Devil Ball Golf - Golf

With Phil Mickelson's impressive victory in the Tour Championship two months ago and his performance this past week in China, some believe Lefty will surpass Tiger Woods as the best player in the game in 2010.

Nonsense. Lefty will find a way to make the wrong mistakes at the wrong time and remain how he will be forever defined: a tremendous player, even a Hall of Fame-caliber player (he'll likely finish with about 50 victories), but nowhere in the class of Mr. Woods. Nobody is. That is no crime.

Mickelson had his chance in the June 2006, and then came the Massacre at Winged Foot. If he had made one more lousy par on the 72nd hole of the Open, he would have recorded his third straight major victory and a legitimate case could have been made that he had surpassed Woods, at least temporarily.

Since then, Mickelson has failed to capture a major in 13 appearances, and that is how greatness in golf is measured, not in winning Tour Championships and certainly not in winning a European event in China despite the quality of the field. He squandered two excellent opportunities in 2009, at the Masters and the Open, with costly miscues on the back nine. Admit it: You weren't surprised he let them slip away, not one bit.

Much of the optimism for 2010 is due to his effectiveness on the greens after working with putting expert Dave Stockton. He made everything the final weekend in Atlanta. Yet there is a vast difference between East Lake and Augusta National, in the difficulties of the putting surface and the magnitude of the event. It remains to be seen whether he can again make the biggest putts on the biggest stages. He has three majors to his credit, but should have at least five or six by this point in his career.

No doubt Mickelson will win more events in 2010, perhaps even four or five. But that still won't be enough to dethrone Woods, who will be more motivated than ever after a year without a major title of his own.

Time is running out for Mickelson, who will turn 40 in June.

Woods will be only 34.

digg delicious
more

62 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Lamont D
    1. Posted by Lamont D Mon Nov 09, 2009 4:53 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Phil, will definitely make HOF (1st ballot), I for one love the fact he also won the last 2 tournaments. We are going to be in for a wonderul ride in 2010. I'm a Tiger fan, but I also love to see him get pushed, and Phil can do that! What I have never understood is why, he doesn't have the same concentration with Tiger out of the field? This is good for golf, I want to see their A games period.
  2. wftex
    2. Posted by wftex Mon Nov 09, 2009 5:18 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Tigger had already banked $3mil. just to show up. I hope the Chinese consider that money well spent just to learn how to cuss and throw a fit when things are not going your way, because that is all they got out of Tigger-man.
  3. wftex
    3. Posted by wftex Mon Nov 09, 2009 5:18 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Tigger had already banked %243mil. just to show up. I hope the Chinese consider that money well spent just to learn how to cuss and throw a fit when things are not going your way, because that is all they got out of Tigger-man.
  4. jkstutes
    4. Posted by jkstutes Mon Nov 09, 2009 5:21 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Phil is a choke artist. No one has the concentration that MR TIGER WOODS so frequently displays. It's just unfortunate for Phil that he is alive and playing golf in the same era as TIGER. The only think people like is that Phil has that OW SHUCKS look when he plays and TIGER doesnt talk to anyone. Maybe Phil should have that same attitude and he would play better instead of high fiving some dude in coaching shorts and penny loafers.
  5. donk
    5. Posted by donk Mon Nov 09, 2009 5:36 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Tiger IS NOT the same golfer he was before the leg injury. Yes he is winning but as has been pointed out in the
    past he is careful on which venues he chooses to play!! So he really knows the layouts for the most part and
    that is a big bonus for him. He just does not seem to have the same hunger he once had. The question is
    will he ever get back to that form? he will soon be a young 34 but he is already showing some signs of
    peaking out, which does not usually happen to these guys until their early 40's!!! 2010 will be an interesting
    year for both these guys since ol' apple pie face still has something to prove to Tiger!!!
  6. true fan
    6. Posted by true fan Mon Nov 09, 2009 5:38 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Let us be realistic if Phil wins 2 majors a year and 6 regular tournaments a year from now until he 45 and no longer a legitimate contender. He will still be one major short of Woods and many tournament wins short of Woods.
    Woods is the best of our time and Phil will have to remain a good but not one of the great golfers of our time.
  7. jeremy j
    7. Posted by jeremy j Mon Nov 09, 2009 5:44 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Say what you want but Phil played better than Tiger at the Masters, the tour championship, and now in China. Could be a big year for him next year if he starts the season hot. And tiger didnt look so clutch in the majors last year neither.
  8. Kenneth S
    8. Posted by Kenneth S Mon Nov 09, 2009 6:10 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Just because the Golden Bear was so dominant during his days DIDNT mean Arnold Palmer was not a 'great golfer'.
    We should be so fortunate to have a repeat of history... Jack (Tiger) and the peoples choice Arnie (Phil) and they were the two best golfers in the world for a few decades.
    Im waiting for the day when Tiger is about 42 (if he doesnt retire before then) and people have said hes done and through, and then pulls an 86' Masters out of nowhere.
    Everyone just relax and enjoy this time in history. It may be another 30 years after they are done before we see two men like this again.
  9. cpt
    9. Posted by cpt Mon Nov 09, 2009 6:39 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    thanks for raining on a parade.
  10. Lawrence
    10. Posted by Lawrence Mon Nov 09, 2009 6:56 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Phil will make the HOF and deservedly so. Tiger will win at least 20 majors and may even win one after the age of 50. Tiger will never ever step foot on the champions tour. Tiger will win at least 100 tournaments before he calls it a day.
  11. Kelly G
    11. Posted by Kelly G Mon Nov 09, 2009 7:24 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I just can't see Tiger playing much after 40. He get's too frustrated when he isn't winning and doubt if he would want to play when his game starts fading permanently. Of course he will if he doesn't have 19 majors, but I still think he will go out when he's still playing well. He won't want to be seen as a has been.
  12. Robert S
    12. Posted by Robert S Mon Nov 09, 2009 8:05 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I give Phil a lot of credit considering what he has gone thru this year personally and win four (4) tournaments. He is also one of the most unselfish players on the PGA Tour with his time. I look for him to have a huge 2010 and yes, win a major. The putter has been missing but is back.
  13. Meda
    13. Posted by Meda Mon Nov 09, 2009 8:05 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    #2 wtfex You would be TW in a heart beat if you could and you know it
  14. steve o
    14. Posted by steve o Mon Nov 09, 2009 8:05 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Love seeing Arkush man up and suck Tigers "dingdong" again. You can now count on 3 inevitables in life. Death, taxes and the media fawning over Tiger. fact #1. Tiger is the best golfer today and probably the best golfer ever. Fact #2 he had his weakest year in terms of closing out major tournaments. The reality is that the day of Tiger's past dominance is done!!!!!!!!!!!! yes he will win more majors and pass Nicklaus but the if you are a true student of the sport you will see a recent weakness in Tiger at crunchtime and that players are responding to Tiger's challenges better. My prediction is that Tiger has a few more years at #1 and at least 5 more majors but dont see him dominating the way he used to. Its not Tiger being a weaker golfer. Its Tiger LOSING HIS PSYCHOLOGICAL ADVANTAGE people
  15. Meda
    15. Posted by Meda Mon Nov 09, 2009 8:12 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    14 steve o not a bad way to look at it but I think TW still has the mental edge in the bigger tournys especially if he is n the last group on sunday but he does look like he has lost a little of his mojo should be a great 2010
  16. steve o
    16. Posted by steve o Mon Nov 09, 2009 8:26 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    15 meda. I agree with you man 100% he still has the edge and will have for awhile and that 2010 is looking ver y promising for golf. I am just trying to make a realistic point that Tiger's dominance is fading and the media will not admit that the rest of golf is catching up. Sure Tiger will have some great runs but his previous domininance is done. His invincibilcity has been shattered
  17. robert c
    17. Posted by robert c Mon Nov 09, 2009 8:28 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Tiger will not pass Jack for Majors.............Jack was the greatest golfer ever..............
  18. td1005
    18. Posted by td1005 Mon Nov 09, 2009 8:47 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    "a tremendous player, even a Hall of Fame-caliber player"
    what? an "even" a Hall of Fame caliber player?
    This is the most inane statment i've heard in a while here.
    Talk about an underhanded slight..
    Phil Mickelson has enough credential to get into the Hall if he were to retire today.
    Tell me who comes even close to having 37 PGA tour victories during the post-Nicklaus era.
  19. gmanglenn
    19. Posted by gmanglenn Mon Nov 09, 2009 8:54 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    4th straight time head-to-head Phil has taken down Tiger! Tiger won 6 tournaments this year but what were they, no majors. Phil won the tour Championship and by the end of this year we all know who looks like the better golfer, don't we? I sure do. Phil Mickelson!
  20. gmanglenn
    20. Posted by gmanglenn Mon Nov 09, 2009 8:57 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Arkrush- 40 year old golfer is hitting his prime, ask VJ and a few others!
  21. billieboy
    21. Posted by billieboy Mon Nov 09, 2009 9:01 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Someone said that Tiger Woods will NEVER set foot on the Senior Champions tour
    when he hits age 50 !
    He may be right coz Nicklaus hated the idea of being a " ceremonial " golfer
    on the PGA Tour BUT he did WIN TEN Champions events before he retired
    completely from golf.
    So maybe Tiger Woods might do the SAME thing !
  22. nbdkgy4
    22. Posted by nbdkgy4 Mon Nov 09, 2009 9:02 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Looked like Tiger could not stand the pressure of being paired with Phil in the final paring, Good choke job Tiger.
    Before all you Tiger lovers flip out, if the scores were reversed, that's what you would be saying........ :-)
  23. dennis m kelly
    23. Posted by dennis m kelly Mon Nov 09, 2009 10:00 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Gotta love it...Phil gets the hero treatment while TW sulks off #18.
    Phil cultivates the crowd. TW is too 'focused' to take notice of his adoring fans.
  24. rotina b redhot
    24. Posted by rotina b redhot Mon Nov 09, 2009 10:19 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    damm right he won't pass tiger except for walking bt him with his head down for the king of golf!!!

Devil Ball Golf

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Jay Busbee

Devil Ball is a golf blog edited by Jay Busbee. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Devil Ball Golf Recent Readers