Yankees 10, Athletics 7
OAKLAND, Calif. (AP)—Although Jason Giambi had a front-row seat for much of Barry Zito’s development into last season’s AL Cy Young winner, he didn’t recognize the shaky left-hander who got pounded by the New York Yankees.
It was the shortest start of the season for Zito (8-9), who has little chance of defending his Cy Young Award despite one of the best ERAs (3.30) in the league.
He has been hurt by poor run support at times this season, but Zito did himself in this time. Falling behind in the count to almost every hitter, he allowed eight hits and two walks in just three innings, and he set up New York’s five unearned runs in the second with a defensive mistake.
“I don’t think I’ve ever seen Barry as wild as he was today,” said Giambi, his teammate in Oakland until last season. “He’s one of those guys that you’re normally down 0-2, 1-2 in the count every time.
“He’s a Cy Young winner, and everybody gets up to try to beat him. He’s not a secret any more. You get those awards and accolades, and it makes everything tougher for you.”
Zito got the most memorable victory of his career against the Yankees in the 2000 playoffs, and he had a 3.12 ERA lifetime against New York before falling apart on a hot day at the Coliseum.
The left-hander is 0-4 with a 3.86 ERA in his last six starts.
“Everything was flat today,” Zito said. “I was also behind the count. Of course I’m not happy not getting a win in a month. You just have to keep on grinding, and try not to get down on myself. The team needs the normal Barry, not the someone else.”
Zito’s problems were underscored by another prolific effort from the Yankees, who won for the 11th time in 16 games.
Williams hit his first homer since May 10 off reliever John Halama in the seventh, adding to an earlier RBI single. The five-time All-Star emerged from an 11-for-50 slump with his best game since returning from the disabled list July 9.
The switch-hitting Williams still has trouble batting left-handed, since he hasn’t regained full strength in his legs since having surgery on his left knee. Those problems didn’t affect him against Oakland.
“Everybody likes hitting homers, but hitting the ball hard is more important to me right now,” Williams said. “With my knee, it’s just a matter of staying with the exercises and making sure it gets stronger.”
Jeff Weaver (6-8) recovered from a rough beginning to retire 11 of 12 in his third victory in five weeks. He allowed 10 hits and struck out five in 6 1-3 innings.
Eric Chavez singled, doubled and tripled while going 4-for-4 for Oakland, but also made a key throwing error. Erubiel Durazo had three RBIs and Tejada had two as the A’s lost for just the fourth time in 13 games.
After Aaron Boone drove in his first run with the Yankees on a first-inning grounder, Zito got into another jam in the second. With two outs and two runners on, he caught Alfonso Soriano trying to sneak to third base—but instead of charging directly at Soriano, Zito threw to third, allowing Soriano to get back to second safely.
Chavez, trying to make up for Zito’s bad decision, threw wildly past second base for an error. Derek Jeter and Williams then drove in runs, and Giambi followed them with a tape-measure shot to right—where so many of his homers landed during his days with the A’s.
Of course, Giambi was booed.
“They wouldn’t boo me if they didn’t miss me,” Giambi said with a grin.
The light-hitting Flaherty added a two-run homer in the third, and Zito was done. Flaherty has three career hits off Zito—all homers. … Boone was in the Yankees’ cleanup spot in his second game since arriving from Cincinnati. He went 0-for-4. … Halama allowed just two hits in four innings of relief— but they were homers by Williams and Matsui. … The bright Oakland sun caused havoc for the Yankees all day. Matsui got a late break on Durazo’s single, which then took a crazy hop past the left fielder; moments later, Boone overran a foul pop to third base by 10 feet. … Jose Guillen, hitting in the A’s No. 2 slot, went 1-for-5 with a ninth-inning single that snapped an 0-for-15 skid.He’s 1-for-9 in his first two games since arriving in a trade with Cincinnati.