I'm indifferent about the original trade. Not sure who would be getting the better deal. But i feel you would be losing out on that Kane trade unless you are stacked on D or could pick up a good free agent. Stewart seems to be pretty underrated in my opinion. I predict Stewart will rack up about 35G, 40A on an improved Blues team, and Phaneuf to put up about 15G, 35-40A. I see Kane putting up about 35G, 55A so interpret that how you wish. I personally wouldn't make that trade. Just my opinion.
Thank you for your insight! I felt i was giving him to much as well. The original trade i felt indifferent as well. I had Kane for my first year doing this last year and besides the injury he kicked ass. Im new with stewart and was taking a hunch when i drafted him this year. Thanks for the help!