Devil Ball Golf - Golf

Tue Oct 21, 2008 6:37 pm EDT

Tinkering under the hood of the PGA

It's the (sort-of) offseason, and here at Devil Ball, we're kicking around various topics of interest to golfers worldwide. Today, we take on ways to improve the PGA Tour. One of the main problems golf faces is the collision between traditional and postmodern culture, between the golf-clappers and the full-throated screamers. Like it or not, though, we're in a louder society these days. And golf has to adapt, or it faces the threat of tennis-esque mass irrelevance. Here are a few of my ideas; you'll have the chance to air your own below.

Take us there. This one's a personal preference, but when I'm playing a new golf course, I do everything short of lay down and roll around on the green to get a feel for the place. TV coverage should do the same thing for us -- take us to every corner of the place, not just the fairways and greens. Follow the players out for a night in the local town. (Anthony Kim would be able to give us some great stories.) Check out that photo above -- stunning courses like that are what golf is all about. (Yes, that course is in Portugal and thus not likely to make the PGA Tour, but roll with me here.)

This Is Your Game. Golf is the only major sport with a significant majority of fans who still actually play the game. So why not play off that more? More tips, more outreach, more pros playing off-days on scrubby little municipal courses. "This Is Your Game" would be an ideal slogan.

It's about more than Tiger. As this year showed, Tiger won't be around forever, and when he goes -- whether through injury, retirement, or bad early rounds that put him out of contention on Sunday -- many of golf's casual fans will follow. That's why golf has to cultivate a new generation of stars, and fortunately enough, a new generation is here. Is it calculated? Is it scheming? Is it hype over substance? Absolutely. It's also the way things are done these days -- again, like it or not. Sure, you'll have some Michelle Wie-style flameouts, but if you can pump up an Anthony Kim or a Camilo Villegas to star levels, so much the better. That said ...

It's all about Tiger. There's a reason you see so many Tiger-related articles on this site. You may be sick of him, but there are several million people who don't aren't. (Hat tip: grammar police.) Tiger is a worldwide icon, and golf would be foolish to run away from him. Tiger's stint as a caddy this week is a perfect example -- the guy needs to be human, needs to be more accessible, needs to make you feel like you could play like him, and not just on a video game. Yes, it's more than we expected out of Jack or Arnie, but again, different times, different expectations of our pros.

The All-Star Showdown. This is a great idea recently advanced by Ryan Ballengee at Waggle Room -- an event of varying games and styles, celebrating golf and golfers rather than sponsors. Skills competitions, pro-fan interaction, affordable tickets -- in short, a great way to connect players and fans while still seeing how good the best really are.

Ryder up the joint. Everybody enjoyed the Ryder Cup -- well, everybody American -- and that's because for a moment, we were allowed to be both golf fans and American sports fans. Look, there's plenty of room for both exuberance and sportsmanship in golf. Why not encourage a little more of that kind of atmosphere at other tournaments around the country? It would require not just tournament directors unclenching, but players, too. And relax, there are plenty of exclusive clubs whose gates you can hide behind when the tournament's done.

Fix the damn championship, already. Look, this isn't college football. Golf is as decisive as it gets -- one guy shoots less than everybody else, and he wins. So enough with the points totals and the reallocations and the made-vs.-missed cuts and all that. Figure a way to get all the best golfers on the course at the end of the season, and then have them battle it out for one true champion.

Swordfights with nine-irons at every turn. Hey, couldn't hurt.

All right, your turn. Come up with your own ideas to improve the PGA's take on the game we all love. Winner gets a ten-year Tour exemption. Maybe.

digg delicious
more

71 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Superman
    1. Posted by Superman Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:57 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Jay, everything is perfect no "typos". you are good to go. thanks
    Villegas, is the man,
  2. Scotty
    2. Posted by Scotty Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    more match play tournaments
  3. Rick W
    3. Posted by Rick W Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Have a tournament where the golfers use only one club for the entire 18 holes. Such as a 7 iron. Off the tee, in the fairway, putting etc.
  4. sidney
    4. Posted by sidney Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    have a tournament where the pros pay an entrance fee (similar to poker tournaments) and the winner gets all.
  5. Kenneth D
    5. Posted by Kenneth D Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    A three club tourny. Players can take any 3 clubs they want, carry them around themselves and see who can score the best. That will show some true imagination and shot making.
  6. kenneth22k
    6. Posted by kenneth22k Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    here's an idea from a golf lover..
    as well all know traditional golf is simply all about stroke play, a stroke can decide winner and loser of the tourny. now let me introduce a system of new golf era.
    Let's make Certain holes of the course(or all 18holes) have TWO different HOLES; for example par 3 & par 5 is being layed on a same hole, which will give players more option to take the lead, or play safe to keep the lead.
    Picture this;
    Tiger is a stroke ahead of AK, in the final 18th hole which has par 3 green and par 5. tiger decides to get a bridie on par 3, yet he misses and gets par. Ak, steps up, and tried to go for par 5 flag, past where tiger is going for. AK hits 2 on, and a put to get an eagle.. AK wins the tourny, and better luck next time Tiger.
    This is an idea, I'm in fact will be gathering documents to have PGA review it. What you think Jay? Email me or post something.
  7. Packer Backer
    7. Posted by Packer Backer Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:07 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Having tournys played on crappy munis. So We can see what pros would actually shoot when they play a course type that the majority of the general public plays.
  8. roger t
    8. Posted by roger t Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:35 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Packer Backer: Playing at muni's would have winning scores of -40 every week, no fun.
  9. roger t
    9. Posted by roger t Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:35 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Packer Backer: Playing at muni's would have winning scores of -40 every week, no fun.
  10. spenceryoumoron
    10. Posted by spenceryoumoron Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:59 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Hey Suffering,
    There may not have been any typos, but if you read the opening sentence from the section entitled "It's all about Tiger", I think you'll find an error:
    "It's all about Tiger. There's a reason you see so many Tiger-related articles on this site. You may be sick of him, but there are several million people who don't."
    Danny Noonan: "I thought you said winning isn't important"
    Ty Webb: "For me winning isn't, you do"
    Danny Noonan: "Good grammar"
  11. spenceryoumoron
    11. Posted by spenceryoumoron Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:59 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    To kenneth22k,
    So your proposal would put a par-3 green in the middle of a fairway that's being used on a par-5. Do the players who elect to play the hole as a par 5 walk AROUND this green in the middle of the fairway? Do they stop to repair ball marks on the that green that they just hit WITH THEIR DRIVER? I think that if you look at scoring, the par-5s play easier than the par-3s, so Tiger wouldn't choose to play the hole as a par-3, he'd try to make his birdie on the par-5 option. Plus, does your scoring system only take into account your relation to par? If not, then AK would have to make an eagle on the par-5 to match Tiger's par on the par-3. Basically, your idea is dumb, I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul.
  12. k
    12. Posted by k Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:24 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I am not sure who first came up with the idea, hot dog, but I would bet my own money on Lee Trevino in a 'winner take all' tournament...maybe even today!
  13. rich r
    13. Posted by rich r Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    One last thing---golf will always be bigger than tiger
  14. listeningpost
    14. Posted by listeningpost Thu Sep 03, 2009 6:54 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    A true champion would be a player who could win a tournament on Augusta National when played with USGA fairways and rough.
  15. rich r
    15. Posted by rich r Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    one last thing---golf will always be bigger than tiger
  16. bruce d
    16. Posted by bruce d Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    At least one mixed tourney a year. LPGA and PGA. Different tees, two cuts, play your own ball. Invitational so the field isn't too big,
  17. J
    17. Posted by J Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Recruit the hottest local girls to caddy for the caddies in skimpy outfits. That will obviously attract viewers and test every pro's focus.
  18. FoxyStarrGurl
    18. Posted by FoxyStarrGurl Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    a lots of stupid ideas,but the one about a mixed tourney is a good idea.i think it would draw a good following,and would help the lpga greatly. i can see it now,tiger and paula creamer on the same team,how sweet it is
  19. nuttyprofessor134578
    19. Posted by nuttyprofessor134578 Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    We need at least one tournament where the fans can yell and scream for their favorite golfer or their least favorite golfer. Let's see the pros hit that great 3 iron over water on a Par 5 with the fans yelling in his back swing. Let's see them make that pressure 5 footer with about 1,000 fans green side screaming at the tops of their lungs. Does this sound so radical? Think about a basketball player shooting a free throw and looking at the basket and seeing nothing except screaming fans; think about the field goal kicker trying to kick a last second field goal with 80,000 irate opponent's fans pleading with him to miss. Now, those are real fan pleasers!
  20. Steve
    20. Posted by Steve Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:41 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Tennis tried team tennis. Why not try it in golf? Have a short season making a big deal of the draft. Each city has a home course in some way? Yea its harder because of preparing a course. Or maybe have team golf matches in one area (the same cource be used around the country but have many different team matches there. Sort of like Ryder Cup but have the leagues playing at the same place at the same time). Sort of like how we watch the NFL on a tv. They keep going from game to game. Really promote City vs. city ect... There you get the cities involved? Then at the end of the season have the playoffs ect.... What do you think?
  21. Maco
    21. Posted by Maco Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Benchmarking from basketball: How about a Half-time show? Instead of it being at the real half time of the last round (after 9 holes), why not before the start of the last round? Just like in a basketball game, there will be games for the fans, putting contest, longest drive, closest to the hole....
    How about an All-Star round for the fans? It will be a two-day event full of fun and exhibition events for the golfers. Rookies vs. Sophomores, East vs. West, Veterans vs. Young Guns, skills games...
    Another thing that we can borrow from Basketball is the time-out huddle where you can hear what the coach is saying to the players, or a broadcaster can say what the caddie and player is talking about...
  22. Fore20
    22. Posted by Fore20 Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:36 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    How I would fix the FedEx cup:
    1. Anything that has a sponsor's name attached to it is pretty much worthless in the annals of sport. You don't try to win the Wendy's World Series or the Subway Super Bowl.
    2. There needs to be something different, not just some magic points scheme. Let your points determine who gets into the "playoffs" but then the season ending tournaments should be from scratch. Each of the final four tournaments should be a tourny of it's own, as it is now, but also a grand cumulative tournament where low man from the final 16 rounds takes the 10 million. This forces everyone to play all the events if they want to win, and sets up some very nice choke opportunities with a tournament that spans a month.
  23. Case
    23. Posted by Case Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:47 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Marco - love the All-Star idea. Good call on Rookies vs. Sophs, West Coast guys vs East Coasters, etc. That would be awesome! Jay also had a nice thought on the "Take us There" section. We need more coverage in the sense of the "feel" of the tournament. Clubhouse tours, town tours, interviewing a local or two - things that can be controlled and not get out of hand. By doing that, the average Joe who doesn't know tons about golf might want to watch and see what the Tour is all about...not just the players who wear white belts and fancy pants.
  24. DOYLE K
    24. Posted by DOYLE K Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:59 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Qualifying for the end of the year tournament should be based on top finishes... those with the most top 5, top 10, top 15 until a field is full. A full field is what 120, have them play a four round tournament one weekend, the top 60 go on to play the next four round tournament the following weekend. Then the top 30, then the top 15 play for the championship the last weekend. Whoever wins that one is the overall Champion.

Devil Ball Golf

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Jay Busbee

Devil Ball is a golf blog edited by Jay Busbee. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Devil Ball Golf Recent Readers