Big League Stew - MLB

If you recall a story about a man who got kicked out of Yankee Stadium last August for moving from his seat during the playing of "God Bless America," you also might recall saying the following to yourself: "Well, that sounds like a lawsuit."

Well, Nostradamus, your vision has come to pass.

Backed by New York State's Civil Liberties Union, Bradford Campeau-Laurion is suing the Yankees and the NYPD for throwing him out of the game. He claims to be a victim of political and religious discrimination.

Campeau-Laurion, a 30-year-old resident of Astoria in Queens, said he wanted to use the restroom and didn't feel like waiting for the Kate Smith standard to end. Fans are required to do as per Yankee Stadium rules. Shortly after getting up from his seat, his version of the story goes, security confronted him.

"I then said to [one], 'I don't care about God Bless America. I just need to use the bathroom,' " Campeau-Laurion told New York's CBS-TV affiliate last August. "As soon as I said that, he immediately pinned my arm behind my back." He soon was ejected.

A statement from Donna Lieberman, the state's executive director of the ACLU, said the Yankees and police used patriotism as cause to violate Campeau-Laurion's rights.

"New York's finest have no business arresting someone for trying to go to the bathroom at a politically incorrect moment," Lieberman said in a Bloomberg News story.

It wasn't an arrest, or even much of a detention. They kicked him out for violating a stadium rule — of which Campeau-Laurion says he wasn't aware — and for causing a disturbance. Paul Browne, a spokesman for the NYPD, says Campeau-Laurion's actions went beyond getting up to go to the bathroom.

"The officers observed a male standing on his seat, cursing, using inappropriate language and acting in a disorderly manner while reeking of alcohol and decided to eject him rather than subject others to his offensive behavior," Browne said.

Campeau-Laurion painted a different picture of how he was sent home.

Here's video from last year.

"[One] shoved me out the front gate and told me get out of their country if I didn't like it," Campeau-Laurion said.

Ironic and ignorant, if true, considering the U.S. is just as much Campeau-Laurion's country as it is for the officers who tossed him.

All this over a song?

The Yankees started playing the iconic tune during the seventh inning in the wake of the 9-11 terrorist attacks in 2001, a national horror that affected many New Yorkers in even greater fashion. The team added the rule by mid-October of that year, after some fans complained that others were failing to observe the moment with peace and quiet.

Campeau-Laurion says he doesn't mind that the Yankees play the song but to prevent people from walking to the bathroom while its performed — for a minute, for 30 seconds, even for 1 second — is extreme, even illegal.

How did it all really go down? Not sure, I wasn't there. It seems that Campeau-Laurion might have been picking a fight. Telling the cop he "didn't care about ‘God Bless America' " is a good way to get a guy's Irish up. For all he knows, the cop lost a colleague or more in the World Trade Center attacks.

But does anyone think it should be legal for a baseball team to force its fans to be still and quiet, unless it's an emergency? It's certainly not good policy.

Fans choosing to be still for "God Bless America" is patriotic.

But being forced to do it? Sounds more appropriate for a place like China.

When the lawsuit is resolved, or even before, here's hoping any activity during "God Bless America" becomes voluntary at Yankee Stadium. That's the American way.

digg delicious
more

92 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. cartoon
    1. Posted by cartoon Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    straight up -
    when people are telling you when to be patriotic - THAT is the fascism that everyone is talking about these days...
  2. Michael F
    2. Posted by Michael F Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:57 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    So no D-bag can claim to be first, I'll simply say that I read this appalled at the story until I heard the cops' point of view. Like every other issue involving rights being violated, there are two totally different sides for what actually happened. It'd be interesting to consult someone who saw all this go down.
  3. Kevin
    3. Posted by Kevin Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:22 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    USA! USA!
    If I want to leave during that song I can. If I want to keep my hat on during the national anthem, why can't I? That's right, this isn't China where we are forced to sit and listen to patriotic songs whether we like it or not.
  4. Hambone
    4. Posted by Hambone Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:17 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm sorry, but the cops statement sounds largely made up. The guy admits to saying to the cops "I don't care about God Bless America", so he doesn't seem like he's painting himself as a saint. The officers sound like they're trying to justify themselves. Furthermore, I don't see how this rule can be enforced.
  5. This is Dave, Hello There!
    5. Posted by This is Dave, Hello There! Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Bob, it's not respectful for someone to make a ruckus during God Bless America. The Yankees can still regulate that by telling people to shut up if they're bothering others. But no walking down the aisle? No peeing in the bathroom?
    That ain't the America I love.
  6. gaborik10m
    6. Posted by gaborik10m Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:05 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Ok theres a HUGE difference between getting up to go to the bathroom and standing on a seat yelling drunken profanities...so which is it?
    If its a rule in your house that no one can go to the bathroom when they need to, i think you need some serious help.
  7. HA-HA
    7. Posted by HA-HA Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:04 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Someone living in America, especially NYC post 9/11, should not be forced to be patriotic... If they are not patriotic after what happened on that day, they need to be kicked upside the head and out of the COUNTRY, not just out of a friggin' stadium. It's those type of people... the liberals and the atheists... that have helped to degrade this country. Anyone who has ever put their life on the line for this country is proud of our anthem and has found god at some point in their life. If you don't believe, STFU and respect those that do and provide you with the freedom to think like an idiot. Most countries TELL you what to do and how to feel, without the freedoms "Americans" take for granted.
  8. mark_3_1_6
    8. Posted by mark_3_1_6 Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:08 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The man seems unreasonable not to wait a minute for a song to end, but I see his point.
    If they are going to kick people out for moving during god bless america then they should do the same to people who move around during the singing of national anthems. I was disgusted to see people boo the Canadian national anthem when the bluejays were in town at yankee stadium, but I'm sure nobody cares because its Canada right?
    Such hipocrits we Americans are.
  9. gaborik10m
    9. Posted by gaborik10m Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:05 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Atheists don't degrade anything NELSON, how many retarded 'Christians' do you see on a Sunday afternoon during NFL season who 'THANK THE LORD' for their performance and then go out and drive drunk, get busted for drugs or are just general pains in the ass of society? Or how about the nice Sunday School teacher who's on trial for murdering her own daughter (i think theres some sort of rape charge mixed in there too) Upstanding citizen!
    Character has nothing to do with religious or even political belief, it has to do with your brain. And if you haven't talked to a lot of people, or noticed that CSI: Miami is a hit show (WTF) or that people love NASCAR, you haven't noticed that about 99% of America is just plain stoopud.
  10. Satan
    10. Posted by Satan Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:22 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    HA-HA you ignorat fool..."If you don't believe, STFU and respect those that do..." OK and in return respect those that don't believe in your false, hypocrite beliefs. Religion is nothing but false hope, lies and deceit for mindless fools like yourself and all the other jesus freaks, bible thumpers and holy rollers out there. "Great spirits have always encountered violent opposition from mediocre minds. The mediocre mind is incapable of understanding the man who refuses to bow blindly to conventional prejudices and chooses instead to express his opinions courageously and honestly. " - Albert Einstein, letter to Morris Raphael Cohen
    PS. Accept Satan as your Lord
  11. Cowboys Are 5 Time World Champs
    11. Posted by Cowboys Are 5 Time World Champs Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:53 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Just another stupid event that ignorant people get bent about. There are some stupid rules and laws out there and this is an example of one! hey i just slapped my kid's hand in public for picking his nose, oh no im assaulting and abusing him, call the cops. arrest me and take him away from me cuz im not capable of caring for him! c'mon people get a grip. quit overreacting. but hey, i can't help everyone stay in school and get an education! i hate those people who take everything too serious to the point where they have to make a scene about it!
    EFF OVER REACTORS!!! Yes the police in that situation, and i thought u were suppose to be loud and obnoxious at sports games, but hey i could be wrong!
  12. dumpsta
    12. Posted by dumpsta Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:38 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    wow, this is an example of nyc's finest taking too many authority pills. It's very surprising that this happens in probably the most diverse city in terms of religion in the world.
  13. Cowboys Are 5 Time World Champs
    13. Posted by Cowboys Are 5 Time World Champs Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:53 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    i personally would of just pissed at my seat in that case! cause oh no i might offend someone by going to the bathroom during the singing of "god BLESS AMERICA", wheres is god anyways i sure would like to meet this almighty "BEING" one day!, oh wait i forgot i just need "FAITH" in him! haha! Geez i love the retards that believe in a higher power! cuz those retards are the ones that are holding the rest of world back. YES i love religious wars!
  14. RobertK
    14. Posted by RobertK Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:57 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    we deserve this,,, we stood by while out rights were trampled ,, not by the terrorists, but by the Bush regime. so you either do this ... or else
  15. frank F
    15. Posted by frank F Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:01 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Once again David Brown proves himself to be a idiot! What's American is the Yankees being able to make there own rules! You jacka$$!
  16. cm
    16. Posted by cm Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:20 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Most cops have a high school education. It's insane the power they are given and constantly abuse.
  17. M. McRazz
    17. Posted by M. McRazz Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:04 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Normally, I would say that the owner of the stadium gets to set the rules. People mistakenly think that the Constitution refers to private places of business.
    But then I looked it up, and the new Yankee Stadium was funded just over 55% by public taxpayer money...so in that case, they can take that rule and stick it up their asses.
  18. Cowboys Are 5 Time World Champs
    18. Posted by Cowboys Are 5 Time World Champs Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:53 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    With the way it is nowadays, we might as well become a communist nation. i mean we're already being told what to do, how to dress, what to eat, when to be respectful, who determined what respectful is, what if it is disrespectful not to take a piss while the song is played! hell i think its respectful to kiss my ass every time u see me!
  19. Leathers
    19. Posted by Leathers Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The National Anthem is completely different than God Bless America. It's one thing to be patriotic, to care about where you came from, but to enforce that 40,000 people not only listen, but also care about, a song that clearly caters to Christianity, that's just plain un-American. NYC is probably the most diverse city in the country in regards to religion, and somehow some people expect every last person in that stadium to sit and not have a problem with what's going on. Incredible.
  20. Butt Pirate
    20. Posted by Butt Pirate Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:03 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Damn it, when george steinbrenner says stand, you will stand. and when he says bend over and grab your ankles, you will do so. and you will like it.
    i did.
  21. Anrkist
    21. Posted by Anrkist Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:56 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    You telling me no one has ever gotten up to pee during God Bless America? This guy is a joke.
  22. Billy M
    22. Posted by Billy M Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:08 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Hey, #19, since you brought up the fact that the government tells us what we can and can't do, look up bill HR 1388 on google.
  23. dragon43078
    23. Posted by dragon43078 Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:47 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    If anyone tried to stop me from going to the bathroom there, the stadium would be renamed after me after I sued their dumb ass. You gotta go..you gotta go. This sounds too much like communism to me. To force a person to stand up and listen to an old song or get thrown out without recompence. Yet another reason for the rest of the Nation to hate the Yankees.
  24. bgtd
    24. Posted by bgtd Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:33 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Of course the Yankees (a private entity) can tell people when to stay in their seats, probably subject only to the fire code. I'm not sure I even see a problem with having the police enforce this. As an analogous situation, you have the right to exercise your religion freely, but you don't have the right to set up a worship service on my front lawn if I don't want you there. I can call the police to have you ejected from my land from trespassing. I don't see the difference with this situation, your ticket is a contract that requires you to abide by stadium rules. Is it a stupid rule? Sure. But the Yanks are a private corporation, if you don't like what they do, root for the Mets. I guess you can make the argument that the Yanks are a state actor, public funding and all, I don't know how far you'd get with that in court.
    Also, 22 is on to something. There has to be more to the story of the guy provoking the police. People probably break this rule all the time without incident.
  25. stmac70
    25. Posted by stmac70 Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Typical liberal BS. He doesn't respect his country. Yes you have to take your hat off during the national anthem. Yes it is only respectful to stand during god bless America. People in this country has forgotten what made this country what it was. Now for all your so called rights and disrespect of our country it is falling apart. If you cant respect and be proud of your country,then why should anybody from any other country?
    Another frivolous lawsuit......I don't even like the New York Yankees,but I will stand and respect my country when the National anthem and God bless America is played at an event. While we are at it I think we should bring the Pledge back into school and prayer. This country has lost its religion and its sad.

Big League Stew

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

'Duk

Big League Stew is an MLB blog edited by Kevin Kaduk. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Big League Stew Recent Readers