Duchene and Seguin seem pretty similar to me, but I would give Seguin the edge with the season he is having. He has a better team and better players around him so I think he can keep up his point per game pace and high plus/minus rating. I think Duchene is good, but I don't think he's quite that 80 point guy yet, more like low 70s. Subban is a more reliable D Man, he gets quite a few PIMS but don't get me wrong Kulikov is having a breakout season. I like this trade if you're getting Seguin and Subban. I'd take it.