Commissioner Corner Message Board

TEAM B

If positions matter, I like Team B. Actually, I like Team B either way. Crosby has been ridiculously hot but the better players are going the other way, plus a better goalie.

Kipper over Varlamov is the key here. You can argue Crosby/Toews/Peverly vs Semin/Boyle/Sedin is pretty even. Crosby is the high end player, but Boyle trumps Peverly in my opinion. Sedin and and Toews pretty much cancel each other out. So, if Semin can come back in playing as well as he was when he got injured, Team B wins hands down, cause Kipper is the marble in the oatmeal.

What a F'd up trade. Why would you trade away 3 centers and get none in return, and why would you want 3 centers and not dish any away??? weird.

Team B wins... what are you going to do with 3 more centers?

Team A

honestly, might as well flip a f'ing coin as to wins that one.

Its a pretty even trade.

But in a keeper I'd definitely want A, because its younger.

Besides that its a wash. Good trade for both sides if it helps the righ tpositions.

Cheers

What's the purpose of trading half your team?

team a wins