Mon Nov 02, 2009 8:04 pm EST

PHILADELPHIA — I've heard and read more than a few Phillies and Yankees fans going back and forth the past few days about payroll. Should the Yankees wrap up title No. 27 tonight (or sometime this week), that bickering will only continue deep into the offseason.
With a payroll ledger twice the size of Philadelphia, the Yankees certainly enjoy a nice advantage over the World Series opponents (although no one ever mentions that spending all that money hasn't bought them anything since 2000).
Still, I don't think that Phillies fans — which had a team with an opening day payroll of $113 million, good for seventh highest in the league — have much of an argument. That type of beef should be reserved for the Oaklands and Kansas Cities of the world.
Big League Stew is an MLB blog edited by Kevin Kaduk. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Posted Nov 24 2009
Marlins Donate Turkeys In Little Havana
Posted Nov 24 2009
Posted Nov 23 2009
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by E. Brennan
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Andy Behrens
180 Comments
1 - 23 of 180
Report Abuse
Angels fan afterward: You guys bought the championship
Phillies fans are even worse. Or suggesting that the umps are favoring the yankees. Ridiculous.
Look at what the homegrown talent is doing this world series:
Jeter .412
Posada .308
Pettite 1-0
Rivera - MVP bound
Every team the Yanks have faced this postseason has made at least one huge mental error. And Yankees have been steady and hustling and clutch. Lets just all give credit where it's due because the game is won between the lines. Of course money helps. The Yankees continue to sell tickets and merchandise. That's what winning for a century will do. Better than having cheap owners like the Indians do, who give up and throw all their players away to pocket more profit. Steinbrenner is not the richest owner, he's just the richest spender. He bought the team for 9MIL don't forget. Phils are a great team, may the best team win.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
dont [profane] and whine about payroll and umps the yankess are playing yankee baseball this year and its showing.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
We had Soriano and traded him for A Rod b/c Texas didn't want to have to pay him that much, how's that our fault they signed him to the most inflated deal ever?
Everyone always complains about how much money we spend, yet we're the ones who have to subsidize teams like the Marlins and the Diamondbacks because they only draw 3-8 thousand fans a game. Yet nobody had any problem when we lost to them in the World Series. Nobody was complaining then.
Find a new reason to whine.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
The notion of one team with a payroll of $200- 225 million competing against a league where the average is something like $60-80 million is absurd. It's like this- if the Yankees do win, it's not an acheivement AT ALL because that financial advantage makes it darn near a certainity that you should win. When they don't win it all it's simply a small measure of justice.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
There is no such restriction on the Yankees, much to the chagrin of the rest of the league. The bottom line is, the purpose of baseball is NOT winning and losing anymore, it's filling the seats of stadiums, it's making money from its fans, it's providing entertainment to masses of people. The Yankees are like the Romans in the Colisseum, though - they can just toy with whoever comes their way, and people (for now) are having fun watching them tease other teams before finally mauling them. But the time will come when no one cares anymore.
Look what has happened in the past 2 decades. Free agency has raised player salaries. This has given players more allegiance to personal stats, and less to teams and fans. The result? Competition is fiercer, players have more at stake, and steroids have pervaded the sport. After all, juicing yourself could make the difference between multimillions and a job at the local grocery store!
So the huge salaries drive up ticket prices, but also take something out of the game for fans, who have to cheer for new players every year if they want to remain loyal to "their team." But one positive spinoff in all of this has been fantasy sports... now we can create our own teams, our own competition, and have personal stakes in the outcomes of not just one game, but all of them! It means I don't honestly care if the Yankees win or not, because I won my fantasy championship this year with only Cano from the Yanks... the rest of my team was studs from teams who didn't win it all. But it don't matter.
I hate the Yankees and their liberal spending, but I'm also not about to cry about it... I will rejoice, though, if/when they choke yet again this year!
Report Abuse
You mean to tell me they'd have 2 WS rings if they didn't go out and get all those players?
They paid $50 million just so they could NEGOTIATE with Dice K, they signed him for another $50 million!!! Nobody's whining about that are they?!
You're all a bunch of hypocrites and the Yankees are good for baseball, how else are teams that draw 3,000 a game supposed to keep a team? You put a salary cap in baseball and you'll start getting talks of contracting teams again.
Remember that? When the Expos, Twins, and Marlins were on the chopping block? Everyone cried out and payed attention.
Revenue sharing is all that's keeping some of these teams afloat and if the Yankees weren't selling 4 million tickets at ridiculously high prices all year, your beloved KCs and Pittsburghs would be dead and gone. So would Oakland. So would Florida. Washington goes bye bye. San Diego would be dismantled and so there all your parity goes right out the window with these teams that can't draw a crowd and all that's left are the teams that were already well off in the first place.
Congratulations your idea has accomplished nothing. The Diamondbacks WON the world series, the Rockies made a huge run to get there in 07, the Marlins WON the worlds series TWICE. Don't discount the little guy as a loser because there are teams with low payrolls that can compete, because it's been proven that they can.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
1 - 23 of 180