Commissioner Corner Message Board
- Jonny G Jonny G Apr 6, 2013 5:38 PM Flag
First round is reasonable in my opinion. However, I think 5th is a little early. I could see anywhere from 9-12 where guys get less reliable being a worthy draft spot.
- Jonny G Jonny G Mar 30, 2013 6:12 PM Flag
I don't doubt the production they're capable of, I doubt the health as several of them are already dealing with injuries.
If they stay healthy, you will be sitting in a prime playoff seat. If they don't, and I don't expect more than 50% of them to, then you will be scrambling with table scraps.
- Jonny G Jonny G Mar 30, 2013 5:53 PM Flag
Yeah, Chisenhall is just filling in because it looks like Sandoval may miss the start of the year. Wil Myers is a 3 year/18th round keeper. I plan on hanging on to him throughout the duration of his 3 year contract.
C- Santana (15th rd keeper, final season)
2B- Kipnis (9th rd keeper)
OF- Kemp, Upton, Adam Jones (5th rd keeper), Ichiro, W. Myers (18th rd keeper)
SP- Price (12 rd keeper, final season), Hamels, Lester, Lincecum, Pettite, Hanson, Maholm, Bundy, Feliz (DL)
RP- Rodney (17 rd keeper, final season), Putz, Kenley Jansen
I traded Encarnacion as a 3 year keeper in the 18th round and Dan Haren for Prince Fielder who is in the last year of his contract as a first rounder. Thoughts?
I don't really trust Encarnacion, even though their lineup is nasty. Good deal?
- Jonny G Jonny G Mar 30, 2013 5:39 PM Flag
Might as well. Teheran looks like a stud in spring, and he will be pitching at the backend of the rotation against lesser talents. Not to mention he should get plenty of run support to feel comfortable when he's on the mound. I'll take the upside on this one.
- Jonny G Jonny G Mar 30, 2013 5:34 PM Flag
A lot of guys are high on Scherzer this year. I think he's significantly over-valued. He will get solid K's, but his ratios will not be reliable. Hill is also an unstable fantasy commodity. I think you should look for a deal elsewhere.
- Jonny G Jonny G Mar 30, 2013 5:29 PM Flag
Wait a sec, do you HAVE Tulo? Or are they offering him to you? If you already have him, DEAL HIM. If they are offering him to you for Castro and Bumgarner, keep what you have.
- Jonny G Jonny G Mar 30, 2013 5:21 PM Flag
Absolutely take that deal. Bumgarner is a stud and Castro should be much less risky than Tulo. Yes, Tulo is a stud when healthy, but when is he ever healthy?