Thu Dec 11, 2008 2:00 pm EST
Describing the Fight for the Troops card as a mixed bag might be the nicest terminology someone in the mainstream media uses to recap the event. The Josh Koscheck and Mike Swick finishes were amazing. IFL-import Jim Miller was devastating in mauling a solid lightweight in Matt Wiman.
I've been covering MMA heavily since 2002 and there's only been one broken limb. Tim Sylvia's arm was snapped by Frank Mir at UFC 48. Most fighters know when to tap in a dangerous situation or the official protects the at-risk fighter from letting his own ego get in the way of safety. You had a lethal mix on live television last night with an inexperienced fighter and a tentative official.
I hate to dump on a guy who just had his arm broken but why was Razak Al Hassan given a fight in the UFC? By the looks of it, he didn't appear skilled enough to make the cut for a 32-man field to get on the The Ultimate Fighter. He shouldn't have been in there with someone like Steve Cantwell and he definitely shouldn't have been fighting on the televised portion of the card. If Al Hassan is not smart or experienced enough to tap then referee Mario Yamasaki had to err on the side of caution. He's way too experienced to allow that to happen to a fighter.
UPDATE: Al Hassan did NOT suffer a broken arm. His right elbow was dislocated but it was popped back into place last night. He may have suffered some ligament damage.
I will disagree with my Yahoo! Sports compadre Maggie Hendricks about Cantwell's role in this debacle. The kid was simply doing his job. His post-fight comments to Joe Rogan did lack some taste but I give him a pass. He's 22 and it's an emotional spot immediately following a fight.
The Al Hassan incident wasn't the only embarrassing piece of officiating on the night.
How many knees did Brandon Wolff need to take before referee Al Coley, working his first UFC card, was going to stop the fight? Apparently, there was no limit. Wolff was overmatched and had his face mashed in by Ben Saunders. Was it necessary for him to take 51 unanswered knees?
Cagewriter is an MMA blog edited by Steve Cofield. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Post Fight Presser ft WEC Featherweight Champion Jose Aldo
Posted Nov 19 2009
Dana White: Brock Lesnar is a unique fighter
Posted Nov 17 2009
Ben Saunders vs Marcus Davis for UFC 106 Glory
Posted Nov 17 2009
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by E. Brennan
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Andy Behrens
58 Comments
1 - 25 of 58
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
He needed to take them until he fell to the ground. The last thing we need is to see another stoppage while both fighters are still on their feet(Slice vs Thompson??). That stoppage was just fine.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Plain and simple its up to the fighter to tap! His other arm wasnt pinned or anything so he had no excuse not to tap. In prefight they said he had a TKD and BJJ background, so he should have been familiar with a armbar and versed in how to tap. He tried to be a tough guy and suffered the consequences.
Report Abuse
How many fellow MMA writers (including yourself) would jump all over Yamasaki if he had, as you have requested he should have done, stopped the fight due to the armbar BEFORE Al-Hassan tapped? My guess is most, if not all.
Even if Al-Hassan didn't deserve a shot in the UFC yet, the fact remains that he was 6-0 with four of those six wins coming by way of submission. Which tells me two things:
1. The most obvious. Al-Hassan has forced people to tapout. Thus, he knows the protocol for stopping a fight, and by association know how to do it himself. Pretty simple, pretty obvious.
and 2. With two-thirds of his wins being submissions, it is pretty safe to assume that he is well-versed in these submissions and should know when he himself is in a bad spot.
You CAN'T blame the referee for a fighter who isn't screaming in pain and isn't motioning for help (tapping). That is pure ignorance on both your part, and Razak Al-Hassan's.
As far as the Saunders-Wolff fight goes:
If you rewatch the the fight, the referee starts to stop it about a minute before the true finish, due to unanswered knees. However, Wolff broke the clinch (however momentarily) and showed no signs of "out on his feet" or anything of the sort. Not to mention the fact that Wolff was doing a pretty good (not great) job of defending (covering up) the intended target of the majority of those knees, which was his head.
Personally, I think you should just delete this particular entry from your blog because it honestly seems like you don't really know much about the sport. Furthermore, I don't understand why some of these MMA pundits are crying out due to the "level of violence" from last nights event. Last time I checked MMA is known as a combat sport. The word combat is also synonymous with the word violence. Pretty simple, pretty obvious.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
On the Al-Hassan arm-bar: It's snap or tap!... and he chose poorly. Although Cantwell's post-fight was crude, Hassan had one chance to tap before he transitioned to try and roll out before Cantwell really pulled at his arm.
Report Abuse
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hwp_JwwGPhc
Report Abuse
And hey Boys...What up with my hero Hughes???Huh??? what a stud out there being REAL with boys that got caught for real...That was AWSOME that means so much to those guys you have no idea..and you bag on him for a stupid shirt fopa...You should be ashamed....Hughes for president...
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
The guy with the afro should have tapped he had to feel it and he was versed in BJJ so that is entirley on him. As for the post fight comment he was hyped it is not like he did anything incorrectly like he broke his arm after he tapped. He clearly had the dudes arm isolated and was pulling back if you do not want your arm broken that is when you tapp obviously Al Hassain did not think Cantwell would goa ll the way with it and break his arm and Cantwell called his bluff I do not have a problem with it at all.
Also, why would the ref stop a fight right there? Horrible call dude wish I could get paid to make assanine comments about a sport I barley understand and have never come even remotley close to competeing/training for.
Report Abuse
seriously so many crybabies on here and including Coefield..this is a contact sport, stuff happens, its part of the sport if you dont like it dont watch it, but i think the refs did a good job, as for Al Hassad and Wolff, thats a whole other story
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Anyways, fighters have amateur records before they become "professional fighters" and I'm sure that was the case for Al Hassan. Yes his ground game was poor and yes he should have tapped, but Joel Silva is a professional and wouldn't sign a guy to fight with zero business being in the UFC.
Report Abuse
1 - 25 of 58