Deadline deals: Nomar, Finley and more
by Mike Harmon
July 31, 2004
Garciaparra replaces a pathetic combination of Cubs shortstops, who combined to hit .222 with five measly home runs. Nomar brings a career .370 on-base percentage with him to Chicago, which means big RBI opportunities ahead for Derrek Lee and Sammy Sosa.
Psychologically, the move also rids Nomar of some of his demons of. He'll only need to worry about the Yankees if the Cubs make the World Series.
They've made the big move at the deadline and didn't have to surrender top prospect Angel Guzman. No goat boys or foul balls can be blamed for falling short this year.
Nomar's replacement, Orlando Cabrera, made it clear that he wasn't going to re-sign with Montreal, which granted him his wish by dealing him to potent Boston. He's immediately on the fantasy radar in AL-only leagues, adding another option at the SS and middle infield positions.
Cabrera has 12 steals on the season, so he'll team with Johnny Damon to get the line moving ahead of the big boys. He'll score a lot of runs in this lineup.
Dave Roberts brings another speed option to the Red Sox off the bench. He won't be an everyday player in this lineup, but he'll still collect some thefts down the stretch. Roberts becomes a spot starter for your team when your regulars are taking a day off.
Doug Mientkiewicz is added as a defensive specialist to allow David Ortiz to do what he does best – mash. Mientkiewicz's best offensive days are behind him, but he'll see regular time. He's clearly a backup. His Minnesota exit was inevitable with Justin Morneau's power production (10 extra-base hits in 21 games).
Gonzalez continues to underwhelm, carrying a .222 average with three HRs and eight RBIs. He's only a fantasy play in an act of sheer desperation.
Beltran has a live arm, but never found a home in the crowded Cubs staff. He strikes out better than a hitter per inning, and will likely compete with Chad Cordero for the closer position in the future.
Brendan Harris is a 23-year-old third base prospect who was shuffled back to the minors with the Cubs' acquisition of Aramis Ramirez. He'll see some time down the stretch with the Expos and will vie for a starting job in 2005.
Chicago White Sox
Since the White Sox will score nearly as many runs as the Yanks, he'll pick up some wins and stands as a good spot starter.
New York Mets
If you look at Benson's 2004 season in full, the 4.22 ERA and 1.37 WHIP aren't blowing you away. But let's take a closer look. Benson scuffled mightily in May, posting a 1-3 mark with an 8.10 ERA. If you look outside of those starts, he's posted a 7-5 mark with an impressive 3.08 ERA. He's posted a career 8-2 mark against his NL East rivals and gets to toss in the more pitcher-friendly confines of Shea Stadium.
Based on his physical tools, I like the possibility of him posting big numbers in New York. I will be curious as to how he responds to pitching in a pressure situation for the first time in years however.
He's still available in a number of fantasy leagues (roughly 20 percent) and makes for a great value play for owners looking for pitching help. Pitching alongside Tom Glavine and Al Leiter, effectively two coaches who trot out every fifth day, can only make him a better hurler
Victor Zambrano jumps from the upstart Tampa Bay Devil Rays to the resurgent New York Mets. This part of the trading game stands out most because of Zambrano's entry to NL-only leagues. Managers in need of pitching help who can withstand his assault on the team WHIP need to hit the waiver wire to claim Zambrano.
He's striking out near one hitter per inning pitched and, like Benson, will benefit from the deep power alleys of Shea.
Pitching coach Rick Peterson is licking his chops to get his hands on Zambrano's live arm. Allegedly, he's already discovered the flaw in Zambrano's motion that will cut down on his propensity to walk a boatload of hitters. That'll be a longer-term project, but the fact that super prospect Scott Kazmir was dealt in the process speaks volumes about the Mets' expectations for Zambrano.
Kazmir is a guy to watch for a fast ticket to the big leagues. He's got an overpowering fastball and will challenge for a spot in the rotation next season.
In Tampa Bay, Jorge Sosa will step into the rotation. He strikes out better than a hitter per inning but walks about the same. He's a project for next season.
Mets closer Braden Looper is dancing over these two acquisitions, as his number of save opportunities stands to rise (he's 21-24 in save opportunities). Recent callup David Wright also solidifies his starting position with the departure of Ty Wigginton. Those managers looking for help at 3B can be encouraged that four of Wright's first eight hits were for extra bases and he's putting the ball into play.
Ryan Vogelsong, he of the 2-7 record and 6.69 ERA, will take Benson's place in the rotation. Next!
Juan Encarnacion returns to Florida, a team that utilizes aggressive baserunning to manufacture runs. He stole 19 bases for the Marlins in 2003, so perhaps his return to the Marlins will allow him to add another component to his fantasy value.
Paul Lo Duca's average has dipped slightly since the All-Star break, but he remains valuable in the catcher position. With only 27 strikeouts in 349 at-bats, Jack McKeon will undoubtedly utilize Lo Duca in hit-and-run situations, leading to more RBI opportunities.
Since Dodger Stadium and Pro Player Stadium both are pitchers' parks, Hee-Seop Choi's numbers will not change tremendously upon arriving in Los Angeles. He'll provide extra power surges throughout the valley with his mighty swings and misses and the occasional moon shot. The big move here is that Shawn Green can return to his comfort zone in the outfield.
Brad Penny solidifies the starting rotation and pitching in Dodger Stadium, one shouldn't see tremendous spikes or valleys to his output. He generally goes six to seven innings in his starts, so one can't help but wonder about the impact that Mota's departure will have on the Dodgers. There will be tremendous pressure on former fantasy favorite Darren Dreifort to protect leads and pave the way for Eric Gagne.
San Francisco Giants
Of course, the trading deadline doesn't rule out possible movement in the month of August. It just gets more complicated with the waiver process.
There are other moves still in the works, perhaps involving veterans such as Charles Johnson (Dodgers?). I'll be keeping a close eye on the action.
Updated on Saturday, Jul 31, 2004 8:28 pm, EDT