Tue Aug 05, 2008 7:31 pm EDT
The heat is on MMA ref Steve Mazzagatti (pictured w/stache) in this week leading up to UFC 87. The formerly mustacheiod Mazzagatti's competence has been called into question more than few times by media, fans and most importantly Brock Lesnar.
Lesnar spoke with ProMMARadio's Larry Pepe and basically called Mazzagatti a clown for his actions early on in the loss to Frank Mir. Lesnar grazed the back of Mir's head with just one punch. Instead of issuing a verbal warning, Mazzagatti stopped the fight with only 25 seconds elapsed and deducted a point from Lesnar.
"It's just an consistency in the reffing by that particular referee. Every fight that I ever watch him ref there's a lot of inconsistency. I'm not naming any names."
CLICK BELOW TO HEAR PART OF THE LESNAR INTERVIEW (w/Pepe on ProMMARadio):
Listen to the entire Lesnar conversation here. Brock questions the legitimacy of Kimbo Slice, talks about his training and say that his opponent at UFC 87 Heath Herring is a poor wrestler. There's also much discussion of Jake O'Brien's wrestling domination of Herring.
It's not easy being an MMA official. You've got to protect the fighters' safety but also let fights reach their legitimate conclusion. The real problem with Mazzagatti's Lesnar point deduction was the fact that he strayed from his normal reffing philosophy. He's generally known as a guy who lets action go. New Jersey-based Dan Mirgaliotta has his critics, but more often that not when something goofy happens, Mazzagatti is at the center of the storm. A quick search of the internet indicates that Mazzagatti may be the most highly criticized official in MMA.
1. Jamie Varner v. Rob McCullough @ WEC 32
Varner loses his mouthpiece and actually stops fighting then signals his own timeout. Varner, who looked wobbly, is actually granted a stoppage by Mazzagatti.
2. Kevin Burns v. Anthony Johnson @ UFN 14
Burns clearly poked Johnson in the right eye. Johnson went down in a heap. Mazzagatti stopped the fight awarding a TKO victory to Burns.
3. Gray Maynard v. Rob Emerson @ TUF 5 Finale
Maynard slammed Emerson but in the process knocked himself out. The win is initially given to Maynard before ringside officials cleared things up for Mazzagatti and the fight was ruled a no-contest.
4. Jamie Varner v. Marcus Hicks @ WEC 35
This is the type of fight where Mazzagatti scares some people. Hicks was knocked down and out with 3:12 left in the first round. He then took 19 additional punches and three knees to the face before the fight is stopped 20 seconds later.
5. Mike Whitehead v. Vernon White at IFL - Las Vegas
Whitehead had White's back and rained down punches. He then told Mazzagatti that White had tapped. Mazzagatti clearly didn't see it but honored Whitehead's 'official' call and stopped it. Coach Ken Shamrock is seen on the ring apron screaming at Mazzagatti, "that was a horrible f**kin call!"
6. Shayna Baszler v. Cristiane Santos @ Elite XC
Santos knocked down Baszler with 1:31 left in the first then prematurely celebrated her victory by jumping on the top of the cage. Santos carried on for 13 seconds while Mazzagatti stood in the middle of the ring and screamed "hey" in Santos' direction to keep fighting. The Portuguese-speaking Santos had no idea what Mazzagatti was saying. Instead of a disqualification, Santos was allowed to come back down from the cage and the action was restarted around 1:08. Santos went on to finish Baszler.
7. Babalu v. David Heath @ UFC 74
The pre-fight included a war of words between the fighters. Babalu got in position for an anaconda choke finish. Mazzagatti stopped he fight and Heath held onto the choke for an extra three seconds. Some think Mazzagatti didn't do all he could to force Babalu to stop.
8. Thiago Alves v. Karo Parisyan @ UFN 13
Alves stopped Parisyan with one big knee and then two punches on his arm. Parisyan was beside himself and actually pushed UFC fight booker Joe Silva several times in the cage as he protested the Mazzagatti stoppage.
Mazzagatti seems like a nice guy and showed a good sense of humor during this 2007 interview with MMAMania.com. Although this guy is a little crazy with his top 45 reasons he hates Mazzagatti. The ref does need to tighten things up or he's going to become an unfair target for many fight fans.
Cagewriter is an MMA blog edited by Steve Cofield. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

UFC 109 Randy Couture talks about his submission win
Posted Feb 7 2010
UFC 109 Post-fight press conference comments from Dana White
Posted Feb 7 2010
UFC 109 post-fight press conference with Demian Maia
Posted Feb 7 2010
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Brooks Peck
Edited by Andy Behrens
43 Comments
1 - 25 of 43
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
But, let's give the man some well earned respect! Here's a guy that gave up making millions a year because he wanted to compete for real again. Walking away from a "cushy" (compared to the NFL or MMA), extremely high-paying job to put his health on the line because he likes to beat people up. I personally think that's very admirable and, even though I think Herring will win, I'm definately rooting for Brock.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Brock does need to suck it up. I do think the ref made a bad call as Steve M should have stood the fighters up, seperated them, given Muir a few to collect himself and given a very visible verbal warning, but that happens in every sport. The guys that are good suck it up, congradulate the winner and move on to fight another day.
Report Abuse
Lesnar will be very good, but it will take time. The UFC should have brought him along a little slower, but i understand the economics of why they didn't
Report Abuse
you are everything i hate about MMA fans..Lesnar with the proper training over time could become a legitimate fighter in the UFC, just because he was in WWE does not diminish the talent Lesnar has..this man is an all around athlete..agile, fast, tough...he is just a baby in this sport..give him some time and we will see what happens..he was fed to a top heavyweight in Mir and almost put him out in the first minute if it wasnt for the stoppage (whether right or wrong)...its easy to criticize someone of the caliber of Lesnar while sitting behind your computer..how about you try your luck in MMA and lets critique your every move
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
And re Whitehead. The fight was stopped by referee stoppage, not by tap out. Mazzagatti didn't honor Whitehead's call, he stopped it because White just turtled and stopped defending himself intelligently...unlike Marcus Hicks, who was probably dazed but was at least moving around and trying to get some breathing room.
Cofield complains he stopped the Whitehead fight too soon and the Varner fight too late, but their opponents' actions dictate otherwise.
Cofield needs to get his tabloid garbage out of Y! Sports and into Y! omg! instead. Some people here complain about Iole and Meltzer shilling for UFC. I don't think they do, but it's at least arguable. This Cofield guy, though...he takes the taco for just plain lousy journalism.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
and for those of you who talk about how his fighting style look at chucks he swings for the fences he looks like crap when hes tried cant strike on the spot powers gone look at the last round of the keith fight, brocks big, strong and thats what hes going to use hes going to over power them thats his game plan and if you were that big youd do that too so stop hatin
1 - 25 of 43