Advertisement

August 1B and DH Rankings

Nate Grimm takes a look at some overvalued players in the NL West, including Carlos Gonzalez, Shelby Miller and Matt Kemp

Here’s the August rankings update. Players are ranked for the rest of the season based on a 5x5 scoring format. Included along with the position rankings is an updated top 300. Players are listed at the position at which they’re most valuable.

Click to see other August rankings:

Top 300 | SP | RP | OF | 1B | 2B | SS | 3B | C | DH

Follow us at @Rotoworld_BB and @matthewpouliot on Twitter.



First Baseman and Designated Hitter Rankings

Aug

First Base

Team

2015

May

June

July

1

Paul Goldschmidt

Diamondbacks

4

3

2

2

2

Jose Abreu

White Sox

2

2

3

4

3

Edwin Encarnacion

Blue Jays

3

4

4

3

4

Anthony Rizzo

Cubs

7

5

5

5

5

Joey Votto

Reds

11

6

8

9

6

Albert Pujols

Angels

6

9

10

6

7

Prince Fielder

Rangers

5

8

6

7

8

Mark Teixeira

Yankees

28

23

13

12

9

Adrian Gonzalez

Dodgers

8

7

7

8

10

Miguel Cabrera

Tigers

1

1

1

1

11

Freddie Freeman

Braves

9

11

12

10

12

Eric Hosmer

Royals

12

10

9

11

13

David Ortiz

Red Sox

1 DH

1 DH

1 DH

1 DH

14

Lucas Duda

Mets

14

12

11

14

15

Victor Martinez

Tigers

10

14

19

13

16

Brandon Belt

Giants

15

18

14

15

17

Kendrys Morales

Royals

24

22

15

18

18

Adam LaRoche

White Sox

17

17

17

17

19

Joe Mauer

Twins

16

16

18

19

20

Brandon Moss

Cardinals

19

21

20

20

21

Mike Napoli

Red Sox

22

25

22

23

22

Adam Lind

Brewers

20

20

21

22

23

Jesus Montero

Mariners

7 DH

3 DH

3 DH

2 DH

24

Ryan Howard

Phillies

25

31

25

26

25

Chris Carter

Astros

2 DH

15

16

16

26

Chris Colabello

Blue Jays

50

NR

29

25

27

Justin Bour

Marlins

48

NR

32

40

28

Ben Paulsen

Rockies

47

NR

36

28

29

Mitch Moreland

Rangers

35

37

30

30

30

Billy Butler

Athletics

21

24

26

29

31

C.J. Cron

Angels

34

36

NR

NR

32

Yonder Alonso

Padres

30

27

27

24

33

Ike Davis

Athletics

31

29

28

27

34

James Loney

Rays

26

28

34

31

35

Nick Swisher

Indians

33

35

31

36

36

Logan Morrison

Mariners

23

26

24

21

37

Mark Canha

Athletics

39

30

35

33

38

Clint Robinson

Nationals

57

NR

40

38

39

Justin Smoak

Blue Jays

32

34

37

37

40

Justin Morneau

Rockies

18

19

23

34

41

Adam Duvall

Reds

43

NR

NR

NR

42

Travis Shaw

Red Sox

80

NR

NR

NR

43

Darin Ruf

Phillies

42

40

NR

NR

44

Kyle Blanks

Rangers

37

33

33

39

45

Tyler Moore

Nationals

41

NR

39

NR

First Basemen

Dropping off: Jon Singleton (32nd), Kennys Vargas (35th), Garrett Jones (41st), Xavier Scruggs (42nd), Efren Navarro (43rd)

o I don’t like having Abreu as high as second. Nor do I like having Gonzalez as low as ninth. They’re all bunched together in there, and I still think Abreu and Encarnacion have the best chance of standing out the rest of the way, even if they’re lagging behind Votto and Teixeira at the moment.

o Last week’s trades didn’t lead to much of a shakeup here. Moss was the only starter dealt, and his value didn’t really change with the move from Cleveland to St. Louis. Surprisingly, Lind stuck around in Milwaukee. That’s not a bad thing for him; he might have wound up in a better lineup elsewhere, but it likely would have been a worse ballpark.

o With Morrison struggling mightily in July and banged up, Montero figures to be up for a serious look in Seattle. Morrison hasn’t done enough to justify being brought back next year anyway, so the Mariners might as well find out whether Montero should be in their plans for 2016. The 25-year-old was hitting .346/.388/.551 with 16 homers in 376 at-bats in Triple-A. He’s far from a lock to contribute in mixed leagues, but I wouldn’t be surprised if he’s of some use.

o Duvall is a sleeper here after going from the Giants to the Reds in the Mike Leake deal, though he didn’t immediately get the break he needed in the form of a Jay Bruce or Marlon Byrd trade. Bruce is likely off the table now, but the Reds could still trade Byrd this month, and if they do, Duvall is their best choice to take over in left field. He wouldn’t hit for average in the majors, but he could smack some homers given the chance.