Let’s continue our search for pitching bargains and busts that we started a little over a week ago, continuing to use our model to test our general sense of worth. The model, which compiles stats from 2010-12, is a tool to help you make your choices. Diverge from it, sure, but be certain you have a really good reason (small sample size, age- or injury-based recent declines, recent age-based performance spike).
The regression police are looking at Max Scherzer. (USAT)
Some last week wanted the actual category stats instead of the mere rankings. The chart was edited for space. I provided the full version to those who requested it when contacting me on Twitter @michaelsalfino and I link it here now.
Rankings here are based only on performance in a handful of categories – K/9, K/BB ratio, ERA adjusted for league and park (especially important for pitchers changing teams and leagues) and the stat that I discovered last year for fantasy projection purposes – isolated slugging allowed. ISO is merely the difference between the slugging average and the batting average allowed. I like it because it isolates the most damaging, run-causing extra-base hits. Pitchers with the lowest ISOs require the opponent to get more hits to score runs. Plus, it’s these singles that are most subjected to Balls in Play (BIP) variance/luck.
To be ranked, pitchers needed to average at least 6.5 Ks/9 with at least 29 starts in the 2010-to-2012 period, but all stats (even in relief) are included. I’ve also noted where some select 2012 starting pitchers who did not meet that threshold of starts would have ranked if they made the requisite starts (and compiled similar stats). The overall ranking is merely the total of the cumulative ranking in each category (lowest is best), though the individual category rank is also noted. I rank these categories instead of the actual fantasy ones because we are trying to find outliers here.
Note: these are not recommended tiers, though tiers are self-evident by the total number ranking (183 in Scherzer’s case). We’re just grouping pitchers 10 at a time to better focus the accompanying analysis.
I’ve always faded Scherzer. The key is whether his strikeout gains from last year are a fluke or whether they are his new normal. Bet on regression to his sample average, which is still very playable. Scherzer is a fly-ball pitcher who is hurt worse than average on the hits he does allow. So even if the BABIP normalizes from .337 to about .300, his ERA will not correct commensurate to that BABIP drop because the improvement is going to come mostly in the least harmful hits - singles. I also wonder if fly-ball pitchers have more stable BABIP due to the nature of the hits they allow, though that’s a topic for another day.
Oswalt is pretty clearly no longer this level of pitcher even if he signs somewhere. Morrow should not be going about 30 spots after Scherzer, as is the case generally and in the Yahoo! Friends and Family League. Marco Estrada, who we rank below, is far more trendy than Phelps but shouldn’t be. He probably shouldn’t be more trendy than Peralta, either, who is much younger. I thought both had a certain spot in the rotation, but now that's up in the air with the acquisition of Kyle Lohse on Monday. Mike Fiers, who this model really likes, is technically the Brewers' fifth starter and if that depth chart listing holds, he'd be out of a starting job despite his sterling K rate and K/BB over a large sample of major league innings in 2012.
Peralta has a big fastball (unlike Fiers, who relies on command and deception). But control will be the key. If he's in the rotation, he should be placed on mixed-league watch lists. Shields gets over-drafted almost everywhere. I don’t trust pitchers when they leave the Rays and that BABIP magic due to defensive positioning. Expect Shields’s ERA in KC to be 4.00ish. As we discovered last year, Cueto’s ERA-overachieving has nothing to do with the variable BABIP and everything to do with his consistently excellent ISO allowed.
Why does everyone love Dan Haren to bounce back? I expect him to land at about this ranking in mixers when 2013 is in the books, especially considering he’s throwing in the mid-80s this spring. Lincecum challenges us to look at his entire sample off the horrid 2012, but even the big numbers are now bargain relative to where he’s often being drafted. Lincecum does have good ISO though, unlike Kennedy. Hudson is on the shelf. I do like Kuroda, but everyone except R.A. Dickey is a risk at age 38. Marcum still is struggling with shoulder issues or I would happily grab him as the poor man’s Haren (much, much later). Collmenter has relief stats mixed into the sample and that’s where he’s pitching to open the season, but he’s not bad.
Look where Moore is versus Harvey (top 20) and note that Moore goes 60 or 70 picks earlier. I do agree that there is a good chance Moore will improve but people are paying like it’s a guarantee. Baker, Hanson and Paulino are hurt. Worley has to pay the AL tax now. That ERA and K/BB knocks Liriano out of consideration for me. I don’t trust Santana’s shoulder one bit. Why does Samardzija also get drafted so much later than Moore? Doesn’t he have similar untapped potential? My model likes Vogelsong almost as much as my buddy @scott_pianowski. Locke was done in by big innings last year, but should be placed on mixed-league watch lists.
I like Niese more than this ranking because I believe more in his recent performance given his age. We could say the same thing about Bailey, too. Beckett gets the NL/Dodger tailwind now and is being faded so much in drafts that even skeptics should be intrigued. And I like Iwakuma, too, though I do not put special weight on last year’s superior splits when starting because having better stats as a starter makes no sense (so it’s likely a fluke).
Cobb is trendy with the smart crowd. My model is neutral. With this last group, it’s not whom you want but rather whom you should avoid. Phil Hughes was off my lists even when he was healthy. Burnett is a tease and I expect a 2013 meltdown in line with this sample despite the benefits of pitching in the NL (which should improve stats 10 percent, tops). I would avoid McDonald, too. The only player in this grouping who I’d feel confident about drafting is Minor, and only as a bottom-level mixed-league starter. Yes, he has upside but every pitcher you draft late should have that.
The argument seemed to be settled at the end of 2012, when Pacquiao was dealt a face-first knockout loss against Mexican legend, Juan Manuel Marquez and Mayweather further established his boxing dominance in one-sided victories over Robert Guerrero and Saul "Canelo" Alvarez. Up until Pacquiao came…
Peyton Manning: Super Bowl winner. MVP. Observer of proper wedding etiquette. The above photo surfaced on Reddit on Monday, and sure seems to be a wedding invitation reply card signed by the Denver Broncos quarterback himself. (Here are samples of … Continue reading →
COMMENTARY | Bill Belichick usually doesn't give the media any juicy quotes for stories. In a world full of coaches and athletes that love to say whatever they can to get into the headlines, Belichick is awfully boring. The New England Patriots will square off against the Cleveland Browns in Week…
COMMENTARY | Michael Jordan once said, "Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence wins championships." And with the Chicago Bulls' Derrick Rose injured with a torn meniscus and out (again) for the season, arguably, the franchise has lost a major driver of its talent. With D-Rose out and…
Lolo Jones was the first woman ever to claim back-to-back World Indoor titles in the 60m hurdles while setting an American record in the process. Following the 2012 Olympics, Jones tried out and made the USA Bobsled team as a push athlete. Jones is now training hard to represent the United…
Dec 4 (Infostrada Sports) - Results and standings from the English premier league matches on Wednesday Wednesday, December 4Arsenal 2 Hull City 0 Fulham 1 Tottenham Hotspur 2 Liverpool 5 Norwich City 1 Manchester United 0 Everton 1 Southampton 2 Aston Villa 3 Stoke City 0 Cardiff City 0 Sunderland…
Mariano Rivera may be retired from baseball, but he showed he's still capable of throwing cut fastballs for strikes while making an appearance at Dick's Sporting Goods "Pinstripe Wednesday" event in Manhattan. The only difference, on this occasion Rivera wasn't … Continue reading →
UFC welterweight contender Hector Lombard had harsh words for colleagues Jake Shields and Georges St. Pierre recently. Lombard made fun of the welterweight champ St. Pierre's fear of aliens to MMA Junkie this week and also called out Jake Shields. “He’s so scared of aliens coming up and taking…
There are five Germans shortlisted for the Ballon d'Or this year — Bayern Munich's Philipp Lahm, Thomas Muller, Bastian Schweinsteiger and Manuel Neuer plus Arsenal's Mesut Ozil. This puts their manager, Jogi Low, in a bit of a pickle. Since … Continue reading →
Jaromir Jagr is incredible, with 22 points in 28 games for the New Jersey Devils. Jaromir Jagr is also incredibly old at 41, which means he probably shouldn't have to carry as much of the offensive load as he has … Continue reading →
Henrik Lundqvist and the New York Rangers have decided to end the wait, end the speculation and end the questions about whether or not a looming contract extension was weighing too heavily on the franchise goalie. Lundqvist has agreed to … Continue reading →
Today, Burton Snowboards is honored to officially unveil the 2014 U.S. Snowboarding Team uniforms that all riders representing the United States will wear during competition at the 2014 Winter Olympics. The Sochi Games will mark the third consecutive Olympics where Burton has partnered with U.S.…
A pretty easy way for celebrities to measure their level of fame is by asking the simple question, "if someone dressed up as me, would people freak out?" Meet Donnie, a man that probably doesn't have a jaw-dropping backhand, but … Continue reading →
Despite a fairly one-dimensional game that's kept him from being a very reliable full-time contributor during his seven-year NBA career, Nick Young has become something of a cult hero and fan favorite among basketball lovers of a certain stripe due … Continue reading →
By now you may have heard about the waiter who was stiffed for a tip by some Alabama fans after he talked about “being proud of Auburn” after their improbable win on a returned field goal in the Iron Bowl. … Continue reading →
Long time UFC middleweight champion Anderson Silva looks back at his shocking KO loss to Chris Weidman this past summer and sees only "basic mistakes" that led to his defeat. "My mistakes in that fight, and that’s the first time I’m saying this, were basic mistakes," Silva recently told Sportv,…
Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin is in danger of being called two-faced, or even deceitful, with his latest explanation of what happened on Thanksgiving. A sincere-sounding Tomlin took the podium for his regularly scheduled Tuesday press conference and issued … Continue reading →