Arrieta finished a long pass from Tony Tchani in the 86th minute.
“It was really a good day to celebrate my (29th) birthday,” Arrieta said. “I’m always under pressure to score. I’m a forward. That’s what I like to do but the most important thing is the team needed to win.”
“It was some of our best stuff, some of our worst stuff all kind of wrapped into a first half and to a game,” New England coach Jay Heaps said.
Federico Higuain made it 2-1 three minutes later with a 28-yard free kick.
Arrieta tied it in the 32nd and another Higuain free kick gave the Crew a 3-2 lead.
Each time Higuain powered the ball over the wall of defenders.
“Those free kicks were world class,” Heaps said.
Higuain has three goals and one assist in three games since joining the Crew.
“The key is to go over the wall because once the kick goes over the wall, you have a better chance to score,” he said. “That’s what I tried to do.”
- For US, roster spots up for grabs in Friday match vs Peru
- Villas-Boas banned 6 games in Russia for striking official
- Chung says AFC broke election rules ahead of FIFA vote
- Arsenal striker Danny Welbeck has surgery on left knee
- Chile rises in top 10 of FIFA rankings led by Argentina
- Soccer players suspended for a game after blackface incident
- Carrard panel starts reform work for crisis-hit FIFA
- Uruguay set to rescind rights deal over bribery probe
- Unsung Iceland and Wales nearly qualified for Euro 2016
- German soccer clubs, fans rush to support migrants
- FIFA reforms panel makes little progress at 1st meeting
- Derby's American owners sell to 'Candy Crush' entrepreneur
- FIFA World Rankings List
- England a magnet for players as clubs flex financial muscle
- Government minister takes over Russian football
- FIFA scandal becomes exhibit at Mob Museum in Las Vegas