id say take it. Its a keeper league. Lee is a year two player who is on the cusp of a breakout in a great opportunity in NJ. Redd is injury prone, im not sure how old he is but i think he is over 30. Lee probably will have more value this year as Redd is already out with pain in his repaired left knee.
I would take it. At this point the only thing that has held you back is name value which obviously Redd has and Lee doesnt. But the numbers, potential, injury free-ness, and future is with Lee.