Big League Stew - MLB

BLS contributor Nick Friedell attended Thursday's MLB draft in Florida and is filing a few reports on what he saw.

I walked into the Milk House at Disney's Wide World of Sports Complex with an open mind.

I wanted to give the MLB Draft a chance.

I knew that Major League Baseball was trying to make the draft an "event," much like the NFL has done with its yearly extravaganza. This is only the second year that baseball has tried such a format — Bud Selig walking to the podium to announce selections, ESPN analysts providing live coverage and fans in the stands cheering the picks.

It's a great path for baseball to follow, but there's still a lot of room for improvement as MLB still lags behind the other three sports in terms of the amount of attention its draft receives.

Here, then, are a few easy ways for Bud Selig and his MLB minions to continue building interest in what they hope will be an annual hallmark event:

Move the draft to a night-time start: Who is going to watch this thing, if it starts at 2 pm ET on a random Thursday in June? If MLB is serious about making the draft a popular, annual event, it has to move the start time back, even if that means that the draft runs up against some games. It's already running against some day games, so why not just move it back a few hours?

Make the draft a baseball holiday: The ideal time to hold this draft would be the day after the All-Star game, when nothing else is going on, but since that probably won't happen, why not give all of baseball a day off, and let everybody watch the draft? It's a radical idea to be sure, but that's the beauty of the NFL, NBA and NHL Drafts ... there is nothing else going on and the leagues make it into a media event. It's a time when fans of those leagues can watch and learn about the new players entering those leagues.

Make the Top 10 players, who are still not playing, come to the draft: I can't tell you how anti-climatic it was to watch Bud Selig announce the fist pick, and then not see him shake the player's hand (in this case, it was Tim Beckham, who was back in Georgia), and take pictures while the player smiles, and holds up his new team's jersey. Every other league does it like that, so why can't the MLB pick up the cost of a couple of airline tickets if the prospects don't have any prior playing commitments?

Find a different location for the draft: Disney World is a nice place, and the people there do a good job setting up all kinds of different events, but there has to be a better place for the draft. As I've mentioned before on the Stew, Orlando is not really a hotbed for baseball fans. In fact, it's the largest media market in the country (19) without a minor or major league baseball team. A simple solution would be to rotate the draft between Major League cities. First up, New York and the glare of the nation's biggest media corps.

Find the Mel Kiper, Jr. of baseball: The popularity of the NFL Draft can be traced in many ways to the rise of Mel Kiper, Jr. on ESPN. Whether people love him or hate him, they watch him throughout the year to see what he has to say about prospects in the draft. ESPN needs to go out and find somebody with a made-for-tv personality (preferably a Kiper-style 'do as well) whose only job is to break down the draft all season, and talk about it on the air. If they find somebody like Kiper, and give him a platform throughout the year, it might actually get people excited — not to mention knowledgeable about the players involved — when baseball draft day approaches.

Allow teams to trade draft picks: This has been discussed for several years, by many different people in baseball circles. But why not let teams trade their draft picks?  It would not only give teams another way to make roster moves, but it would make the draft itself much more interesting.

Baseball fans would be glued to their television sets to see whether or not their favorite team was going to make a draft-day deal. Drafting a player no one has heard of, who won't be ready for the majors for a few years, if ever, doesn't excite the average fan. Trading that pick for a veteran player who can make an immediate impact would.

digg delicious
more

33 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. bobby spectacular
    1. Posted by bobby spectacular Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    i really agree with the last one ... itd be great cause the a's would have like 8 first round picks with beanes genius
  2. NolesFan90
    2. Posted by NolesFan90 Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    What's up with the disrespect for Orlando? If the Rays moved to Orlando, they might actually come close to selling out games. We could even build a better field than that ridiculous excuse of a field called "the trop" located in St. Petersburg that even Tampa residents claim is too far of a drive to go to games. We have been able to support an NBA franchise for over twenty years. Orlando is a perfect place for the MLB draft. MLB just needs to hold it on a Saturday like the NFL does and make it just before the free agent signing period like the NFL and NBA do. The early start time wouldn't matter if it was held on a weekend. For that matter the NBA should also hold their draft on a weekend. Orlando is a ripe baseball market. If any of the Florida MLB teams played here they would have better attendance. Don't blame Orlando for MLB dropping the ball when they decided on cities to expand in Florida. They went for glamorous bigger metropolitan areas over booming cities that actually had baseball fans. MLB holding their annual draft in Orlando is at least a step in the direction of them recognizing that error.
  3. madase
    3. Posted by madase Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    all points are valid---i agree
  4. TiZZaH
    4. Posted by TiZZaH Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Does the draft still have like 600 rounds?
  5. Eric T
    5. Posted by Eric T Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:57 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Baseball is my favorite sport, but the draft will never compare to that of the NFL and NBA. It's just a totally different animal. While I like the suggestions, the MLB draft has a couple big drawbacks. First, the following for college baseball is almost non-existent, so most or all of the players are unknowns on the national stage (not to mention the large number of high school players). Second, even most of the college players are years away from playing in the big leagues. The article captures this at the very end, but it's hard to get excited about a bunch of guys I've never heard of who will take several years to make it to the bigs, if ever. In the NFL and NBA, there's a much better chance of the draft having an immediate impact on a team.
  6. Lakerxxxs
    6. Posted by Lakerxxxs Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:59 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    how the hell r they gonna trade picks there are tons of rounds and in baseball there is no gurantee on any pick in football a player can come in and play right away same thing in basketball but in baseball it takes someone 2,3 years to get to the majors and 95 % of the players drafted dont even make it to the majors!!
  7. Michael L
    7. Posted by Michael L Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:28 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    can we have somebody else introduce the picks too -- it was amusing to see bud selig sneer while trying to read the teleprompter for the next team to pick
  8. Chipper
    8. Posted by Chipper Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:29 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    NUMBER 8 all legit ideas
  9. Older_than_Moses_Shaq
    9. Posted by Older_than_Moses_Shaq Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:56 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Had they not had the draft 2008 logo under him I'd have expected Bud to say I'll have another shot and a beer. The guy looked like guys you see who've already pounded a few back. He needs a stylist to fix him up before he goes in public.
  10. Goodoleboy58
    10. Posted by Goodoleboy58 Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:05 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    My biggest issue with the draft is the time of year... Nobody will ever know much about highschool stars but the College World Series could be a major boost to the MLB Draft. However, holding the draft before the College World Series robs the most televised college baseball events from holding a special meaning to the fans. Imagine a walkoff grandslam from a potential 1st round pick and everyone clamoring for him to be on their team. As it is now that walkoff grandslam will only excite whosoever fan base drafted the guy already.
  11. sdcubfan
    11. Posted by sdcubfan Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Trades of picks don't make any sense, since no GM in his right mind will trade a guy
    who can have an impact at present for a pick which might blossom 3 years or more
    from now, although, something similar happens when teams lose free agents, but
    pick up supplemental picks in the process. If dollars weren't a factor, no GM would
    allow this to occur. Even if it were allowed (to address a teams fiscal issues), it
    wouldn't make that much of an impact. Proof: Without looking at the 1st three rounds,
    name the teams involved in draft pick swaps due to Free Agent signings. You may be
    ble to by considering who the big Free Agents signed with last winter. However, one
    draft pick was exchanged. Name it... Tell me why it was swapped... Most won't be able to...
    As for the time of day, that is exactly why somebody invented
    DVRs/VCRs/your-favorite-recording-device-here. It makes the
    TOD inconsequential.
  12. Baron
    12. Posted by Baron Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I really don't want the baseball draft to come anything close to the NBA and NFL draft. I hate how much press is given to the drafts, especially the NFL when the number of busts in the NFL draft is similar to MLB. I try to watch a draft every once in awhile, but just cannot stand it. Drafts are really freaking boring and take two full days. I will just read a first round recap and look at who my team has picked up.
  13. Drew
    13. Posted by Drew Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:00 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    They have found the mel kiper jr of baseball his name is Law, I think the largest reason their draft sucks so much is because 3/4 of those players that dont get annonced in the first round go to college and 4 years later spend most of thier carerr in minor league baseball. I understand that the system but thats the reason the Mlb will always be behind, its just the fact that when they draft those players you wont see them in the starting line up from maybe 5 years unlike the NBA and the NFL which are drafted and start the next year
  14. going going gone
    14. Posted by going going gone Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:04 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I agree that there should be trading of picks for picks or picks for veteran players. I also do agree that there should be a draft analysist that does get envolved with the draft and put interest in who should be pick for what teak. The draft should be shortened to 10 rounds at first and then how it goes and maybe it should be down 7 rounds in the future. And if ESPN or MLB.Com is looking for someone who is dedicated to baseball with both college and minor and major levels give me a ring or message, I will be waiting patiently.
  15. Mike S
    15. Posted by Mike S Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Keith Law and Jim Callis do a great job as draft analysts. Follow along on the ESPN and Baseball America websites and you'll see prospect lists, mock drafts, and analysis of prospects. Trading picks shouldn't be so much for trades with current players but more for a team like the Mets who need an overhaul of their minor league system can trade their top pick for multiple later picks. And very rarely is there a consensus among who the top 10 picks will be due to signability and teams willing to break slotting requirements
  16. Ryan R
    16. Posted by Ryan R Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:57 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I think they should only be allowed to trade picks for picks not veteran players. This gets rid of the fact that you will trade picks that are a few years a way for an instant veteran fix. You could move up a few spots by trading a first and say a fourth round pick, like they do in the NFL draft.
  17. robert e
    17. Posted by robert e Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:36 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Let's get it done asap! Get out of Mickey Land. Get top players there in person. ESPN airing at 2 pm is sick. I understand we are in a depression/recession and no one is working, but come on. Most of us are still wipping toilet seats at 3pm to pay for all of this.
  18. First L
    18. Posted by First L Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    well...the NFL has their draft in the offseason. Have the MLB Draft maybe a month after the World Series....i'm all for the other suggested changes for making the MLB Draft a watchable event every year
  19. Neo
    19. Posted by Neo Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:35 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Orlando is a wantabe cow town. Most of the residents don't have 2 nickles to rub together. I lived there for 2 years seemed like 20. They hate educated people and still have a longing for the bars and stars..
  20. Mile High Bolts Fan
    20. Posted by Mile High Bolts Fan Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    @5 ... 50 rounds / 1495 picks this year. As for a location, not a fan of moving it around; for a different permanent place, how about Cooperstown ???
  21. terry h
    21. Posted by terry h Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    i totally agree with comment #17 trading picks for picks. also, i believe there should be a slotted bonuses(like the NBA and in the near future the NFL). this way the bad teams get to select the best players and not have any scott boros deals keeping them from going to bigger market teams OR not being drafted until later than they should. some kids are making more money than good MAJOR LEAGUERS who are proven.
  22. CplaneLawr
    22. Posted by CplaneLawr Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:23 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Cooperstown is a great idea, have the draft the Monday or Thursday after the College World Series with a Baseball Holiday (make sure it can't come up against the NBA finals) and start is around 8 pm EDT. This would allow for the top rated players ALL to be thereI would include the top 100 or so) and only have the first 2 or 3 rounds as the "EVENT." The rest of the players are going to be relatively obscure and not of much interest outside of their schools and families. Allow trading draft choices, but the issue of slotting might not work because some players are much closer to being ready for the majors than others. There might be a way to slot based upon draft position/age(or college experience) as a factor, but certainly it would make the draft more fair to slot.
  23. CplaneLawr
    23. Posted by CplaneLawr Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:23 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Oh yeah, one other thing.....find someone more attractive and less sleazy than Bud Selig to announce the draftees.
  24. wkl
    24. Posted by wkl Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    didn't know they couldn't trade the picks (why not)? what if some team is willing to trade up for a Jered Weaver or similar type (that dropped to what 14 because of his anti-christ agent). as afar as only picks for picks (again who cares)? make the team dumping the veteran pick up some of the remaining contract so it isn't just a salary dump. would make the draft a little interesting because now it's checking out the first few picks and who cares for 3 or 4 years.

Big League Stew

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

'Duk

Big League Stew is an MLB blog edited by Kevin Kaduk. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Big League Stew Recent Readers