Big League Stew - MLB

Here are a few initial reactions as we await official word from The Moose on how he's retiring to the Pennsylvania countryside while the rest of us make him this generation's classic Hall-of-Fame argument.

(And if it takes the pitcher a little while to pull the trigger? Don't forget to give Dave Brown's excellent Answer Man session with Mike Mussina last August another re-read as well.)

UPDATE: It's now a done deal. Pete Abe has the official press release from the Yankees.

Tyler Kepner, NY Times: "As a beat writer, I'll miss him a lot. Mussina was one of my all-time favorite players to cover. He could be amused by his surroundings or curmudgeonly about any inconvenience. He did crossword puzzles, of course, and read novels and issues of Old Car Trader magazine. He wore funny T-shirts from 80stees.com — the Flux Capacitor, Abe Froman: Sausage King of Chicago, and many more. And he guzzled Mountain Dew all day long.

"When you needed a big-picture, insightful quote about the state of the team — and you wanted unvarnished honesty — Mussina was the go-to guy among the pitchers. When you had a question about a labor or rules issue, Mussina was the man to ask. And when you wanted to learn about pitching — this was my favorite thing about him — Mussina was willing to share."

Aziz Nekoukar, Pride of the Yankees: "I was constantly skeptical that Mike Mussina was actually going to retire. Who in their right mind would walk away from $25 million for two years of service? Then, you remember he has three kids. You look at his Baseball Reference page (scroll to the bottom and look to the right) and see he's earned a ridiculous $144,533,619 over 18 seasons -- in other words, he is not pressed for cash. Then you remember that he's a borderline hall of famer. And he just feels that he can be content and call it a career. A pretty amazing career, at that."

Ed Valentine, Bugs & Cranks: "Mussina was never the dominant pitcher in the league, and never won a Cy Young. He was almost always among the best, however. Before last season I thought he was short of Hall of Fame caliber. Now, considering how the game has changed and that the 300-victory plateau should probably not be the benchmark, I'd say he should get in."

Andrew Fletcher, Scott Proctor's Arm: "This is a rather significant blow to the Yankees' pitching staff. The Yankees may have to give in to Andy Pettitte's demands to simply fill up the rotation with capable arms. But those are decisions for another day. Today we celebrate Mussina's extraordinary career. Mussina finishes with a record of 270-153 and a 3.68 ERA. Pitching his entire career in the American League East, those are terrific numbers. Thanks for the memories, Moose."

Stacey, Camden Chat: "When I got in my car this evening the first thing that flashed on my XM radio was, 'Report: Mike Mussina to retire,' and I'll be honest, it caught me off guard how emotional I felt. I sat in the parking lot looking at those words flash across the screen and I welled up with emotion. Since he'd declared free agency, I'd harbored this fantasy that Mussina would sign a three year deal with the O's and during those three years he'd get his 300th win and also the WS ring he's been chasing his whole career. I knew it wouldn't happen, but I wanted it to so badly."

Neal S., The Loss Column: "I first saw the news a few hours ago on a TV at the grocery store (of all places), and I greeted it with a shrug. Then I tried to conjure up some sense of wistful emotion, some sense of fondness for his time in black-and-orange. No luck. As far as I'm concerned, Mussina isn't an Oriole and may as well have never been one. He pitched here, yes, but lots of guys did that. I didn't feel any particular fondness when Randy Myers retired, either."

digg delicious
more

58 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. eight inches
    1. Posted by eight inches Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    This is exactly how baseball players should retire and exit. When they are on top and not making fools of themselves on the mound or on the field. Are you listening Trevor Hoffman?
  2. ravenous defense
    2. Posted by ravenous defense Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:54 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Moose deserves to be a Hall of Famer, especially since he pitched in the AL East his whole career. 270 wins in the AL East is like 350 in any other division. Come back to the O's.
  3. tonyarob
    3. Posted by tonyarob Thu Sep 03, 2009 6:57 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Goodbye to this generation's Don Sutton. That's not meant to be a compliment or in any way suggest that Mussina belongs in the HOF. Like Sutton, he was simply a pretty good pitcher for a long time. Never dominated or never one of the truly spectacular pitchers of his era. Longevity, durability and consistancy count for something. Just not a plaque in Cooperstown in my opinion. Before we start talking about Mussina as a possible HOF candidate let's do something about taking down Sutton's plaque please.
  4. mathesond
    4. Posted by mathesond Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    2 things I'll remember about Mussina - 1) When he warmed up without being told to in the '93 All Star game, thereby inciting the Camden Yards faithful to boo AL Manager Cito Gaston for not putting him in, and 2) Complaining about the ceremony for recently deceased Jays announcer Tom Cheek (he of the 4000+ consecutive games called streak), which delayed the start of the game by a whopping 10 minutes. Mussina certainly was a classy player, and he deserved all his World Series rings
  5. saucy
    5. Posted by saucy Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:41 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    as much as i kind of knew this was going to happen, i was still pretty bummed out after hearing it yesterday (even though not official). i too, held a shred of hope he'd be back since he did file for free-agency.
    see you in the hall, Moose. class act all the way!
  6. Saro G
    6. Posted by Saro G Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:46 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    ""Mussina was never the dominant pitcher in the league, and never won a Cy Young. He was almost always among the best, however. Before last season I thought he was short of Hall of Fame caliber. Now, considering how the game has changed and that the 300-victory plateau should probably not be the benchmark, I'd say he should get in.""
    Uh, you gave a great argument for him not getting in, Ed Valentine. As Bill Simmons said a while ago, is Mussina the type of pitcher who made you say "Wow! I gotta buy tickets to see him pitch tonight."?
    Mussina should get in only after Blyleven does.
  7. ravenous defense
    7. Posted by ravenous defense Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:54 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Do have any idea what it is like to pitch in the AL East? A team from that division has been the AL champ 11 out of 18 years in Mussina's career and that includes the 1994 strike season. So it should be 11 out of 17 seasons. He has always had to pitch against the top teams every year multiple times a year so his numbers are astounding and he should easily be a hall of famer.
  8. cameron m
    8. Posted by cameron m Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:20 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Saro G, ya think a lot of people said, "Wow! I gotta buy tickets to see Tom Glavine pitch tonight"?
    Doubtful.
    I'm a Red Sox fan and I think Mussina belongs in the Hall. He spent his entire career in the AL East and posted a career won-loss record that's more than 100 games over .500, and that's pretty remarkable. Who cares if he never won a Cy Young. Neither did Nolan Ryan or Marichal or Blyleven.
    I never really liked Mussina's game, but it's hard to argue with his career stats, particularly in the era in which he pitched.
  9. Saro G
    9. Posted by Saro G Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:46 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The AL East from 2001-2007 included the AWFUL Orioles and Rays teams as well as the mediocre Jays. The division is overrated thanks to the two teams at the top. Mussina is a stat compiler, not a legitimate ace.
  10. Saro G
    10. Posted by Saro G Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:46 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Mussina can't hold Nolan Ryan's jockstrap, cameron.
    And I agree Glavine is overrated too. Benefited the most from the pitch 6" outside the zone. But he's more deserving than Mussina anyway.
  11. ravenous defense
    11. Posted by ravenous defense Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:54 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    every team except the orioles had a winning record this year and he had his best year ever at 40
  12. Saro G
    12. Posted by Saro G Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:46 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Read post #10 again very carefully, ravens D.
  13. ravenous defense
    13. Posted by ravenous defense Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:54 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    i read it, i was stating another point...and as for the Nolan Ryan comment....totally wrong. Nolan Ryan could barely get to 324 wins and it took him 27 seasons to do it, which is an average of 12 wins a season. He is the most overrated pitcher ever simply b/c he had a 103 mile an hour fastball.
  14. Saro G
    14. Posted by Saro G Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:46 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    If you're only looking and wins and losses to determine HoF eligibility, you're lost. While Ryan walked a lot of batters, his huge strikeout totals have to count for something. He is a one-of-a-kind pitcher that transcended the game.
    So one good season in 2008 after several mediocre ones makes Mussina a Hall of Famer? He was awful in 2007. As far as I'm concerned, the last two years even out. And if you want Mussina in the Hall of Fame, may as well let Jamie Moyer in too.
  15. N. Y. NIGHTMARE
    15. Posted by N. Y. NIGHTMARE Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    NO MOOSE!! dont go , you can make it to 300 baby.
    15+ seasons with 12 or more wins IN THE AL EAST!!! nuff said
  16. ravenous defense
    16. Posted by ravenous defense Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:54 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    he had only 2 losing seasons in his 18 years and one of them was his first year where he went 4-5
  17. ravenous defense
    17. Posted by ravenous defense Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:54 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    he posted a 4 to 1 strikeout to walk ratio
  18. Baseball fan
    18. Posted by Baseball fan Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:40 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The 10 years Mussina spent with Baltimore were special when you consider how far that franchise has fallen since. Granted, ownership in Balt. has destroyed the Orioles in many other ways, but he won against Boston and NYY, not to mention Toronto (they were decent back then). He was always consistent, always a team guy, always a force on the mound. Then, the guy leaves one trainwreck to jump onto another called "The Steinbrenner Express." New York, with all its money, power, and allure, has continued to implode due to piss-poor ownership. Despite of all that, Mussina soldiered on. True, money helps, but he stayed competitive, ending his career on top of his game. Is he worthy of the HOF? Yes, when you consider his career stats and divisional wins.
  19. MIKE
    19. Posted by MIKE Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    At least Mussina never cheated, I still wonder if Ryan juiced, hair loss and close with Clemens..hmmmm
  20. Saro G
    20. Posted by Saro G Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:46 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Mussina career compares to Kevin Brown (not a hall of famer), Tom Glavine (overrated hall of famer), Jack Morris (bigtime big game pitcher) and Curt Schilling (one of the greatest postseason pitchers in recent memory). The thing that separates Schilling from Mussina is his great success in the postseason. Mussina's had some highs (2001 ALDS, 2003 ALCS) and lows (2002 ALDS, 2006 ALDS).
  21. Five_outs
    21. Posted by Five_outs Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:54 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Total class act
  22. Five_outs
    22. Posted by Five_outs Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:54 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Total class act
  23. Jeff
    23. Posted by Jeff Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:47 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Willie McGee should be in the hall before Moose. Having said that, Moose has had a good career and whether it warrants a HOF induction, we'll have to wait and see if Clemens will try to bring his name some shame too and say he shared with Mikey.
  24. ravenous defense
    24. Posted by ravenous defense Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:54 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Kevin Brown was terrible he was completely inconsistent and a huge waste of money. Moose was never any of those. He earned every penny he ever made and I wish he would come back to the O's for a few more seasons to provide our awful pitching staff with an excellent example of everything a pitcher should be.
  25. Karl G
    25. Posted by Karl G Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:13 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Regardless of HOF or not, Yankees will have a big gap to fill with him gone. His stamina, durability, and personality are very hard qualities to find in a lot of players these days and he was a team player through and through. I think most of us thought he was washed up after 07, but he proved us all wrong, he always showed a dedicated to his craft and i wish him all the best with his family, the AL East wont be the same without him.

Big League Stew

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

'Duk

Big League Stew is an MLB blog edited by Kevin Kaduk. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Contributors:
David Brown, Alex Remington,

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Big League Stew Recent Readers