“It’s the playoffs, we’re not going to quit,” Jay said. “We played hard, we fought hard and we came back and were able to win.”
The wild-card Cardinals, who got into the postseason only after the Phillies beat Atlanta in Game 162, got the split they were looking for on the road against the team that had the best record in the majors.
Lee hardly looked like the guy who used to be so dominant in the postseason. He gave up five runs and 12 hits, striking out nine in six-plus innings, to lose his third straight playoff start.
“I wasn’t able to make my pitches, so I take full responsibility,” Lee said.
Pitching on three days’ rest for the first time in his career, Chris Carpenter struggled for the Cardinals—but one reliever after another did the job for manager Tony La Russa.
“We’ve been doing this all year. We don’t give up,” Motte said. “People counted us out, (but) we kind of went out there and just kept playing hard.”
After chipping away for a few innings, the Cardinals took the lead in the seventh. Allen Craig(notes) led off with a triple off center fielder Shane Victorino’s(notes) glove. A three-time Gold Glove winner, Victorino misplayed the ball. He had to go a long way to make the catch, but overran it and the ball bounced off his glove.
Cardinals players jumped up and cheered wildly in the dugout, while Phillies fans sat silently in disbelief. The red-clad faithful had their hearts broken already once Sunday.
Just a few hours earlier, the Eagles blew a 20-point lead and lost 24-23 to the San Francisco 49ers in an NFL game across the street.
Many fans walked over to watch the two-sport doubleheader, and the crowd of 46,575 was the largest in the eight-year history of Citizens Bank Park.
For a while, it seemed the Phillies had this one under control.
After all, Lee is one of the best postseason pitchers in history, and he was 17-9 with a 2.40 ERA and a major league-best six shutouts this season.
Lee was 7-0 with a 1.26 ERA in his first eight playoff starts—4-0 with the Phillies in 2009—before losing Games 1 and 5 of the World Series to the San Francisco Giants as a member of the Texas Rangers last year.
He’s 0-3 with a 7.13 ERA in the last three outings.
On a chilly night when game-time temperature was 50 degrees, Lee was the only starter in short sleeves.
Maybe he got cold.
“Any time I got a 4-0 lead in the first or second, I feel I have the game well in hand,” Lee said.
Clinging to a 4-3 lead, Lee got the first two outs in the sixth. Then Theriot lined a two-out double to left and Jay followed with an opposite-field single to left. Theriot slid home safely ahead of Raul Ibanez’s(notes) high throw to tie it at 4.
Down 4-0, the Cardinals started their rally in the fourth. Berkman walked and Yadier Molina(notes) hit a one-out infield single. Theriot sliced an RBI double down the right-field line and Jay followed with an RBI single to get St. Louis within 4-2.
But Rafael Furcal(notes) followed with a line-drive single to left. Theriot scored and Jay came rumbling around the bases. Ibanez made a perfect one-hop throw and the ball arrived along with Jay. He slammed into Ruiz, his left forearm knocking the stocky catcher backward. But Ruiz held to temporarily prevent the tying run from scoring. Lee, backing up the plate, pumped his fist while Ruiz calmly picked up his mask and jogged to the dugout.
“I was hoping that throw to the plate would shift momentum to our side,” Phils manager Charlie Manuel said.
Carpenter, the 2005 NL Cy Young Award winner, allowed four runs and five hits in three innings. It was the shortest outing of the season for Carpenter, who led the NL with 237 1-3 innings pitched this year.
The bullpen bailed him out.
Fernando Salas(notes) retired all six batters he faced, and Octavio Dotel(notes) set down five in a row. Marc Rzepczynski(notes) gave up a two-out single to Rollins in the seventh, ending a streak of 15 straight batters retired. Rzepczynski left after hitting Chase Utley(notes) to start Philadelphia’s eighth.
Both teams had issues with plate umpire Jerry Meals, and Cardinals manager Tony La Russa criticized the strike zone during the telecast.
“It’s not a great comment to make, but I was upset,” La Russa said. “I’ve never had a problem with Jerry before ever.”
Crew chief Jerry Layne deferred comment to Joe Torre, Major League Baseball’s executive vice president of baseball operations or Peter Woodfork, the senior vice president of baseball operations.
“My job is to make sure that I have no comment,” Layne said. “It’s only right that Major League Baseball is informed of what’s going on, and if there’s really a comment that should be made, it should come out of Joe Torre or Peter Woodfork. That’s why they’re in the titles that they carry.”
The Phillies, who overcame a 3-0 first-inning deficit in Game 1, took a 3-0 lead in the first in this one.