Cagewriter - UFC

The officiating became a big story at UFC 96. Rightly so with what appeared to be an early stoppage and a very late stoppage. Would Dana White have been better served taking a more level-headed approach with the referee issues that arose during the event? New York is examining the safety of the sport as it decides whether to sanction mixed martial arts. Why would Empire State politicians think the sport is safe if its biggest name promoter is saying there are only three qualified referees in the entire country?

White told the media throng after UFC 96 that the state of officiating is sad (video- 4:00 mark):

"There's a couple of guys that are real good but there are a whole bunch that aren't."

White only named Yves Lavigne, Herb Dean and Mario Yamasaki as competent refs. He mistakenly mentioned Steve Mazzagatti and then corrected himself. You have to wonder what Marc Ratner, former athletic commish in Nevada, currently a UFC VP was thinking when he heard White say there are very few qualified referees for MMA. How does he answer that question if it's posed by Bob Reilly, the N.Y. State Assemblyman? Reilly is fighting hard to keep MMA on the sidelines and is looking for all the ammo he can throw at his co-horts. Afterall, these are the guys who are charge of the fighters' safety in the cage.

Cage Potato spoke with fellow N.Y. Assemblyman Jonathan Bing, who said the N.Y. state legislative session is finished in June and right now the vote stands at roughly 50-50 on legalizing MMA. Bing, who is pro-MMA, also says 2010 may be the earliest we see an MMA event in New York.

While we're on the issue of qualified refs in the UFC and MMA. Can we please stop saying the UFC needs to re-hire Big John McCarthy? BJM (pictured w/Randy Couture) was forced at the end of 2007 to leave officiating once he decided to pursue a career in broadcasting. He's now returned and is eligible to reapply in the 36 states where MMA is legal. The UFC has no veto power over whether McCarthy officiates its fights and can't "re-hire" him. Each state has a stable of approved officials and can appoint anyone it wants to work the cards.

The same goes for Mazzagatti. It's been suggested that "The Stache" isn't working UFC fights anymore. That's inaccurate, he's slated to officiate at UFC 98 and 100 in Nevada. Watch out Brock Lesnar! Just kidding, it's very unusual for any ref to work a rematch as is the case with Frank Mir and Lesnar, so he won't be working that fight. White can trash "The Stache" all he wants, Mazzagatti is still part of the Nevada crew. McCarthy isn't and right now there isn't an opening for a job in the Silver State. That said, it would be wise for states to get McCarthy in the fold. It would also help if BJM works on rebuilding the image that he is objective.

digg delicious
more

13 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. MMA4Life
    1. Posted by MMA4Life Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:28 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Hopefully this will not stop NY and other places from getting the UFC since they need to show that the UFC is truly growing like they claim.
  2. KJ-MMA Armchair
    2. Posted by KJ-MMA Armchair Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:52 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Yeah, it's easy to point at UFC for the referees chosen. Although they DO choose referees when they go to the UK, which makes you wonder why they keeping using Dan Mirglialotta since he's one of the most incompetant refs I've seen. Maybe he's cheap.
    However, you have to wonder how experienced these referees are. The SAC's should really pick refs that have had something like 100 matches minimum on the smaller shows without cause for concern before picking them for the big show. Some of these guys that appear on UFC cards look like its their first night on the job.
    Big John's sanctioned in California I know that much. I've no idea how long it takes to get licensed in the states, particularly if you had to leave for whatever reason to start with.
  3. BearDown
    3. Posted by BearDown Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:23 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Here's an idea........ Instead of posting article/blog reruns; how about reporting on the process that is mapped out for refs to become qualified to work by the state athletic commisions. Didn't Ratface Ratner help in that process and recommended the route in which a ref has to take? Oh, wait.....that would actually be something news worthy. My mistake. I retort.
  4. mathiasmorciglio
    4. Posted by mathiasmorciglio Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't think all these new refs in MMA are "bad" as Dana suggested. I think it's more accurate to say "inexperienced". I don't think reffing a pro MMA fight is something you can just learn in a weekend seminar. Unfortunately curbstomp is right, Dana like's to run off at the mouth sometimes, and sometimes (usually) he talks before he thinks, and in this instance (as in many others) it looks like he's put his foot in his mouth.
  5. jasonp
    5. Posted by jasonp Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I agree mathiasmorciglio. I think that mma is still a relatively new sport (15 years maybe?) and there simply aren't as many places for refs to get the experience needed to become an expert. But if Dana is as concerned about it as he says and he really is speaking out of concern for his beloved sport, then why doesn't he invest in better training for refs? The guy's loaded and the Fertelli's (Goonies..... anyone?....... anyone?..... Bueller?) are frickin' BILLIONAIRES for Pete's sake! Stop your bit@%*& and open a flippin MMA Referee Training facility if you're so damn concerned.
  6. Shaun T
    6. Posted by Shaun T Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:17 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Why doesn't White like Mazzagatti?
  7. HAHA
    7. Posted by HAHA Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    when i first read dana comments i thought the same
    thats like stern or goddell critizing refs
    but its the TRUTH so what does it matter
    its always betta to keep it real
    and who gives a damn about NY
    UFC/MMA is going to flourish with out NY
    it has jus been passed in Pennslyvania
    and im boosted about that, Philly a real fight town
    I will be visiting my cuzins out there and checkin out the UFC events when they get there
    i hope it gets passed in D.C. soon too, then I wont have to travel HAHA
  8. HAHA
    8. Posted by HAHA Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    when i first read dana comments i thought the same
    thats like stern or goddell critizing refs
    but its the TRUTH so what does it matter
    its always betta to keep it real
    and who gives a damn about NY
    UFC/MMA is going to flourish with out NY
    it has jus been passed in Pennslyvania
    and im boosted about that, Philly a real fight town
    I will be visiting my cuzins out there and checkin out the UFC events when they get there
    i hope it gets passed in D.C. soon too, then I wont have to travel HAHA
  9. HAHA
    9. Posted by HAHA Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Double Post MY BAD
    but since I did
    whjat do u guys think of Matt Hughes sayin he wants to go to MW to face Spider?
  10. The Unsilent Majority
    10. Posted by The Unsilent Majority Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:01 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I bet if Dana pitched women's MMA in a chocolate pudding-filled kiddie pool wearing bikinis that Mr. Reilly would be on board in an instant...or would it have to be prostitutes, too?
  11. IDGAD
    11. Posted by IDGAD Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Dana overstated the situation but not by too much. If you don't think there should be any refs, then go back to martial arts cartoons. There's a lot to dislike about Dana but he's not boring. He's got a 'motor' and that was and still is, to a degree, needed. Without his drive (ego, obsession, etc..) you'd have bupkas on TV. He needs to 'grow' if he truly expects to go mainstream. I don't think MMA can do so and still be of interest to many current and past followers, however.
  12. Todd D
    12. Posted by Todd D Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:57 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Posting this article just brings attention to the fact. So really, this just adds to the possible negative coverage it may or may not receive.
  13. fightchica
    13. Posted by fightchica Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:53 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    What I say is: HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA.
    Spider will own Hughes. He has way too much of a reach advantage, (arms and legs) and if Hughes takes it to the ground Anderson will lock those long legs around his neck and that will be that. Spider by triangle submission.

Cagewriter

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Steve Cofield

Cagewriter is an MMA blog edited by Steve Cofield. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Contributors:
Maggie Hendricks, Zak Jensen,

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Cagewriter Recent Readers