• Commissioner Corner Message Board

  • Gabe Gabe Nov 29, 2010 3:10 AM Flag

    5 for 5 trade! [Gasol, Rose, Westbrook, Noah and Beasley for Love, CP3, Lee, Manu and Iggy]

    I've been offered:

    Pau Gasol
    Russell Westbrook
    Derrick Rose
    Joakim Noah
    Michael Beasley


    Chris Paul
    Kevin Love
    Manu Ginobili
    David Lee
    Andre Iguodala

    My team: (excluding the players involved in the trade)
    Kobe Bryant
    Brandon Jennings
    Eric Gordon
    Rudy Gay
    Dirk Nowitzki
    Boris Diaw
    Rodney Stuckey
    Chris Kaman

    I think it's good, but I'm scared I'm giving up too much.

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • if anything take the first offer with noah not the one without him. I'd say do it.

    • Duhh, Westbrook and rose give u great depth at G, Beasly and Westbrook are on fire, and Gasol will figure it out, plus ur not givin up that much compaired to wat ur gittin back!!! Cp3 and love r good but the others are not that bigga price!!!

    • rose gasol alll day westbrook a beast are kidding dont trade.....cp3 and gasol coin flip...manu is old but he old can get hurt any day....david lee over noah never...andre iguodala he plays good then bad ....rose a beast .....beasley puttin numbers up westbrook playing better then durant....are u kiddin i wouldt come close to trading dem players

    • When making major trades, never look at the top players because they will be pretty even in value. ALWAYS look at the bottom players and try to rank them. The guys you're giving up do not equal in value to the guys you would be getting. Another piece of advice is to make a trade that's in your favor. This is quite different than the feelings you're giving away at the moment. You seem hestitant, so DON'T do it. Stuart

    • u trade me kobe n rose for chris paul!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • I'd say go ahead and accept it because all the players you are getting are going to make deep run in the playoffs.

    • i do it real fast. gasol is an actual STUD, westbrook is playing at an MP level. Rose is actually playing D and hittin 3s this year and the rest is irrelevant

    • you loose this deal. your players are far better fantasy wise. do not takke it. trust me

    • make it a 3 for 3 deal. That will figure out what he is really going after. Looks like he is trying to sell high. He really wants Chris Paul and Manu. Those guys would give him a boost in all shooting percentages and even assists. But he is offering you a lot of points in return. Can you count on those same points down the stretch? These commenters say no. Gasol is the only reason you make a deal with him, even if his minutes drop he is still one of the best in the league. I can't see how Beasley can keep up this pace. Take Beasley and Love out of this and you have a real reason for trading. I doubt he will do that but if he isn't confident with Noah and Beasly neither should you. One more thing to consider...Manu is one of my favorites on either of these teams but he has never been healthy for a full season and usually his time off is a long time off. I would hate for that to happen during your playoff games if its Head to Head.

    • This looks like a trade just for the sake of making trades.I can't see how the overall stats of all these players are any different. I think if anything you are getting lower less threes and more turnovers. And Noah can't help your FT%. But really its just a personal decision when its this even, do you want to cheer for these players? This must be a fun league with very few owners huh.

    • View More Messages

Expert Fantasy Advice

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Football