What's buzzing:

Dose: Jumbo clears Hertl

Rotoworld
Dose: Jumbo clears Hertl
.

View photo

Wednesday's Hockey Dose weighs the pros and cons of jumping on the Tomas Hertl bandwagon. Biggest pro: …

In the past few Hockey Doses, the messages have been pretty consistent: don’t panic, don’t overreact and don’t blow everything up. This time around, I’m going to focus on the second part of a key point I made on Tuesday:

Don’t blow up your foundation. Instead, focus on smaller tweaks.

Generally speaking, it’s best to take bigger risks in the “smaller tweaks” area earlier in the season. That’s because the waiver wire is far more robust with players people either a) don’t trust yet, b) haven’t caught on to or c) haven’t gotten around to adding. (Some might only check their leagues once a week, or less.)

As much as I’ve trumpeted the need to take high shooting percentage guys with a grain of salt, it’s also true that every now and then, a guy makes a legitimate breakthrough. Wouldn’t you rather drop a bit player who won’t really move the needle much either way for a guy with a higher ceiling and lower floor?

The higher-ceiling, lower-floor guy I’m talking about is San Jose Sharks rookie Tomas Hertl.

Editor's Note: Rotoworld's partner FanDuel is hosting a one-day $4,000 Fantasy Hockey league tonight (Wednesday). It's just $10 to join and first prize is $500. Starts at 8pm ET. Here's the link.

Also don’t forget, for everything NHL, check out Rotoworld's Player News and follow @Rotoworld_ HK + @cyclelikesedins on Twitter.

Oh, and there’s still plenty of time to join a Yahoo! Hockey Pool, so get on that.

THE PROS

Now, I’m not going to say that I predicted Hertl would have a jaw-dropping four-goal night, which included an absolutely mind-blowing finale. The most I can say is that I targeted him as a player to watch on Oct. 4.

This isn’t about half-hearted horn-tooting; instead, the point is that Hertl’s not quite as out-of-left-field as some might label him.

JUMBO JUMP

The reason why Hertl’s general success isn’t shocking is that he’s lining up with Joe Thornton and Brent Burns.

Thornton no longer ranks in the absolute uppercrust of NHL forwards, but he’s still really good. One would be foolish to overlook how much he’s helped other scorers, most notably including:

Jonathan Cheechoo: Peaked with 56 goals riding shotgun alongside Thornton in 2005-06, earning a Maurice Richard Trophy.

Glen Murray: Scored 111 goals in 236 games during his best years with Thornton in Boston from 2001-02 to 2003-04 versus 226 in the 773 other games in his career. (Basically going from a goal every two games versus a .3 goal-per-game average.)

Those are probably the two most dramatic differences, but the takeaway remains that Thornton is like a great QB who augments the abilities of WRs in ways that can be downright misleading.

TALENT

The Sharks selected Hertl 17th overall in 2012, so it’s not like he’s some nobody.

THE CONS

-- He’s averaging less than 15 minutes per night with an unsustainable 46.2 shooting percentage.

-- Hertl didn’t dominate overseas (less than a point-per-game), so it’s easy to argue that his impressive run won’t last.

-- He’s also just 19.

-- The Sharks possess other talented forwards, but if he drops out of the top six, his outlook changes drastically. (Thornton!)

-- San Jose’s one of the few teams that has the stones to decide Hertl needs more time to develop outside of the NHL after nine games, especially if he doesn’t produce much after this amazing night.

RECENT BREAKOUTS

Perhaps we need some other examples, then? Since 2005-06, 21 other players (18 active) have produced a four-goal game. The list includes some obvious stars such as Alex Ovechkin (twice) and Ilya Kovalchuk - some of which might have been breaking out - but the most interesting examples are:

-- Jussi Jokinen - four goals for Dallas, Nov. 16, 2007 (age: 24) - Hey, Jokinen had a hat trick last night, too! Jokinen’s career has been awfully interesting since that four-goal night, as he’s accomplished the goal of proving he’s more than just a shootout specialist, but he hasn’t quite been able to stick with a team in a comfortable way.

-- Lars Eller might be the most interesting parallel of them all. (Four goals, one assist for Montreal on January 4, 2012 at age 22).

Like Hertl, he was mid-first round draft pick (13th overall by the Blues in 2007). Eller has some intriguing linemates in Alex Galchenyuk and Brendan Gallagher, but it remains to be seen if he can stay within striking distance of the pace he's generated so far. Like Hertl, Eller is talented, but both need the right mix of injury luck, positive bounces and opportunities to make the most of things.

-- Sam Gagner four goals (and four assists) for Edmonton on that memorable day in Feb. 2, 2012 (age 22).

The dream scenario is for this to be Hertl’s “Gagner moment,” bypassing the awkward first few years Gagner experienced in Edmonton. It’s difficult to dispute the notion that Gagner found his confidence following that historic outburst, especially following it all up successfully last season (when he took advantage of a big opportunity to showcase his skills by scoring 38 points in 48 games).

OVERALL

No doubt, logic says that Hertl will flatten out.

Really, though, the situation is promising enough - he’s lining up with Big Bird! - that I’m not really against giving him a short-term pickup. He’s currently owned in just 31 percent of leagues, but that’s likely to change by the merit of his highlight reel goal alone. If he doesn’t work out, you can drop him for a stable-but-not-very-exciting guy instead.

Let’s not forget the moments when you just said “aw, why not?” and rolled the dice with a depth position. Personally, I most fondly remember grabbing Eric Staal, Henrik Lundqvist and Cheechoo in the extremely early stages of their breakthroughs and reaped some serious rewards.

Plus … he’s playing with Joe Thornton.

After the jump: game notes from a busy Tuesday.

SAN JOSE 9, NY RANGERS 2

-- If Rangers fans weren’t miserable enough, it looks like Rick Nash suffered an upper-body injury from a Brad Stuart hit. He dealt with a concussion at the hands of Milan Lucic last season, so this is very worrisome. Hey, at least that horrible road trip can’t last forever, though … right? (Laughs nervously.)

VANCOUVER 3, NEW JERSEY 2 (OT)

-- Cory Schneider wins the battle (Tuesday's game), but Roberto Luongo wins the war (getting to start most nights). Well, at least as much as Luongo can win while still being in Vancouver ...

-- OK, I'll admit it: I'm warming up considerably to the plus side of the "Czech connection" between Jaromir Jagr and Patrik Elias. So much hockey IQ, so little foot speed ...

PHILADELPHIA 2, FLORIDA 1

-- Someone in Philadelphia: "See, they just needed to fire that lousy coach! Everything's OK now."

-- Tim Thomas left the game with a lower-body injury, not shocking since he's been out of action so long. Your patience with this situation should depend largely on the quality of other options on your waiver wire. Unless he just snaps and retires, of course.

-- Maybe Steve Mason's worth owning after all? (It hurt just to type that.) In all seriousness, it seems like he's pulling away from Ray Emery.

NASHVILLE 3, MINNESOTA 2

-- I was actually in the building for this one, so I'll roll with a few more gut reactions than usual.

-- For one thing, Ryan Suter's subtle greatness really stands out in person in a way that reminds me of Nicklas Lidstrom. I'm not saying Suter's as good as the Supercomputer On Skates, just that he's remarkably efficient and can blind you with breakout passes. Too bad he’s not a little more trigger-happy, though ...

-- Niklas Backstrom was banged up in the game, forcing Josh Harding to jump into a penalty shot situation (his only goal allowed by sneaky-solid depth guy Eric Nystrom). Minnesota's goaltending situation is beyond worrisome if Backstrom’s issue is substantial.

-- Colin Wilson and Filip Forsberg are the forwards to watch in Nashville, though that might be more about the future than the present. We’ll see.

-- Seth Jones is a weird mix of raw and ready. Another “we’ll see” there, at least in term of this season. (All signs point to a bright future.)

-- Zach Parise's never shy to shoot, and fantasy owners should love him for that.

PITTSBURGH 5, CAROLINA 2

-- Jussi Jokinen is just one of those guys who can explode at any time and go ice cold just as easily. He's tempting on a team like Pittsburgh, but I'd be worried about how James Neal's return may eventually submarine his (or Beau Bennett's?) value.

-- If the Hurricanes had the courage and/or fear of failure, they'd give Anton Khudobin a chance to at least earn a platoon situation. Cam Ward's really struggled in recent years, so why not?

COLORADO 2, TORONTO 1

-- Can't say I expected these flawed-but-explosive teams to combine for a paltry three goals, but kudos goes to Semyon Varlamov and Jonathan Bernier, two goalies who are probably starting to make their fan bases excited. (Dark times for James Reimer owners, eh?)

-- It kind of blows my mind that P. A. Parenteau isn't lining up much with Matt Duchene after their great 2013 (often the only bright spot for the Avs), but it's working for Colorado, especially for Nathan MacKinnon (four assists already).

-- Phil Kessel's early season puck luck is once again weirdly awful; he has one measly goal to show for 22 SOG.

NY ISLANDERS 6, PHOENIX 1

-- Michael Grabner is one of those confounding guys. He has a 34 and 20-goal season to his name in just three full campaigns, yet it's important to note that he's in the Jeff Carter/Sean Bergenheim class of guys who often score more goals than collect assists. He has 77 tallies vs. just 45 helpers in his career, so there's an "all or nothing" feel to his game, especially since he doesn't generate many PIM and isn't a SOG hog. That speed is enticing, though.

-- Maybe I owe Evgeni Nabokov an apology, as he's enjoyed a great start so far. I expect him to be a quantity-over-quality guy overall, and for where he's probably being drafted, there's no shame in that at all. Anything more is gravy.

-- The Coyotes are a low-budget team whose system can really inflate a goalie's stats, yet they gave injury-prone and up-and-down goalie Mike Smith a typical huge franchise deal. Baffling.

TAMPA BAY 3, BUFFALO 2 (OT)

-- By most accounts, Victor Hedman is already a good defenseman, though he's middling in fantasy. His first three games don't provide overwhelming evidence that he'll do much better this season, but at least it's early.

-- Ben Bishop could be worth a look if you need a third goalie. He's been steady on a team that can still figure things out, especially if they figure out that Anders Lindback is in a tough spot.

-- It's probably foolish to expect much from guys not named Thomas Vanek, Ryan Miller or Cody Hodgson. Buffalo is squalid.

For a full injury list, click here.

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Football
View Comments (12)