Advertisement

High Fives: Lining up the outfield

In conjunction with our Outfield position primer, Brandon Funston, Dalton Del Don and Scott Pianowski offer their top-5 takes on various topics concerning the fantasy outfield positions, including the outfielders that are most overvalued and undervalued for '15 drafts, as well as a nod to both the future and the past. Let's get to it ...

[Yahoo Sports Fantasy Baseball: Sign up and join a league today!]

Top 5 outfield draft values, based on Yahoo ADP

1. Avisail Garcia - His power/speed game is primed for a breakout - 242.6 ADP a filthy bargain

1. A.J. Pollock Had a .302-41-7-24-14 line over 75 games last season. Plays in terrific hitter's park

1. Michael Brantley Five categories outside Top 25 ADP, yes please

2.  Melky Cabrera  - Good lineup, good park, track record of outperforming current ADP

2. Marcel OzunaHave him as a top-25 OF, but he's not being drafted close to that

2. Charlie Blackmon - The Regression Police went too far; at 77 ADP, I'm buying

3. Mookie Betts - Fantasy-friendly skills and environment

3. Joc Pederson Legit ROY candidate

3. Yelich/OzunaEmerging talents, screened by The Stanton Show

4. A.J. Pollock - Round 20 ADP crazy cheap for a guy that has legit .280/15/25 upside

4. Steve PearceI'm apparently more of a believer in last year's breakout than most

4. Melky CabreraA mere duplication of 2014 makes him mad bargain

5. Ben Revere - Explain to me why you'd take Hamilton when Revere can be had 100 picks later

5. Drew Stubbs No current starting role but had 15 homers/20 steals in 388 ABs last year

5. J.D. Martinez Low-walk, solid-average players often misunderstood. Hits ball hard consistently

 

Bottom 5 outfield draft values, based on Yahoo ADP

1. Billy Hamilton - Not paying top 50 price for a one-cat player who hit .200 post AS break

1. Justin UptonNot a big fan of spending a third round pick on a RHB who plays in PETCO Park

1. Yoenis CespedesMore name than game; .263 hitter, steals not bettable

2. Michael Brantley - His top 30 tag assumes that 20/20 is his new normal - I'm not so sure

2. Nelson CruzComing off a career-year at age 34 and moving to a worse hitter's park

2. Hunter PenceWhy go out of way to meet an injury issue?

3. Justin Upton - Paying for a name brand - Doesn't run much, and Petco going to hurt his bat

3. Alex Rios - Had 4 HRs in nearly 500 ABs last year in Texas

3. Matt Kemp Arthritic hips, worst of all ballparks

4. Brett Gardner - Unlikely to sustain his HR/FB rate from '14 - no longer a big SB booster

4. Josh HamiltonHe's borderline undraftable

4. Matt HollidayRather be a year early than a year late

5. Austin Jackson - For fantasy purposes, he's a one-cat player (Runs) and even that's a maybe

5. Rusney Castillo Like his potential but real chance he opens year in minors

5. Alex RiosPop a concern, steals tough to trust into age-34 season

 

Top 5 combined HR+SB bets for '15 among the OF-eligible crowd

1. Billy Hamilton - I'll call it 7 HRs and 55 SBs

1. Mike TroutHe's running less, but has averaged 63.7 HR+SB over his first 3 seasons

1. Carlos GomezThree years in a row, can’t be denied. Defense also dreamy

2. Mike Trout - I'll call it 35 HRs and 25 SBs

2. Billy HamiltonHis O/U for SBs alone is probably around 59.5

2. Mike Trout How much does he feel like running?

3. Carlos Gomez - I'll call it 22 HRs and 32 SBs

3. Carlos Gomez - Has averaged 59 HR+SB over past 3 seasons

3. Andrew McCutchenDoes everything well, including stay healthy

4. George Springer - I'll call it 29 HRs and 19 SBs

4. George Springer ZiPS projects 26 HRs and 17 SBs in just 113 games

4. Jacoby Ellsbury - Case of Two Jakes - didn’t hit on road last year

5. Andrew McCutchen - I'll call it 26 HRs and 19 SBs

5. Andrew McCutchenTempted to go Giancarlo Stanton but 'Cutch seems safer.

5. George Springer Look for more confidence on bases this time around

 

Top 5 projected fantasy rookie outfielders for '15

1. Jorge Soler - Great athlete with huge power and an idea of what he's doing at the plate

1. Jorge Soler He's the real deal and will be hitting in the middle of a suddenly potent looking Cubs lineup

1. Jorge Soler Loaded organization, could raise a flag before decade ends

2. Rusney Castillo - BOS outfield is crowded but a Victorino trade/injury is bettable

2. Joc Pederson BA risk but ZiPS projects a 20/20 season in fewer than 140 games

2. Joc Pederson Don’t mess with him, Mattingly

3. Joc Pederson - .303/33/30 line in 121 minor league games damn impressive, even in PCL

3. Yasmany TomasWill help playing in one of the best hitter's parks in baseball

3. Steven Souza Traded into a job, 15-15 or 20-20 isn’t a stretch

4. Yasmany Tomas - Becoming easier and easier to bank on power-packed Cuban imports

4. Rusney Castillo - Not a fan of his ADP, but Castillo has major upside if things break right

4. Dalton Pompey Toolsy switch-hitter was a fast riser in 2014

5. Steven Souza - Will get chance in TB to see if his 20/20 skills translate to MLB

5. Dalton PompeyCould reach 30+ steals this year. Great first name

5. Michael Taylor - First call when injury strikes; needs to work on contact rate

 

Top 5 least favorite MLB outfielders of all-time

1. Barry Bonds - Forget PEDs, he had a severely narcissistic personality that only a myopic Giants fan could pardon

1. Ty Cobb - Was a bit before my time but seemingly an awful human being

1. J.D. Drew Marsellus Wallace stole his soul, stashed it in a briefcase

2. Barry Bonds - My cup of haterade for Bonds runneth over - he needs two spots on my list

2. Yasiel Puig - He nearly fought MadBum! I'm sure I'd love him if he were on my team though

2. Jim EdmondsA master of making catches look much harder than they really were

3. Paul O'Neill - King of the pouty face

3. Elijah Dukes - Kept buying in and spending big on him. Despicable dude

3. Carl CrawfordSigns huge contract, then tells you everything he doesn’t want to do

4. Jose Canseco - What a meathead

4. Nyjer Morgan - Tony Plush! OK, he's kind of awesome, but there was this

4. Milton Bradley Go back to your own planet

5. Jonny Gomes - Definition of hell is being forced to watch a video of his tick-laden pre-pitch preparation over and over

5. Not Barry Bonds - If anyone picks Bonds in this category, they are dead to me

5. Gregg Jefferies None of his teammates liked him, either