Tue Nov 10, 2009 6:34 pm EST
The topic of instant replay came up at the general manager meetings today, but conversation was apparently limited to the current system and did not touch upon expanding it past home run calls.
Instead, the stubborn general managers symbolically lined up behind commissioner Bud Selig in a stance that sees no use for making sure the game is called fairly and accurately.
I mean, it's enough to make a baseball fan run toward the nearest cement wall with his or her head lowered.
Jimmie Lee Solomon, one of Selig's guys, said the GMs were briefed by an umpiring official on training, evaluation and structure. I would guess that means that MLB is looking to make umpires more accountable for their calls.
And after the disasters of the just-passed postseason, I suppose that's good news.
But it's not nearly good enough. Though hell hath no fury like the baseball blogosphere piling on an umpire's blown call, I still believe that no one feels worse in the aftermath than the man in blue himself. Umpires aren't going to get more calls right because they're subject to a harsher penalty; they're already putting enough pressure on themselves as it is.
And since we live in a world of 78 camera angles per game and frame-by-frame replay, there's no way for an umpire to be 100 percent accurate and escape public ridicule.
Look, the technology could easily be there to provide a safety net for the human element on the field. It came through without much lost time during A-Rod's camera home run during Game 3 of the World Series and has been streamlined in almost every other sport.
Why not let it come through in other spots that are just as crucial?
Why must this be so difficult?
Big League Stew is an MLB blog edited by Kevin Kaduk. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Posted Nov 22 2009
Scioscia gets top manager honors
Posted Nov 18 2009
Rockies skipper is NL manager of the year
Posted Nov 18 2009
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by E. Brennan
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Andy Behrens
29 Comments
1 - 25 of 29
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
a sort of a Super Ump!
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
heres my point with replay in regards to the teams wanting it or not. These are the guys shelling out the millions of dollars for the players to get the wins and attract the fans and to turn the millions they've spent into millions earned. if this made the game better in any way I'm pretty sure they would have jumped all over the opportunity by now.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
However, the fact is that replay would spoil the live experience, which should be the focus of the 162 game season. Once you get to the post season, though, why not expand replay? They have extra umps for post season, so just use expanded replay for playoffs and World Series.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
But the point of your argument makes sense...How can we overturn a call (even a fair/foul call) when the initial call altered everyone's conduct. It's the same when a runner is ruled down by contact on the field and fumbles. The whistle blows the play dead...what are the players supposed to do, and how is an umpire supposed to predict what would have happened if the play continued?
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
How would we ever expect the owners and the owner/commish to do anything that isn't stupid? I mean, come on, look at their history...
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Bub Selig should be replaced if he does not go for instant replay.................this years playoffs and world series was the worst in baseball history......Yankees should not even been there!!!
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
MEN IN THE MIDDLE - losing interest in baseball, playing games in the freakin snow, umps are a joke and fatter than hell. game is losing credibility quickly.
YOUNG MEN - we dont like baseball
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
1 - 25 of 29