2009-- Hideki Matsui(notes), New York (AL)
2008-- Cole Hamels(notes), Philadelphia (NL)
2007-- Mike Lowell(notes), Boston (AL)
2006-- David Eckstein(notes), St. Louis (NL)
2005-- Jermaine Dye(notes), Chicago (AL)
2004-- Manny Ramirez(notes), Boston (AL)
2003-- Josh Beckett(notes), Florida (NL)
2002-- Troy Glaus(notes), Anaheim (AL)
2001-- Curt Schilling(notes) and Randy Johnson(notes), Arizona (NL)
2000-- Derek Jeter(notes), New York (AL)
1999-- Mariano Rivera(notes), New York (AL)
1998-- Scott Brosius, New York (AL)
1997-- Livan Hernandez(notes), Florida (NL)
1996-- John Wetteland, New York (AL)
1995-- Tom Glavine(notes), Atlanta (NL)
1994-- No Series.
1993-- Paul Molitor, Toronto (AL)
1992-- Pat Borders, Toronto (AL)
1991-- Jack Morris, Minnesota (AL)
1990-- Jose Rijo, Cincinnati (NL)
1989-- Dave Stewart, Oakland (AL)
1988-- Orel Hershiser, Los Angeles (NL)
1987-- Frank Viola, Minnesota (AL)
1986-- Ray Knight, New York (NL)
1985-- Bret Saberhagen, Kansas City (AL)
1984-- Alan Trammell, Detroit (AL)
1983-- Rick Dempsey, Baltimore (AL)
1982-- Darrell Porter, St. Louis (NL)
1981-- Ron Cey, Pedro Guerrero and Steve Yeager, Los Angeles (NL)
1980-- Mike Schmidt, Philadelphia (NL)
1979-- Willie Stargell, Pittsburgh (NL)
1978-- Bucky Dent, New York (AL)
1977-- Reggie Jackson, New York (AL)
1976-- Johnny Bench, Cincinnati (NL)
1975-- Pete Rose, Cincinnati (NL)
1974-- Rollie Fingers, Oakland (AL)
1973-- Reggie Jackson, Oakland (AL)
1972-- Gene Tenace, Oakland (AL)
1971-- Roberto Clemente, Pittsburgh (NL)
1970-- Brooks Robinson, Baltimore (AL)
1969-- Donn Clendenon, New York (NL)
1968-- Mickey Lolich, Detroit (AL)
1967-- Bob Gibson, St. Louis (NL)
1966-- Frank Robinson, Baltimore (AL)
1965-- Sandy Koufax, Los Angeles (NL)
1964-- Bob Gibson, St. Louis (NL)
1963-- Sandy Koufax, Los Angeles (NL)
1962-- Ralph Terry, New York (AL)
1961-- Whitey Ford, New York (AL)
1960-- Bobby Richardson, New York (AL)
1959-- Larry Sherry, Los Angeles (NL)
1958-- Bob Turley, New York (AL)
1957-- Lew Burdette, Milwaukee (NL)
1956-- Don Larsen, New York (AL)
1955-- Johnny Podres, Brooklyn (NL)
