Blue Jays 3, Yankees 2, 10 innings
Heredia, New York’s only left-hander in the bullpen, has a 6.32 ERA in 33 outings this season.
“He’s probably more frustrated than we are. It just hasn’t worked out,” New York manager Joe Torre said. “We could get by with him if he does what he did last year.”
Heredia had a 1.20 ERA in 12 games with New York last season. Torre thinks acquiring a left-hander isn’t a priority because they usually use right-hander’s Tom Gordon and Paul Quantrill in the seventh and eighth.
Gordon wasn’t available because he pitched in the previous two games.
“Tonight was just one of those nights where we couldn’t use Gordon, so it really stood out,” Torre said.
Heredia said he left a slider over the middle of the plate to Delgado.
“My pitches are staying up,” Heredia said. “Last year I got my ball down. This year, I don’t know what’s happened. I’ll try to keep working.”
Wells homered off Scott Proctor (1-1) with one out as Toronto avoided a three-game sweep. In the top of the 10th, Wells robbed Derek Jeter of extra bases with a running catch at the wall in center field.
Wells felt responsible for Monday night’s loss against New York after Tony Clark’s double ticked off his glove in left center, scoring the go-ahead run in the 6-5 loss.
“I have to make that catch. It was frustrating not to come up with it,” said Wells, whose team improved to 1-4 against New York this year. “It’s always fun beating the Yankees, no matter what the situation is. They are the best around. It’s fun playing against an All-Star team.”
A night after hitting his 400th career homer in Tuesday’s victory, Gary Sheffield reached SkyDome’s fifth deck with a first-inning homer off Miguel Batista, just the 12th time a ball has reached the uppermost tier.
New York’s Enrique Wilson fouled a ball off the side of his head in the seventh, but stayed in the game and hit an RBI single two pitches later, giving New York a 2-0 lead. Miguel Cairo replaced Wilson at second to start the bottom of the inning.
“I fouled the ball and that’s the only thing I remember,” said Wilson, who was sporting a Band-Aid over his left eye. “After I got the base hit I was a little dizzy. I wanted to stay in the game, but Joe said no.”
Toronto’s Frank Catalanotto hit an RBI single in the bottom half.
Jason Frasor (4-3) pitched two innings for the win.
Lieber allowed one run on eight hits in 7 2-3 innings. The former 20-game winner has pitched at least six innings in 13 of his 16 starts. A New York starter has gone more than six innings in just five of the last 13 games.
“I feel bad for Felix and Scott,” Lieber said. “It’s a tough loss.
Yankees right-hander Kevin Brown will likely return from the disabled list Friday and start against the Baltimore Orioles that night. Brown, sidelined since June 9 with a lower back spasm and an intestinal parasite, threw a bullpen session Wednesday and felt good. … Teammate Jason Giambi has also been fatigued because of an intestinal parasite, but manager Joe Torre expects to know more about the slugger’s condition Thursday. … Toronto manager Carlos Tosca moved rookie outfielder Alex Rios to the leadoff spot. Rios, who usually bats seventh, eighth or ninth, went 3-for-5.