depth in an 8 man league? i think if i drafted somewhat competently im going to have some depth already. if this was 10 12 man and up than i would consider it depending on my team. The offer is decent/fair, but are you overpaying for a guy that goes top 5 in most drafts, I dont think so. Ill take perry especially in a league that counts pims. I dont know what the other team looks like but its hard for me to imagine he will take semin and hall for perry. If this deal is on the table and hes willing i would take in a heartbeat. thats just me.
allow my to clarify. im a ducks fan and i had perry on more than half of my teams last year. this year i have him on zero of my teams because hes simply overvalued. i watched many ducks games last season and the year perry had scoring wise was flukey and he won't repeat it. at the end of the day, semin is a better player and more likely to put up superior numbers. add in another wing with 70+ point potential in a h2h league where depth matters a lot and even though perry is one of my favorite players i'd still glady hit accept. thats just me.