Tom Brady's generous gesture worthy of scrutiny

Michael Silver

So Tom Brady, out of the goodness of his gold-minted heart, has cut the New England Patriots a contractual break, taking far less than he's worth so that the team will have more room under the salary cap.

Patriots, you are now on the clock.

How aggressively the Pats parlay the cap savings into retaining and acquiring premium players will determine whether Brady's gesture was a smart one. While the future Hall of Fame quarterback certainly had his reasons for doing a cut-rate deal — and, on many levels, he has earned the right to make that decision — it did not come without a psychic cost relative to his reputation within the NFL community.

In agreeing to a three-year, $27 million contact extension that runs through the end of the 2017 season, when he'll be 40, Brady likely riled agents and players throughout the league, especially those of the elite-quarterback variety. From Joe Flacco, who's currently negotiating a long-term deal with the Baltimore Ravens in the wake of a Super Bowl championship, to Aaron Rodgers, whose deal with the Green Bay Packers is well below market value, highly compensated passers can look forward to being guilt-tripped by employers, media members and fans imploring them to "Take Less For The Team."

When that happens, Brady shouldn't expect to receive any thank-you cards.

This is not to suggest that Brady particularly cares about the discomfort his decision might cause Flacco, Rodgers or any of his other competitors — nor that he necessarily should. In addition to being a popular leader who is one of the greatest players of his generation, Brady has strong credentials with the rank-and-file, having lent his support to the union via his involvement with the players' antitrust lawsuit during the 2011 lockout.

All Brady cares about is winning — and with three rings to his credit (and two near-miss-championships since his last one eight years ago), he's got a chance to surpass four-time winners Joe Montana and Terry Bradshaw in the all-time annals of Super QBs.

So he drank the cap-space Kool-Aid, and/or bought into the owner-driven sob story about not being able to surround him with enough talent under his current contract. As my colleague Les Carpenter pointed out Monday, Brady had good reasons for doing the Pats a solid and has fewer financial worries than the average multi-millionaire athlete, given that his supermodel wife commands an even healthier slice of cheddar.

[Related: Tom Brady puts Patriots in position to keep winning for years to come]

It should also be noted that Brady, according to two sources familiar with the deal, did get something out of the extension: With a $30 million signing bonus, he'll be guaranteed $3 million more over the first two years of the deal than he otherwise would have. Additionally, if he's still on the roster following the 2014 season, the other $27 million becomes fully guaranteed against a career-ending injury — a $24 million upgrade on the previous deal.

All of that sounds good, but I could spend a ton of time giving you the rebuttals of cynics in the NFL world who believe Brady took an inexplicably bad deal and that his agent, Don Yee, should wear a "Kick Me" sign at the next league event for having negotiated it. I'll spare you, partly because I don't necessarily believe Brady's financial decisions are necessarily any of our business (beyond how they might relate to the NFL's competitive landscape), and partly because I'm convinced Brady is at peace with the deal.

The important issue pertaining to the contract is that Brady believed this was something he had to do in order to allow the Patriots to compete. I understand his reasoning, but it's a matter that's certainly open for debate.

First off, I'm trying to imagine the reaction of Brady's chief rival, Peyton Manning, if he were given a similar pitch by the Denver Broncos. I'm guessing it would range somewhere between mad, cackling laughter and a four-word response that suggests a physically impossible act, and which served as the basis of an entertaining punchline in recent Best Picture winner Argo.

Manning, who made $18 million in 2012 (and will earn a reported $40 million, guaranteed, over the next two seasons provided he passes a physical next month), is sucking up a pretty big share of the Broncos' salary cap. For what it's worth, Denver seemed to do just fine last season, going 13-3 to earn the AFC's No. 1 seed.

Brady obviously believes that by clearing up cap space for the Patriots, his bosses will work to surround him with as much talent as possible, from difference-makers to the less-heralded backups who sometimes push contending teams over the top.

I just hope he's not being gullible. My regard for Patriots owner Robert Kraft is well-documented, and I know that he, like Brady, strives for excellence on a constant and enduring basis. That said, the model that has worked for Kraft and coach Bill Belichick is one in which the team typically holds firm on its valuation of players, rather than allowing the market to dictate its expenditures.

[Related: Would you take less money to help your team financially?]

That's fine — but it's not necessarily in line with going all out to maximize cap space in the desperate pursuit of short-term championships. And I hope Brady considered his own history before agreeing to take less in the final years of his vaunted career.

Remember that back in 2005, when Brady signed a six-year, $60-million contract, he consciously took a below-market deal because he wanted the Patriots to have more financial flexibility in signing other players. Kraft, however, didn't suddenly morph into a combination of Eddie DeBartolo, Jerry Jones and Daniel Snyder. He basically stayed true to his business model, and some hard decisions were made in the process.

One of those tough decisions — failing to meet the financial demands of Brady's favorite target and close friend, wideout Deion Branch, who was subsequently traded to Seattle in 2006 — angered the quarterback at the time. Arguably, the absence of a big-time receiver the following January cost Brady and the Pats a chance to win another Super Bowl, as they were edged by Manning and the Colts in an epic 2006 AFC title game.

This time around, another favorite target and close friend — Wes Welker — could potentially bolt the Patriots. The team franchised the prolific slot receiver a year ago, giving Welker a huge raise to $9.3 million for the 2012 season. Belichick seemed almost offended by that number, marginalizing Welker during last September's season opener (five targets; three catches; 14 yards). Welker's role increased after the Pats lost two of their first three games, and he finished with 118 catches for 1,354 yards.

He's now less than two weeks away from unrestricted free agency, barring a contract agreement.

If the Pats take some of the cap dollars they saved on the Brady extension and pay market value to Welker, he can pick up the tab the next time they go out in Boston or L.A., and the quarterback will believe he did the right thing by creating the cap room. If Welker ends up in another uniform — perhaps (gasp) catching passes from Manning in Denver — I have a feeling Brady won't be so enthused.

Perhaps Brady is simply ahead of his time, having grasped the reality that a relatively flat salary cap under the current CBA (though I have my suspicions about this and plan to address the subject in a future column) makes the notion of a $20 million a year quarterback competitively unfeasible. It's also possible that his current deal will be revised after 2014 to provide for another massive signing bonus that leads to another cap friendly deal, though I'm told this was not an expectation on his camp's part.

[More: Tyrann Mathieu continues redemption process with strong combine outing]

Whatever his reasoning, Brady clearly believes he's putting himself in the best position to win, and it's tough to argue with that reasoning. By being selfless financially, he is also being selfish, and he has certainly earned that right.

Now we'll see if the man who pays his salary — and the coach whose vision he trusts — are similarly motivated to sacrifice.

Other popular content on the Yahoo! Sports:
Packers reserve D.J. Williams has a unique wing man
NBA Power Rankings: Spurs starting to feel the Heat
Mark Cuban 'agitated' because of Derek Fisher's move to Oklahoma City
Darrelle Revis' exit would spell doom for Rex Ryan

  • NFL morning after: The decline of Colin Kaepernick

    Colin Kaepernick is the NFL’s most significant player off the field, a player whose simple act of declining to stand during the national anthem has led to wide-ranging discussions across America about race, police brutality, free speech and the role of sport in society. That has been the subject of thousands of commentaries. But it’s not the subject of this commentary. Instead, I want to talk about why I also consider Kaepernick the most fascinating NFL player off the field. And the reason for that is simple: He has rapidly declined from a very good quarterback to a terrible quarterback, at an age when most quarterbacks are still getting better. It was less than four years ago that Kaepernick

    NBC Sports: ProFootballTalk
  • Ryan Miller slams goaltending equipment criticism: 'I’m inside the rules'

    Vancouver Canucks netminder Ryan Miller still has hard feelings over how he has been portrayed in the debate over the size of goaltending equipment. Last season, TSN’s Ray Ferraro pointed out how Miller and Carey Price wear the same size pant even though Price is much heavier than the 168-pound Miller.

    Puck Daddy
  • PHOTO: The Moment Clinton Learned the Cubs Are World Series-Bound

    Hillary Clinton's travelling press secretary captured the moment that the Democratic presidential candidate learned that her beloved Chicago Cubs are headed to the World Series. Nick Merrill snapped the photo Saturday night onboard the campaign plane, where Clinton -- who was raised in the Chicago suburb of Park Ridge -- was handed a phone and watched highlights from the game. The Cubs beat the Los Angeles Dodgers 5-0. It will be the team's first time in the World Series since 1945. "That look when you cap off a day on the trail by watching the @Cubs cement their trip to the #WorldSeries. #FlyTheW," tweeted Merrill. The game had just ended as Clinton was boarding a plane in Philadelphia, where

    ABC News
  • How will DeAndre Hopkins perform in Denver?

    Yahoo Sports' Fantasy Football Live crew looks ahead to Monday night's meeting between the Houston Texans and Denver Broncos.

    Yahoo Sports Videos
  • Gary Cahill doubles Chelsea's lead

    Off a Chelsea corner kick the ball falls to Gary Cahill who smashes the ball into the back of the net to give Chelsea a 2-0 lead over Manchester United.

    NBC Sports
  • Joe Gibbs Racing shows why being conservative works in the Chase

    Maybe Talladega was the “lay up” race of the third round? Joe Gibbs Racing’s four cars represent half of the eight drivers advancing to the third round of the Chase. Kyle Busch, Carl Edwards and Matt Kenseth entered Sunday’s race with hefty points advantages over ninth place.

    From The Marbles
  • Disastrous Break, Quadruple Bogey Derails PGA Tour Player's Chance at Win

    (c) 2016 Time Inc. Justin Thomas Defends Title at CIMB Classic Justin Thomas battled back from a four-shot deficit during the final round of the 2016 CIMB Classic at TPC Kuala Lampur to successfully defend his 2015 title.Anirban Lahiri had one of the

  • Wow! A.J. Green makes an unbelievable catch on a Hail Mary

    Hail Marys are always pretty cool, but Cincinnati Bengals receiver A.J. Green made one of the greatest catches you’ll see on one. At the end of the first half, Andy Dalton heaved one to the end zone. It was the same scrum in the end zone we’ve seen for most other Hail Mary throws, with everyone going up at once.

    Shutdown Corner
  • Terry Francona and Tyronn Lue are typically awkward acquaintances

    Indians manager Terry Francona (left) and Cavaliers coach Tyronn Lue are still on good terms despite a text message mix up. Indians manager Terry Francona and Cavaliers head coach Tyronn Lue are the leaders behind the sports renaissance in Cleveland. According to ESPN’s Dave McMenamin, the two men first met years ago in Boston when Francona was managing the Red Sox and Lue was an assistant coach for the Celtics.

    Big League Stew
  • Winners and Losers: The pool of CFP candidates is thinning

    There’s a little more than a week until the first official College Football Playoff rankings are announced, and there are still a handful of teams that could make the Top 4. As we saw Saturday with Ohio State, it’s difficult to stay at the top of the heap and more often than not the teams that appear at the top of the first CFP rankings aren’t necessarily the teams that go on to actually play in the playoff. Alabama: Can anyone topple the Tide? For a moment on Saturday, Texas A&M made it look possible, but a few mistakes later and the Tide were heading off the field with another dominant victory.

    Dr. Saturday
  • Mets plan to slow-play market for Yoenis Cespedes

    The Mets want to bring back Yoenis Cespedes, "but they probably wouldn't chase him if he got an enormous long-term deal elsewhere," given his age and the streaky nature of his production, according to weekend report from's Buster Olney. According to multiple reports, Cespedes is expected to opt out of his three-year contract and become a free agent. There is mutual interest in having him return to the Mets. However, "There is no urgency," a source told Olney, who says the Mets are open to effectively updating his current deal with another opt-out clause. Cespedes has until three days after the end of the World Series to decide whether to opt out of his current contract with the Mets,'s

  • Cubs loving Jonathan Toews outed as White Sox fan by Kris Versteeg

    The Chicago Cubs are seeking their first World Series championship in 108 years. “Cleveland Indians fans”) is pretty much pulling for the Cubs to break several curses to Fly The ‘W’ for the title. According to Kris Versteeg, former Chicago Blackhawks winger and current Calgary Flames player, Toews is a sock in Cubs’ clothing.

    Puck Daddy
  • Don’t glare: Heritage Classic start time delayed

    It’s not a familiar situation for the NHL, but it has happened before: a weather delay for a hockey game. The Winnipeg Jets confirmed that the start time for their Heritage Classic game against the Edmonton Oilers has been delayed. The glare of the sun appears to be too much. At the moment, it is not yet known how severe the delay will be. Puck drop was originally scheduled for just after 3 p.m. ET. That’s a bummer, but at least it inspired a joke that would probably make Ilya Bryzgalov smile: Warm-ups were moved to 4 p.m. ET. PHT will keep you posted if there are any other changes.

  • Chelsea rout Manchester United 4-0 to ruin Jose Mourinho's return (Video)

    Jose Mourinho accomplished something on Sunday that he was incapable of doing last season as Chelsea manager: motivate Chelsea’s players. The return of the Special One to Stamford Bridge – for the first time since being fired last December – was all the inspiration the Blues needed as they rampaged to a 4-0 Premier League victory over Mourinho’s listless Manchester United. It took just 30 seconds for Chelsea to grab the lead.

    FC Yahoo
  • Sprint Cup race results from Talladega Superspeedway

    Car owner Roger Penske’s Sprint Cup teams never won a restrictor-plate race until the 2008 Daytona 500. Joey Logano’s victory Sunday at Talladega Superspeedway — the sixth in the last nine plate races for Team Penske — evokes memories of Dale Earnhardt Inc.’s dominance and Hendrick Motorsports’ success. Only DEI, which won nine of 12 plate races from 2001-03, has a better winning percentage over multiple seasons at such tracks than Penske.

    NASCAR Talk
  • LeBron James says he can still win MVP with reduced workload, cites Stephen Curry

    The door is open for LeBron James to win a legacy-altering fifth MVP. But his Cavaliers could also win another championship, leaving Cleveland coach Tyronn Lue planning to limit LeBron’s minutes in preparation of a long playoff run. LeBron, via Dave McMenamin of ESPN “No,” James said Saturday when asked if he was concerned that planned rest could affect his MVP case. “Because Steph played 31 minutes a game and he won the MVP.” “Well, I’ve never set into a season saying I want to win MVP,” he said. “I’ve always thought of the season saying I want to be MVP for my team and it’s resulted in me getting four of them. So I’ve been available, for the most part, every night and I’ve been available on

  • NFL Winners and Losers: Time to place Matthew Stafford among NFL's best

    It only seems like Matthew Stafford has been quarterback of the Detroit Lions forever. Stafford is still fairly young. He’s 28. Sunday’s game was his 100th NFL start. We expect instant results from our quarterbacks, but players are still allowed to improve

    Shutdown Corner
  • The tragic story of the champion Jewish fencer who fought for Hitler

    She represented Germany at the 1928 Amsterdam Summer Olympics, bringing home a gold medal. Four years later, she competed in the Los Angeles Games. Two hours before her final matches, she learned that her boyfriend had died in a military training accident. She finished fifth. Mayer stayed in California and attended college for international law, hoping to perhaps become a diplomat for her country one day. In 1933, Hitler and the Nazi Party took power in Germany, and quickly set to work stripping away the rights of Jewish citizens — including Mayer, whose father was Jewish. Mayer’s membership in her hometown fencing club was revoked, and it became clear she could not return to Germany. The former

  • Coaches Poll: Michigan takes Ohio State’s spot behind Alabama as Buckeyes drop

    After slipping on the road against Penn State, Ohio State took a slight fall in the coaches poll this week. The Buckeyes dropped from second in the poll behind top-ranked Alabama to eighth. Adding salt to the wound, Michigan took over the second spot in the poll previously occupied by Ohio State. Clemson remained at third in the poll and Washington moved into the top four. Arkansas and Ole Miss dropped out of the rankings this week, making room for Colorado and Virginia Tech. Houston, despite a blowout loss at SMU, remained in the top 25 at No. 24. Here is this week’s coaches poll, with first-place votes noted: Alabama (63) Michigan Clemson (1) Washington Louisville Nebraska Baylor Ohio State

    NBC Sports: CollegeFootballTalk
  • Michael Crabtree touched his shoulder and was flagged for unsportsmanlike conduct

    Michael Crabtree is one unsportsmanlike conduct penalty from an automatic ejection after getting penalized for doing nothing wrong. Oakland Raiders wide receiver Michael Crabtree wasn’t able to avoid the penalty Sunday, even though he didn’t even do one. Crabtree celebrated a 2-yard touchdown pass against the Jacksonville Jaguars just before halftime by tossing the ball.

    SB Nation
  • Clayton Kershaw struggles again in postseason during Game 6 loss

    The “Clayton Kershaw can’t pitch in the postseason” narrative is alive and well. After coming up big during the Los Angeles Dodgers’ first two playoff series, Kershaw was saddled with the loss as the Chicago Cubs beat the Dodgers 5-0 in Game 6 of the National League Championship Series. With the Dodgers facing elimination, the 28-year-old ace gave up five runs, four earned, on seven hits over five innings.

    Big League Stew
  • NFL FANTASY - Charles and Ware battle it out in the K.C. backfield

    Yahoo Sports Fantasy Football expert Liz Loza breaks down the battle between Jamaal Charles and Spencer Ware in the K.C. backfield.

    Yahoo Sports Videos
  • Duncan-less Spurs eager for another run at NBA postseason

    SAN ANTONIO (AP) — The San Antonio Spurs responded to their most successful regular season in franchise history with the greatest turnover in Gregg Popovich’s two decades with the team. Tim Duncan’s retirement played a large role in the reconstruction, but so did losing in six games to Oklahoma City in the Western Conference semifinals. Duncan is gone along with veterans Boris Diaw, Matt Bonner and late-season additions Andre Miller and Kevin Martin. While San Antonio added another veteran in Pau Gasol, they also brought in a lot of youth and athleticism as they prepared for life without Duncan, the power forward who led the franchise to five NBA titles in 19 seasons. “Right now we don’t know

  • Gracie Gold addresses issues of weight, physical shape in skating

    Dressed in sparkling gold, Gracie Gold arrived at Skate America, the kickoff event of the new figure skating season, hoping to reassert herself as the nation’s pre-eminent skater 16 months before the 2018 Winter Olympic Games. Instead, she followed a shaky short program Friday evening with a poor long program Saturday afternoon, falling twice to drop to fifth place in the 11-woman field, finishing 12 points behind the winner, Ashley Wagner, her American teammate and rival who is still riding the momentum of winning the world silver medal last spring. Within minutes of leaving the ice, Gold, 21, the two-time U.S. national champion, spoke alarmingly about the pressure she feels. “We just need to adjust my physical shape and mental shape to see if the program can be salvaged for the rest of the year,” she said.

    USA Today
  • Report: Yi Jianlian has asked for release, will be waived by Lakers

    On paper, Chinese center Yi Jianlian made a lot of sense for the Lakers, especially in Luke Walton’s system — he was the only floor spacing big on the roster. Watching Yi at the Olympics, it was easy to imagine it working out for him in the NBA this time around. In practice, he was struggling to find a consistent role with the team. He had averaged less than 11 minutes a game in the preseason, shooting 35 percent overall and 16.7 percent from three. His defense wasn’t good, and he remains a player who doesn’t exactly have a high motor. With Julius Randle, Larry Nance, Timofey Mozgov, and Tarik Black, Yi wasn’t finding a consistent niche. So he has asked out of his contract and the Lakers are