Big League Stew - MLB

This and every weekday a.m. during baseball season, let's rise and shine together to recap the most recent diamond doings. Roll Call starts in Kansas City, Mo., home of Kauffman Stadium and the world's finest barbecue. In those traditions, the Royals put Kerry Wood(notes) on a spit and charcoaled the Indians in a classic ninth-inning meltdown. Could Indians manager Eric Wedge have prevented the fire?

Game of the Day
Royals 6, Indians 5

How do you feel about Cleveland? From the Tribe's perspective, this one can be viewed two different ways.

1) Kerry Wood, the $31-million closer, simply failed to hold Cliff Lee's(notes) 5-2 lead in the ninth inning, with the Royals rallying behind back-to-back home runs by Mike Jacobs(notes) and Mark Teahen(notes), along with a sacrifice fly by Willie Bloomquist(notes).

"It just didn't work out for us," Wedge said. "Wood's been through all the battles, as a starter, as a closer. He has tremendous presence out there, but tonight they just got to him."

2) Lee was cruising along, la-la-la, having allowed two runs and thrown 101 pitches over eight innings, but Wedge took him out because, apparently, "that's what managers are supposed to do" these days come the ninth.

"He's the guy you were going to," Wedge said after Wood's second blown save of the season. "That's the reason he's here. A three-run lead in the ninth inning is the best situation for any closer."

Wood blew it, sure. But did Wedge blow it first by relying on an overused tactic in a situation that called for something else?

Over the Cliff: Considering Lee wasn't throwing a no-hitter or even a shutout, and his pitch count wasn't exceptionally low, most other mangers, most other times, probably would have gone to the closer. If the Indians had anyone they really trusted in the eighth, Wedge might have taken out Lee sooner.

But, should Lee have been removed? Was he fatigued? I can't tell from any of the stories I've seen if he was even asked — by a reporter, by Wedge, by anyone. He retired his last eight batters and his 101 pitches were the second-lowest of the season; his average had been 108.

Is the point of the closer just to pitch the ninth inning of a relatively close game, accumulate saves and justify his expense, or is he there to get a save in the statistical sense and figurative sense? Did Cliff need to be saved?

Verdict: If Lee's not tired and could have pitched the ninth, Wedge was being a sheep. Bahh! General manager Mark Shapiro bought him an expensive toy, a closer, in the wake of the demoralizing ninth innings of 2008. The Indians might have won the AL Central if the back of their bullpen had been in order. These factors probably went into Wedge's thinking. When it came to push the ninth-inning button, he did it. He's no fool. Except, that, he was.

* * *

Feelin' Rundown (neither Kerry Wood nor Eric Wedge messed up any of these games): 

Yankees 9, Orioles 1: A-Rod has seven hits since coming off the DL on May 8, and five of them are homers. It was tough to hit home runs to left-center in the old Stadium, but A-Rod just gets the ball up into the jet stream, or something, and finds plenty of life in what was Death Valley across the street. Imagine what this guy could be doing if he were still on Vitamin S.

Brewers 4, Astros 2: We interrupt these six solid innings from Dave Bush(notes) to report that another player has stolen home. Kaz Matsui swiped the plate in the first during a double-steal-rundown thingie the Brewers messed up. Good to see Matsui recovered from his (whispering voice) anal fissures of a season ago. ... We interrupt these anal fissures to report that relief pitcher Russ Ortiz(notes) has hit a home run, his seventh dinger in nearly 500 career plate apps. ... We interrupt this home run to report that Mike Hampton(notes) cut his left thumb on a soap dispenser in a shower at Wrigley Field last week and had to leave this game after four innings.

Tigers 4, Rangers 1: Dontrelle Willis(notes) rolled up his sleeves (and his socks), went to work and something funny happened. He pitched great! Detroit is a Pistons town, of course, but everyone checks out those Calves when D-Train pitches.

Phillies 4, Reds 3: Hamels usually pitches well at Great American, where he made his big league debut in '06. The Phillies' rotation ranked last in the NL with a 6.35 ERA. Really? ... Still no word about Joey Votto(notes). It's still probably just the flu. But, as one of our commenters suggested, what about vertigo? Get Nick Esasky on the blower.

Red Sox 2, Blue Jays 1: Knuckles Wakefield was back in form, except for one he left hanging for Millahhh! ... Another solid outing for Brian Tallet(notes), whose mustache was hurt by the very bottom of the Red Sox lineup. How to explain this? I am aware of Jeff Bailey(notes), but every time I see him mentioned, I feel like going, "Who?" ... Big Papi still 0-for-season.

Pirates 8, Nationals 5 (10 inn.): The Nats have dropped six in a row while scoring at least five runs in each defeat; they are only the fourth team ever to do so. Look at Manny Acta, checking the stats: "We continue to put runs on the board, Acta said. "This is the 10th game in a row where we score five or more runs — and we're 1-9. That tells you the story right now."

Angels 6, Mariners 5: It wasn't his best game, but 30-year-old rookie Matt Palmer(notes) improved to 5-0. The moral of his story: if you have a dream, don't let go of it until you're at least 31.

D-backs 5, Marlins 3: ... When, all of a sudden, the Snakes struck for five runs against Josh Johnson(notes) and Rey Pinto in the seventh. Then, with their work done, they slithered back into their little wicker basket.

Athletics 4, Rays 1 (11 inn.): This was scoreless through 10 but a rare error by Jason Bartlett(notes) set up Matt Holliday(notes) to hit a three-run, go-ahead homer. The Rays won games like this last year, ain't doing it this year, and that's why they're not going to make it back to the playoffs.

Dodgers 5, Mets 3: The New Yorkers have allowed 20 unearned runs in 39 games.  It's a good thing bad defense don't hurt ya'. ... Orlando Hudson(notes) has a bruised shoulder, but is OK, Torre reports. ... One homer allowed in 61 innings for Billingsley.

White Sox 6, Twins 2: Mark Buehrle(notes) is about the only reason to turn on a White Sox game these days. Unless you're Jonesing for Laynce Nix(notes). ... Mentally, the Twinkies were still in New York City, where they dropped four games by what seemed like a combined two runs.

Braves 8, Rockies 1: Todd Helton(notes) reaches 2,000 hits, for real this time. Unless he already did.

Cardinals 3, Cubs 0: A three-hitter (only one for extra bases) by Joel Pineiro(notes). I've said it before, and I'll say it again: pitching coach Dave Duncan is worth his weight in beer to St. Louis. Pitching coach Dave Duncan is worth his weight in beer to St. Louis. Told you I'd say it again.

Padres 2, Giants 1: Zito continues to take baby steps back toward $126-million respectability. He dropped to 1-4, but he's not nearly the basket case he was at this time last season when he was on the way to 0-8. It would help if the Giants scored better than 1.25 runs a game for him, probably, but they're not going to light up the scoreboard for anybody.

digg delicious
more

24 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Josh
    1. Posted by Josh Wed May 20, 2009 6:54 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    It's a travesty that Eric Wedge wasn't the first manager fired this year. At least he'll be the second.
  2. Victor G
    2. Posted by Victor G Wed May 20, 2009 7:51 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Well, if the Red Sox are winning, Papi do not have to bat homers.. Anyways, Billingsley keeps doing his thing!!
  3. The Dood
    3. Posted by The Dood Wed May 20, 2009 8:29 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Stupid decisions (Thank you Wedge) are dooming the Indians to failure. They should fire Wedge, get rid of the big contracts, but keep the core players, and basically go into rebuilding. They've become the laughing stock of Cleveland. On one side you have the Cavaliers trying to make a name for the city in the finals, then you have the Indians on the other side basically screwing any chance to make Cleveland a legitimate championship city.
  4. Danny R
    4. Posted by Danny R Wed May 20, 2009 9:08 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Wow...if Wood does his JOB and gets the royals out, this is a non issue. It wasnt Wedge that left hanging pitches to 3 batters in the 9th. If he leaves Lee in and Cliff loses, its tthe same thing. Deal with iot, you overpaid for a washed up bum that has been on the DL 12 times, with more to come.
  5. killtee
    5. Posted by killtee Wed May 20, 2009 9:32 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Just karma for the way Wedge used Wood to try and teach the Rays you are supposed to quit before the game is over. Mad because Upton stole two bases in an inning where a 9-0 game became a 9-6 game on Thursday, Wedge warmed Wood up in the 8th inning of a game he normally wouldn't see, just to throw at Upton.
  6. Gary
    6. Posted by Gary Wed May 20, 2009 9:42 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Detroit is not a Piston town. They are #4 on sports fans lists, even the Lions are ahead of the Pistons. Its Hockeytown, Tiger town, Loser Lion town, and then brawl in the stands Pistons town.
    Welcome to the D, D-train. Hopefully this is what he's gonna do for the rest of the year
  7. cpass
    7. Posted by cpass Wed May 20, 2009 9:43 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I watched the Indians-Royals from start to finish and was absolutely amazed that Wedge would pull a cruising Cliff Lee to start the ninth. Here was the perfect opportunity to STAY AWAY from those arsonists in his bullpen, but he couldn't resist throwing yet more gasoline out there. The Tribe couldn't possibly be more demoralized at this point.
  8. Saro G
    8. Posted by Saro G Wed May 20, 2009 9:54 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Until a legitimate first baseman is added to the team, the Mets will score 2-3 runs a game. You can't field a team with the likes of Jeremy Reed and Ramon Martinez in the lineup.
  9. pitcairnis
    9. Posted by pitcairnis Wed May 20, 2009 10:10 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Yep, Cliff Lee should have been allowed to finish the game (as Mike Jackson should have started the ninth in game 7 back in 1997), but the problem is that what terrifies managers most is being criticized for losing a game by not going by the book. It got Grady Little fired. Criticism of the manager is pretty muted if he loses going by the book, but all hell breaks loose if he loses a game going against it. So most managers will willingly take 10 losses going by the book rather than risk losing just one by going against it, and the book says bring in the closer in the ninth.
  10. FresnoDave
    10. Posted by FresnoDave Wed May 20, 2009 10:22 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I know how Cleveland fans feel. We Giants fans have a similar problem with our closer, Brian Wilson. He blew two ties in the ninth last week and every time he pitches he allows hits, walks, and almost always gets to a 3-2 count. We all remember the maddening days of Armando Benitez, and Wilson isn't much better. But, what are they going to do?
  11. rays_affliction
    11. Posted by rays_affliction Wed May 20, 2009 10:48 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Just two years ago the Indians had a good bullpen and a good starting rotation. Something has gone terribly wrong and things have to change. I'm sure the position players on the team cringe when every pitch is thrown by the staff. The only bright spot is Lee and they don't do anything to support him. This pitch count syndrome among major league managers is pathetic. When a starter is in the groove there is absolutely no reason to pull him unless his stuff starts to diminish. Like everyone else on the planet, some days you are really strong and some days you are less. The pitching staff on this team should really look at itself and figure out how to stop letting down a group of position players that are putting up enough runs to be a better than .500 team. Reality is that after a while the position players are going to let down and just not play as hard or, make that extra effort. Sounds bad but, we all know it's reality.
  12. rays_affliction
    12. Posted by rays_affliction Wed May 20, 2009 10:50 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    By the way, Eric Wedge took the Indians to the brink of the world series two years ago. Where is the real Eric Wedge?
  13. Bill
    13. Posted by Bill Wed May 20, 2009 10:51 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    To Revolution: You are a true fan of cleveland. Where were you at when the Indians were going to post seasons and winning the WS in the 90s? Oh, you must have be talking about how the cavaliers were the joke of NBA because back then, they were. Glad to see that you got on the cavalier's bandwagon. You stick with your team thru its ups and downs.
  14. PromethiusZ
    14. Posted by PromethiusZ Wed May 20, 2009 11:16 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    To rays_affliction:
    This Eric Wedge is the REAL Eric Wedge. Two years ago was a fluke. Wedge didn't have to do anything. He had more talent than he knew what to do with.
    The mark of a good or great mangaer is getting the most out of an average team. That is the main role of the manager. And Wedge only follows the book because he has no idea what to do without it.
    Finally, I grew up on Indians baseball, but I have decided that until Wedge gets fired, I am done watching this year.
  15. RML0819
    15. Posted by RML0819 Wed May 20, 2009 11:18 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    At least get the scores correct before expecting me to put any thought into your articles. Tiger win 4 - 0 on a 1 hitter, not 4 -1. Sometimes details are important. They help others trust you.
  16. jlpamc
    16. Posted by jlpamc Wed May 20, 2009 11:26 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    What happened to the lefty-righty matchup theory? Wedge pulls the lefthanded Lee and inserts the righthanded Wood. Then the lefthanded batters Jacobs and Teahan hit homeruns. Deja Vu. Wasn't Joe Borowski an ex-Cub also?
  17. Nick F
    17. Posted by Nick F Wed May 20, 2009 11:31 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    What's something the Cubs and Indians have in common? They haven't won a world series in over 60 years. I put my money on the Cubs to win next.
  18. Mark T
    18. Posted by Mark T Wed May 20, 2009 11:51 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I wouldn't put money on the Cubs to win if it were Game 4, up 3 games to none at Chicago with 2 strikes, 2 outs and a 20-0 lead.
    As for the Wedge (and managers in general) thing, nobody knows what is going to happen. Wedge went to his overpriced closer in a situation where he SHOULD get the job done. By saying they need to fire him because he brought in a guy who 9 times out of 10 will get the job done there and didn't is just stupid. You think there is a guy out there who can push all the right buttons all the time?
  19. tonyarob
    19. Posted by tonyarob Wed May 20, 2009 12:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Uh, Bill (post 13). The Indians haven't won the World Series since 1948.
  20. D Man
    20. Posted by D Man Wed May 20, 2009 12:36 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Anyone who thinks the Indians are the laughing stock of Cleveland didn't see too many Browns games last fall...
  21. Tut
    21. Posted by Tut Wed May 20, 2009 1:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    "...Royals set fire to Wood, barbecue Indians..." - Mr Brown, what knid of a headline is that? You need sensitivity training, my man. LMAO!! Seriouly!
  22. J Rizz
    22. Posted by J Rizz Wed May 20, 2009 6:57 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I was at the K last night with my buddies and it was probably the greatest ball game I've ever been to. I saw an awesome 9th inning comeback at Wrigley by Slammin' Sammy and the Crime Dog one time against the Phils that was pretty sweet, but I had never seen back to back HR's in person, by my team, ever in my life. The feeling that follows is complete joy- we were jumping around like Chalmers had just hit that trey in Rose's eye (later Mempiss). Then the triple by DeJesus, who's been struggling a bit, and the sac by the Willie who hits NINTH in the order?! That stuff didn't used to happen around here, so don't be surprised when people are swimming in the fountains in September!
  23. J Rizz
    23. Posted by J Rizz Wed May 20, 2009 6:59 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    T-Bone, sensitivity training? KC is known for barbecue, the pitcher's name is Wood, that headline practically wrote itself, c'mon dude, lighten up. It's baseball.
  24. Older_than_Moses_Shaq
    24. Posted by Older_than_Moses_Shaq Wed May 20, 2009 7:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    If you've got a closer you'd expect him to get the job done. When Wood is on his game he's as tough as anybody in the league. When I saw his fastball only reaching 94 mph I knew he wasn't on his game. That's the job of the bullpen coach to be able to spot when a guy's ready to come out of the bullpen. Clearly, he should've told Wedge he wasn't ready and Wedge could've let Lee start the ninth. Maybe Lee gets hit and then they go to their closer. But some of the managers in the league, Mike Soscia, for instance, have their set routines and they're quite successful because of them. Wood gets lit up and it's Wedge's fault? What the heck are they paying him the big bucks for? To do what he failed to do yesterday. It's all on Wood.

Big League Stew

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

'Duk

Big League Stew is an MLB blog edited by Kevin Kaduk. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Contributors:
David Brown, Alex Remington,

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Big League Stew Recent Readers