the Blues (and a lot of other teams), the NHL’s salary cap number didn’t increase very much and it forced the organization to part ways with a number of key veterans. Gone are captain David Backes, winger Troy Brouwer and goalie Brian Elliott. There could be even more change between now and the start of the year, as Kevin Shattenkirk could find himself elsewhere. Those key departures mean that the Blues will need some of their younger players

  • Sausage Breakfast Casserole

    Sausage Breakfast Casserole

    Next time you're expecting weekend guests, serve this hearty, make-ahead breakfast casserole. It's simply delicious, and a great way to start the day.

    Campbell's Kitchen
  • PGA Championship 2016: Golf Clothes and Apparel at Baltusrol

    See the golf clothes and golf apparel that pro golfers are wearing at the 2016 PGA Championship at Baltusrol, including Rory McIlroy, Jordan Spieth, Rickie Fowler, Dustin Johnson and more.

  • Raikkonen secures Driver of the Day honors in Hungary

    Kimi Raikkonen has captured the vote for F1’s Driver of the Day award, following his efforts to come from 14th to sixth place in Sunday’s Hungarian Grand Prix, and with the fastest lap of the race in the process. The Ferrari driver missed Q3 for the first time all season but atoned nicely in the race at a track where passing is usually at a premium. Raikkonen’s battle with Red Bull Racing’s Max Verstappen was one of the race highlights, the Dutchman defending aggressively – perhaps too much so – against Raikkonen’s advances. But with no penalty assessed and no warning issued, Verstappen ended ahead in the battle for fifth. “I think it was very questionable, but it’s not my decision to decide,”

  • White Sox suspend Chris Sale five days over Saturday’s clubhouse incident

    White Sox starter Chris Sale was scratched from Saturday’s start against the Tigers due to a clubhouse incident. It turns out Sale wasn’t happy that the White Sox wanted to use throwback uniforms that featured collars. Sale reportedly cut up his uniform and got into a heated argument with front office staff. The White Sox released a statement on Sunday, announcing that Sale has been suspended five days. White Sox senior vice president and general manager Rick Hahn said, “Chris has been suspended for violating team rules, for insubordination, and for destroying team equipment.” Hahn continued, “While we all appreciate Chris’ talent and passion, there is a correct way and an incorrect way to express

  • Know how much your home is worth.

    Know how much your home is worth.

    Zillow's Zestimate helps you track your home's value whenever and wherever you want.

  • Jim Delany releases statement on passing of Foltz, Sadler

    Big Ten media days begin today — nominally a time of celebration, optimism and free food in the conference. This year’s gathering will take on the direct opposite feel, at least at the start, as the conference continues to reel from the tragic passing of Nebraska punter Sam Foltz and former Michigan State punter Mike Sadler. Ahead of the event’s official opening, Big Ten commissioner Jim Delany released this statement: “We join the Nebraska and Michigan State communities in sending our thoughts and prayers to the families, teammates, coaches, administrators and friends who have been impacted by the tragic loss of Sam Foltz and Mike Sadler. While we are deeply saddened by their untimely loss,

    NBC Sports: CollegeFootballTalk
  • DeMarcus Cousins looks to make most of chance with US basketball team

    LAS VEGAS (AP) — DeMarcus Cousins considers the thought, and one of the NBA’s most recognizable scowls quickly turns into a bright smile. Without saying a word, it’s clear he agrees: For the first time under Mike Krzyzewski, the U.S. Olympic basketball team has a genuine offensive weapon in the middle. The Americans might even have the best center in the world. Cousins had 14 points and 15 rebounds in just 16 minutes of the Americans’ exhibition opener, a 111-74 victory over Argentina. The Sacramento Kings star can score inside and out, and gives the U.S. a dimension it hasn’t had while winning the last two gold medals. “DeMarcus is going to be a force in Rio,” teammate Klay Thompson said. The

  • China vs. Team USA

    Kevin Durant leads all scores with 19 points as the Team USA defeats China 106-57.

  • Take the Lead - Coast Guard Opportunities

    Take the Lead - Coast Guard Opportunities

    Want to learn more about the exciting opportunity to serve in America's elite force of maritime defenders? Plan your next move.

    United States Coast Guard
  • Ranieri on Leicester post-Kante: “Don’t worry. Football in Leicester will keep going”

    Claudio Ranieri hasn’t lost his way with words over the summer. The Leicester City boss who famously refused to admit his team was in a title race for most of the Premier League season is keeping it cool in the wake of N'Golo Kante signing for Chelsea. Simply put, Ranieri says everything’s going to be fine. From Sky Sports: “Last season we lost Esteban Cambiasso and everybody was crying,” Ranieri said, after his side drew 1-1 with Celtic in a pre-season friendly. “Now we are crying because we lost Kante. Don’t worry. Football in Leicester will keep going.” Kante was probably the most important part of Leicester’s title capture last season, but Ranieri’s system was also critical. The follow-up

  • The Olympic athletes’ village in Rio is reportedly ‘uninhabitable'

    Some of the world's most highly skilled and highly trained athletes are preparing to live and compete in Rio de Janeiro in just a few short weeks. Upon their arrival to the athlete's village, the Australian Olympic Committee found the venue to be uninhabitable.

    SB Nation