Big League Stew - MLB

Fri Sep 28, 2007 3:18 am EDT

Five and Fly: National scramble

It's the last Friday of the regular season, and exactly zero National League playoff spots have been claimed. Seven teams will bottleneck into four slots, and each game Thursday night teemed with importance.

What did we learn?

The Mets' collapse is complete.
The Phillies' resurrection is too.

The Rockies might never lose again.

The Diamondbacks better hope they do .

The Cubs are bad.

The Brewers are worse.

The Padres are lucky to be in Milwaukee.

Excitement and fear both course through clubhouses, while pure energy – good and bad – emanates from stadiums. No one in Philadelphia cares that Ryan Howard set a major-league record with his 196th strikeout this season. They're just glad Pat Burrell is hitting like a $13 million player. And no one in New York knew that the last time Joel Piñeiro threw at least eight shutout innings was May 30, 2003. They just knew the most recent time was Sept. 27, 2007.

So as fans panic and great pitching matchups present themselves and winning streaks keep going – only nine teams this decade have exceeded Colorado's 11 straight – it's no longer a disconcerting mess to envision all the possibilities.

It's a fun, wild, messy final weekend – exactly what baseball could use.

FIVE …

• Rather than go over the potential tie scenarios here, we'll allow David Pinto to explain – and to state his case that those looking for the best four-way tie possible should root for the Rockies and against the Diamondbacks.

• Then again, the Rockies' pitchers for the last two games don't exactly inspire confidence. After today's games, here are the starters on whom seven teams' seasons rest:

Mets: John Maine and Tom Glavine
Rockies: Mark Redman and Ubaldo Jimenez
Padres: Chris Young and Brett Tomko
Diamondbacks: Edgar Gonzalez and Doug Davis
Phillies: Adam Eaton and Jamie Moyer
Cubs: Rich Hill and Ted Lilly
Brewers: Dave Bush and Jeff Suppan

• While we're on Milwaukee, no word better describes the Brewers than pathetic. The Cubs tanked an entire series against Florida, and all the Brewers could manage was a one-game gain in the standings. How can a team that so desires a postseason slot commit five errors in a game and be taken seriously? With one more Brewers loss and Cubs win, Chicago clinches the division.

Oh, and for those who believe Ryan Braun is a runaway choice as NL Rookie of the Year – three of those errors were his, adding to his major-league-leading total for a third baseman and dropping his fielding percentage below .900.

• Not that Diamondbacks manager Bob Melvin would consider such a maneuver, but doesn't it seem absolutely reasonable to use Micah Owings as a pinch-hitter for an everyday player? The perfect candidates: Arizona's right fielders, who are hitting .242 and slugging .361 in 582 at-bats this season. Owings, on the other hand, is batting .339 with a .695 slugging percentage after his 4-for-4 day Thursday.

• OK, OK, enough of the NL. Cleveland starter C.C. Sabathia pitches tonight at Kansas City for the Cy Young Award. Yes, it's practically a meaningless game – the Indians will face the Yankees in the first round in almost every conceivable scenario – and yet voters will look for a standout performance to separate him from Josh Beckett. In his chance to impress Thursday, Beckett yielded five runs in six innings. He now owns a higher ERA than Sabathia in 34 fewer innings, the same number of losses, fewer strikeouts and more walks. And if Sabathia beats Cleveland, his 19 wins are second in the AL to Beckett's 20.

… AND FLY

Seeing as this is the final Five and Fly of the season …

Last.

digg delicious
more

164 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Ken D
    1. Posted by Ken D Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:53 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I read the comments throughout the year and only once broke down and defended Pat Gillick, Pat Burrell, Charlie Manuel, and those within the Phils organization that took a beating throughout the season. Well, its the last weekend of the season and the Filthies are knocking on the door of Hotel Playoff looking for a seat at the table. GO PHILS!
  2. Mark
    2. Posted by Mark Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:46 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm a BIG METS fan and I have to say, I am totally disappointed with my team. Even if they do make the playoffs, I wouldn't be surprised if they get swept out of it in the first round.
    There are just too many things wrong with this team. The biggest one is probably Willie Randolph's reliance o his guts and experience over the "numbers". We also can blame Omar for signing Mota to 2 years after he confessed to using steriods. Maybe they should stick him one more time for the playoff push.
    I guess Mets fans all over the world are thinking, what the hell happened?!
  3. Dave B
    3. Posted by Dave B Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Does Kyle Kendrick and his 10-4 record for the Phillies get any rookie of the year consideration? If they had one more pitcher with his composure, consistency and ability they would have won the East a week ago
  4. JustinK
    4. Posted by JustinK Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:07 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    doesnt matter who wins the NL.. AL is dominating this year.
  5. Cactus Jack Sancho
    5. Posted by Cactus Jack Sancho Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Here is hoping for C.C. to get his C.Y. Award!!!
  6. travis k
    6. Posted by travis k Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:19 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I agree. If Sabathia finds a way to beat Cleveland, he should be handed the Cy Young. By my calculations, he would then be the first player to register a win against the team he currently plays for. Amazing.
  7. Gary W
    7. Posted by Gary W Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Go Rockies, 14 is a magical number!
  8. Your Boy  T
    8. Posted by Your Boy T Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    go PHILS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  9. Gary W
    9. Posted by Gary W Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The Rockies might never lose again.
    The Diamondbacks better hope they do .
    Thanks Jeff, this made me bust up!
  10. footdoc k
    10. Posted by footdoc k Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    what is being lost in why the NL wild card is so exciting is the play of the NL EAST teams other than NY and PHILLY. Sure, alot has to do with PHILLY winning and the METS collapsing, but look at the last place teams FLA and WASHINGTON. they could have easily thrown their season away but instead FLA just swept the CUBS and WASH has just killed the METS ( I believe they took 5/6 games these past 2 weeks), the BRAVES season ended last night, but even they had a chance and they practically knocked the BREWERS out last week winning 3/4 games. THE NL CENTRAL and WEST bottom feeders haven't done crap to make the race exciting. What have the dodgers, giants, reds, and pirates done these last 2 weeks except look to next year.
  11. aramalian
    11. Posted by aramalian Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:57 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Umm... Pirates took 2 of 3 from the D-Backs this week... someone should watch a little more Baseball Tonight and a little less Desperate Housewives.
  12. footdoc k
    12. Posted by footdoc k Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    aramalian,
    prior to the d-backs, pirates had lost 9 in a row! in the last 10 games played, none of the teams I mentioned has a .500 record except Houston who played St. Louis and Cincinnati (both teams out of the race). Both the Braves and Washington were 6-4 or better; Florida was 4-6 but they just swept the Cubs and Washington swept the Mets. The CEntral is a joke (neither team deserves to go to the playoffs. This last weekend, the WEST plays against top teams to make that division interesting but the giants and dodgers haven't done anything to make the west interesting. ok i'll give you 2/3 pirates over diamondbacks, but that's the only meaningful series where a bottom team took a series from playoff team other than the marlins or nationals.
  13. Narcisso
    13. Posted by Narcisso Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Nice Catch on that misprint of passans Travis K. Even as a person who despises the Indians i would have to bow down to Sabathia if he beat his own team tonite.
  14. Glenn S
    14. Posted by Glenn S Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Could you imagine the hype if the Rockies played on the East Coast instead of in the Forgotten Time Zone in a square state as far from an ocean or Great Lake as you can get in North America?
    The Rockies are well on pace to set the highest fielding percentage ever in the history of baseball.
    Tulo can make the case not just for rookie of the year and not just a golden glove but for the best combination of offense and defense by a rookie shortstop ever.
    Not only is Helton hitting .400 in September with power, he has committed only 2, as in two, error the whole year. Thanks the Baseball gods we didn't trade him to Boston last summer for some lame AAA rejects and half of Helton's salary.
    Altitude doesn't advantage defense. The humidor has made Coors field statistically far more of a normalized park. Yes the ball flies 15% further in Denver than at sea level. But Coors' dimentions are massive. The humidor has soften the balls and helped restrict their flight.
    The Rox are good likeable guys. I can't remember the last time a Rock got busted or said something stupid or self-absorbed.
    The Kid Rocks are the real deal. Consider this lineup:
    1B - Helton .318 16HR 89RBI, 2 errors - Team Leader, played for one team, Just a nice guy. Legit Gold Glove
    2B - Matsui .288 32SB 3 errors - backed up by utility ace Carroll
    SS - Tulowitski .292 23HR 94 RBI, 11 errors, MLB leader in Fielding .986, put outs, assists, double plays, No brainer Gold Glove and Rookie of the Year
    3B - Atkins .294 25HR, 107 RBI, 14 errors
    LF - Holiday .338 36 HR 117 runs 132 RBI, 3 errors, 11SB, legit Gold Glove and MVP
    CF - Tavaras (back for PHX home stand, he's been out most of the run) .320 33SB, 4 errors
    RF - Hawpe .289 29HR 111 RBI, cannon arm, his hole was his hitting against Lefties, which made him a semi-platooned RF, now he's suddenly crushing them
    C - Torrealba .260 7 HR, 7 errors, solid defense, very strong arm, calls game well, pitchers like throwing to him
    Bench
    UTL Carrol, plays all INF with exceptional defense
    OF Spillboughs .300 11HR 1 error, very good OF range and gun
    OF Sullivan .303 0 errors, excellent OF range and arm
    The Rox payroll is under $50 million.
    And most importantly, Coors is beautiful - nothing beats Denver on a cool low humidity bugless summer night. Denver has a hip, young, safe, fun downtown. You can park your car anywhere, troll the bars through LoDo dodging all the beautiful women in the fittest state in America.
    Broncos who?
  15. Chaos
    15. Posted by Chaos Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:04 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Funny you AL dominating believers. I would say this theory was crushed by St. Louis only what....last year. Thank You, Come Again.
  16. holycow
    16. Posted by holycow Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:20 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    the Cubs are not bad...winning 10 of their last 12 before coming to Florida
    the Padres legitimately won last night, regardless of errors by the Brewers.
    What are you smoking?
  17. Peach
    17. Posted by Peach Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Suddenly, the previous 161 games don't mean jack; all Philly has to do is win more games than the Mets do this weekend, and the division is ours! Go Phils!
  18. Bag of Asses
    18. Posted by Bag of Asses Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    You need to get more sleep. If my calculations are right, I do not believe C.C. Sabathia can beat Cleveland, but stranger things have happened. I would agree with the Ownings idea, but they tried that in Chicago and Zambrano was terriable in his pinch hit at bats. Also, make sure to keep Bill Murray out of the damn Cubs dugout, he may die down there.
  19. Sully
    19. Posted by Sully Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:58 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    LOL Go Trav. Even I missed that till I read your comment. That would be a feat for sure. I think with the over inflated media love for Boston, Buckett will get it regardless of what C.C. does. Although C.C.'s numbers are clearly better than bucketts, bsoton gets all the media hype.Like Pedrioa will get ROY even though he has the same knock as Braun as being a bad fielder. Delmon Young has had a great season and should get mad consideration as well. But he is on a small market team that is in the basement so he will not get the votes. Makes me wonder if the people that have votes are actual sports guys or hometown blockheads.
    GO YANKEES!!!!
  20. Don B
    20. Posted by Don B Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:15 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    On using Owings as a pinch-hitter: absolutely. I'm biased toward hitting, though, as evidenced by the fact that I said this week to a friend that the Marlins should turn Dontrelle Willis (over 5 ERA, but with a .277 average and a couple home runs this year) into a right fielder.
  21. A Yahoo! User
    21. Posted by A Yahoo! User Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I really hope Charlie Manuel has a trick up his sleeve to keep Adam Eaton off of the mound on Saturday night. He has single handidly kept the race this close and could be the person to blow it! Move Moyer up a day and use Lohse on Sunday!
  22. Sully
    22. Posted by Sully Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:58 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Alright Glenn, I'm sold. The Rockies are a class orginization that obvioulsy has a good scouting department. Correct me if I am wrong but outside of Taveras and Matsui the rest are farm products, right? Holliday could definitly be considered in the MVP talks considering that like Prince he is leading his team in average, home runs, rbis and runs scored. Not too mention, and I know this from having him on my fantasy squad, has been RED HOT the last month, which is what defines MVP. Carrying the team in the final push to gain the ticket to October.
    They just need some better pitching (one or two Wang like pitchers with that D) and they would be the team to beat, period.
    any good realestate left up there?
  23. jason f
    23. Posted by jason f Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:53 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Mets will prevail.
  24. Ramstein
    24. Posted by Ramstein Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    3 more errors for Braun!! Anybody who believes he should be ROY over Tulo is a cretin.
    GO ROX!!!!!!!!!

Big League Stew

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

'Duk

Big League Stew is an MLB blog edited by Kevin Kaduk. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Big League Stew Recent Readers