New York Mets
- 16-24,
- 4th NL East
| Date | Opponent | Result | Win | Loss | Save |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tue, May 1 | Houston Astros @ Houston (9-14) | L 3 - 6 | J. Happ | J. Niese | B. Myers |
| Wed, May 2 | Houston Astros @ Houston (10-14) | L 1 - 8 | W. Rodriguez | C. Schwinden | |
| Fri, May 4 | Arizona Diamondbacks vs Arizona (13-13) | L 4 - 5 | B. Ziegler | J. Rauch | J. Putz |
| Sat, May 5 | Arizona Diamondbacks vs Arizona (14-13) | W 4 - 3 | J. Santana | P. Corbin | F. Francisco |
| Sun, May 6 | Arizona Diamondbacks vs Arizona (14-14) | W 3 - 1 | R. Dickey | T. Cahill | F. Francisco |
| Mon, May 7 | Philadelphia Phillies @ Philadelphia (14-15) | W 5 - 2 | T. Byrdak | J. Papelbon | F. Francisco |
| Tue, May 8 | Philadelphia Phillies @ Philadelphia (14-16) | W 7 - 4 | M. Acosta | C. Qualls | J. Rauch |
| Wed, May 9 | Philadelphia Phillies @ Philadelphia (14-17) | W 10 - 6 | T. Byrdak | K. Kendrick | |
| Fri, May 11 | Miami Marlins @ Miami (16-15) | L 5 - 6 | H. Bell | F. Francisco | |
| Sat, May 12 | Miami Marlins @ Miami (17-15) | W 9 - 3 | R. Dickey | R. Nolasco | |
| Sun, May 13 | Miami Marlins @ Miami (17-16) | L 4 - 8 | H. Bell | F. Francisco | |
| Mon, May 14 | Milwaukee Brewers vs Milwaukee (15-19) | W 3 - 1 | M. Batista | Y. Gallardo | F. Francisco |
| Tue, May 15 | Milwaukee Brewers vs Milwaukee (15-20) | L 0 - 8 | Z. Greinke | D. Gee | |
| Wed, May 16 | Cincinnati Reds vs Cincinnati (18-17) | L 3 - 6 | J. Arredondo | J. Rauch | S. Marshall |
| Thu, May 17 | Cincinnati Reds vs Cincinnati (19-17) | W 9 - 4 | B. Parnell | L. Ondrusek | |
| Fri, May 18 | Toronto Blue Jays @ Toronto (21-18) | L 5 - 14 | R. Romero | J. Niese | |
| Sat, May 19 | Toronto Blue Jays @ Toronto (22-18) | L 0 - 2 | B. Morrow | J. Hefner | |
| Sun, May 20 | Toronto Blue Jays @ Toronto (23-18) | W 6 - 5 | D. Gee | H. Alvarez | F. Francisco |
| Mon, May 21 | Pittsburgh Pirates @ Pittsburgh (19-22) | L 4 - 5 | J. Hughes | J. Rauch | J. Hanrahan |
| Tue, May 22 | Pittsburgh Pirates @ Pittsburgh (20-22) | W 3 - 2 | R. Dickey | J. Cruz | F. Francisco |
| Wed, May 23 | Pittsburgh Pirates @ Pittsburgh (20-23) | W 3 - 1 | J. Niese | C. Morton | F. Francisco |
| Thu, May 24 | San Diego Padres vs San Diego (16-29) | L 5 - 11 | E. Stults | J. Hefner | |
| Fri, May 25 | San Diego Padres vs San Diego (17-29) | W 6 - 1 | D. Gee | A. Bass | |
| Sat, May 26 | San Diego Padres vs San Diego (17-30) | W 9 - 0 | J. Santana | C. Richard | |
| Sun, May 27 | San Diego Padres vs San Diego (17-31) | W 2 - 0 | R. Dickey | E. Volquez | F. Francisco |
| Mon, May 28 | Philadelphia Phillies vs Philadelphia (25-24) | L 4 - 8 | C. Hamels | B. Parnell | |
| Tue, May 29 | Philadelphia Phillies vs Philadelphia (26-24) | W 6 - 3 | J. Hefner | J. Blanton | F. Francisco |
| Wed, May 30 | Philadelphia Phillies vs Philadelphia (26-25) | L 6 - 10 | A. Bastardo | J. Rauch |
* if needed