Big League Stew - MLB

There have been just over 1,250 postseason starts since 1903, but few have been better than Cliff Lee's(notes) appearance in last Sunday's NLCS Game 3 against the Dodgers. He went eight scoreless innings allowing only three hits, striking out 10 and walking nobody. Additionally, only one runner got past first base.

Lee didn't exactly need to be that good — the Phillies scored 11 runs and knocked Hiroki Kuroda(notes) out after he'd given up six runs and recorded just four outs — but it was still pretty amazing to watch.

But just how historic was Lee's day at the office? In postseason history, there have only been 45 starts better than Lee's, and only 15 in the last 20 years, as ranked by Game Score.*

*Game Score is a metric devised by Bill James that attempts to index how good a start is, by rewarding the pitcher for innings pitched and strikeouts, and penalizing them for hits, walks, and runs allowed. It more or less operates on a 100-point scale — 0 is atrocious, 100 is tremendous, 50 is average, and scores below zero or above 100 are almost unheard of. Cliff Lee's score was 86 — not quite legendary, but certainly quite good.)

Without further delay, here are nine of the best postseason starts of the last 20 years:

98: Roger Clemens(notes), ALCS Game 4 10/14/2000 In his second season in Yankee pinstripes, the Rocket annihilated Seattle in 2000 to the tune of a complete game one-hit shutout, with 15 strikeouts and just two walks, for a game score of 98. (The immortal Al Martin spoiled the no-hit bid with a double in the 7th.) Clemens owns the highest game score in history, just in front of Dave McNally (97), Babe Ruth (97) and even Don Larsen's perfect game in the World Series (94).

93: Josh Beckett(notes) NLCS Game 5 10/12/2003 This is the moment that the Josh Beckett legend was born. The Marlins were down 3-1 to the Chicago Cubs in the NLCS and the 23-year old Beckett started Game 5 and pitched a complete game shutout. He allowed just two hits (both singles), one walk, and struck out 11 batters. The Marlins won the last three games of the series en route to their second World Championship.

92: Kevin Brown, NLDS Game 1 9/29/1998; 89: Kevin Brown, NLCS Game 2 10/8/1998 Kevin Brown pitched two of the greatest starts in playoff history in two successive playoff series, with 16 strikeouts in eight shutout innings against the Astros and then 11 strikeouts in nine shutout innings against the Braves a week later. His success didn't last, though. Brown gave up four runs in 6 1/3 against the Yankees in the World Series and his Padres were swept.

91: Randy Johnson(notes), NLCS Game 1 10/16/2001; 91: Randy Johnson, World Series Game 2 10/28/2001 The pitcher who brought down the Yankee dynasty, Randy Johnson won three games in the 2001 World Series, one by way of a complete-game shutout — something he'd treated the Atlanta Braves to just two weeks earlier. Johnson and Beckett are only the eighth and ninth pitchers ever to record multiple complete-game shutouts in a single postseason and the only ones in the last 20 years.

90: Livan Hernandez(notes), NLCS Game 5 10/12/1997 Blame Eric Gregg if you want, but Livan was awfully dominant this day. He went the whole way, giving up just three hits and one run (on a Michael Tucker(notes) solo shot) while striking out 15 Braves and walking just two.

89: Curt Schilling(notes), NLDS Game 1 10/9/2001 Nearly as good as Johnson was teammate Curt Schilling, who destroyed the Cardinals that same October, going the distance and giving up just three hits and one walk while striking out nine.

89: Kevin Millwood(notes), NLDS Game 2 10/6/1999 Millwood was just 24 when he broke out with the Braves, finishing third in the Cy Young voting. He kept it up against the Astros, allowing only one hit — a Ken Caminiti solo homer — in a complete-game victory that would help lead the Braves to the last World Series of their "era." However, like Kevin Brown's Padres, they wound up losing to the Yankees.

digg delicious
more

35 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Socalwhite
    1. Posted by Socalwhite Fri Oct 23, 2009 5:39 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Erm... sorry Perfect game = perfect game Just because he didn't strike out 15 or so, Larsen has to be at 100
    Let the rest shoot for that. (And I'm not even a Yankee fan!)
  2. Kate
    2. Posted by Kate Fri Oct 23, 2009 6:04 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm a huge Phillies fan, so I feel the need to point out that one runner got to second base. Let's make sure we have all the facts straight.
  3. michael
    3. Posted by michael Fri Oct 23, 2009 6:07 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm with you Socalwhite, a perfect game is just that, perfect. 100 out of 100
  4. Flint A
    4. Posted by Flint A Fri Oct 23, 2009 6:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm a little surprised that Tom Glavine's gem in the 1995 World Series isn't listed on here. Glavine allowed one hit in eight innings in the decisive game 6 of the '95 World Series. The Braves won, 1-0, on a solo home run by David Justice.
    The Cleveland Indians were an offensive juggernaut that year and got completely shut down by Glavine. No, he didn't strike a ton out, but he was dominating, nonetheless.
  5. idschray
    5. Posted by idschray Fri Oct 23, 2009 6:15 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Let's not forget Tom Glavine's performance in the 1995 World Series clincher... An 8-inning 1-hitter certainly deserves mention here...
  6. idschray
    6. Posted by idschray Fri Oct 23, 2009 6:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Ha! Great minds think alike, Flint! :-D
  7. * * * * * * * *
    7. Posted by * * * * * * * * Fri Oct 23, 2009 7:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    sorry, but being that it was against the weak hitting Dodgers, I dont really thing that it ranks in among the "all-time" anything
  8. Breeze Bruin
    8. Posted by Breeze Bruin Fri Oct 23, 2009 8:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Where is Sandy Koufax?
  9. nel23
    9. Posted by nel23 Fri Oct 23, 2009 8:32 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Yikes. No Jack Morris in Game 7 of the 1991 World Series? 10 shutout innings to get the win? How is that not on here?
  10. 1stnoel
    10. Posted by 1stnoel Fri Oct 23, 2009 10:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Y'know, watching Cliff Lee and CC pitch and Ben Francisco contribute and the fact that Casey Blake was in the post season makes me almost feel sorry for the Cleveland Indian fans. Wow what team they had.
  11. Daniel L. Stock
    11. Posted by Daniel L. Stock Fri Oct 23, 2009 11:15 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Yeah, there's too many division games up here. Jack Morris' game needs to be on that list as does Josh Beckett's world series clincher in 03
  12. cuffablimp
    12. Posted by cuffablimp Sat Oct 24, 2009 12:46 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    It wasn't a CG but could have been and it ranks up there with Jack Morris, Bob Gibson, Catfish Hunter, and many others who excelled beyond belief in post season play by making their talents known in a dominating manner. It's a great story in the sense he was actually left off a playoff roster 2 years ago due to an off year after already being an established better than average starting pitcher and in his first shot at the playoffs he's pitched like a CY Young award winner everytime he's been given the ball. That's one great story in progress.
  13. Marcus J
    13. Posted by Marcus J Sat Oct 24, 2009 1:18 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    wow...im on the verge of never reading a sports blog on this site again.
    this list lost all credibility once i saw there was no jack morris...and this is from a braves fan. not only was it the best playoff start ...it was one of the best post season perfomances ever(in any sport)...... in one of the best world series ever...in one of the best series ever(baseball basketball hockey)...in one of the best game 7's ever.
    10 innings. world series. game 7. 0-0 going into the ninth.he allowed no runs and got the win. nuff said.
  14. Alex Remington
    14. Posted by Alex Remington Sat Oct 24, 2009 3:11 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I didn't choose the games. It's just ranked by a stat called Game Score.
  15. Jo Bangles
    15. Posted by Jo Bangles Sat Oct 24, 2009 7:15 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Jose Lima - 2004 NLDS ;0 - - -
  16. zubee
    16. Posted by zubee Sat Oct 24, 2009 10:59 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    How about Bob Gibson throughout the 1967 World Series? He pitched a gem in each of the 3 games he took the mound. Jim Lonborg of the Red Sox pitched well until the game 7 when he tired out and was outdueled by Gibson. But from a total pespective, Don Larsen has to be the tops.
  17. RaymondGuy
    17. Posted by RaymondGuy Sat Oct 24, 2009 12:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Real major league city teams keep buying up the Tribe!
    * Bud Selig roid cheats and monopoly ball *
  18. milan52
    18. Posted by milan52 Sat Oct 24, 2009 2:07 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Remember Sandy Koufax? Sport writers must have short memories. World Series 1963. He pitched 18 innings in two starts. Remember when a pitcher could actually last an entire game? He gave up 12 hits, struck out 23 hitters, and had an ERA of 1.50. Then in 1965's WS, he pitched 24 innings, gave up 13 hits, struck out 29, had an ERA of 0.38, and still lost one game. If we are going to look at the best of all time, Lee isn't in the ballpark yet.
  19. milan52
    19. Posted by milan52 Sat Oct 24, 2009 2:19 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Larsen pitched the best single game in WS history but if you look back, he walked 4, gave up one hit and fours runs in the first 1.2 innings of game two that year.
  20. KerryS
    20. Posted by KerryS Sat Oct 24, 2009 3:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Must everything in baseball be reduced to "stats"? Can't anyone think for themselves, without feeding numbers into a formula. A great pitching performance is based on circumstances, not how many strikeouts you have. As others have said, a perfect game has to be the best. And a great game in game 7 of the WS (Jack Morris) is better than game 1 or 2 of the LDS.
  21. hello
    21. Posted by hello Sat Oct 24, 2009 3:47 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    In the USA today week end newspaper the Phillis is on there frontpage,this's a jix,they will most likely lose.Andy Petite will pitch well this week end against the Angels.
  22. M2
    22. Posted by M2 Sat Oct 24, 2009 10:09 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Dudes, read the blog carefully. It states best postseason starts of the LAST TWENTY YEARS, and based on a specific Bill James formula that weights strikeouts for dominance. So that would be from 1989-2009.
    So no Koufax, no Larsen, no Gibson. And based on a specific statistical formula, period. If you remove the formula, the other pitchers that have been mentioned, like Morris, would be up there because you would be different standard.
    It's amazing how many people DON'T READ the BLOG carefully, thus do not understand the CONTEXT of the discussion and then mouth off about how screwed the list is and how stupid the writer is. It ain't Alex Remington's list - it's the list based on a statistical analysis called Game Score.
    Read and understand the context of the discussion before you jerk off and click to post your comments
  23. Daniel L. Stock
    23. Posted by Daniel L. Stock Sun Oct 25, 2009 12:10 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I understand that Alex didn't create the list, but I'd be interested in seeing a post not just about stats which seem questionable; especially since it doesn't seem like they're weighting the series appropriately. A WS start should be ranked higher than a DS start--not only is there FAR less pressure in a division series, you're almost assuredly facing easier competition than you would in the WS.

Big League Stew

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

'Duk

Big League Stew is an MLB blog edited by Kevin Kaduk. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Big League Stew Recent Readers