Draft and Trade Talk Message Board
- mcbrizzle mcbrizzle Sep 23, 2013 4:15 PM Flag
league notes their explanation of the scoring. They use an NFL rule as the support for their reasoning but their scoring using a different basic premise (NFL does not acknowledge defensive TDs, as upon change of possession Def immediately becomes offense).. So to use the technical explanation by the NFL when the beginning premises are different in the first place is a flaw in the reasoning.
- mcbrizzle mcbrizzle Sep 23, 2013 3:48 PM Flag
See I don't see it as Yahoo's Rule....I see it as Yahoo's interpretation. The scoring under Defense merely says TD. Since the NFL doesn't (apparently) recognize defensive touchdowns at all, using an NFL technicality as support for their argument when the premise of Defensive TD doesn't exist in the first place...is poor logic. I hate that they are going against the grain and going to force me to set precedence by overruling. This is now a slippery slope and I can thank them for pushing me down it
I read their reasoning and their logic is flawed (like so many of their articles). Just wanted to get a sense from other commissioners on how many are actually going to over rule yahoo and adjust the points manually? I head a fairly high stakes league and this will be single determining factor on which owner wins and loses. Thanks,