This was my gut impression, however . . . until I changed the background image from the blurred image to the solid white, the entire screen was hard to digest, visually.
It's not all bad. You have added some great features, like the instant save on lineup changes and the ability to start all available players with one click.
So, it's more the visual experience. For example, I will take a while to get used to not seeing all the digits on the player stats as you have chosen to lighten the zeros as well as some of the categories entirely.
Back to my earlier point about the background image, though; can I control it on pages beyond my fantasy pages? I don't like it.