• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • Agent Girl Agent Girl Oct 2, 2011 2:12 PM Flag

    Is This Fair Trade?

    them:
    kopitar
    Vanek
    Brassard

    me:
    Ovechkin

    should I or should I keep?

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • R u crazy?!? Yes u would get Ovie but u r giving up way too much.

    • Kopitar and Vanek will be studs on teams that will win a ton of games. Brassard has yet to turn into the player the Jackets were looking for and I would think that his ice time will drop with Carter and Ryan Johanson in the mix. I would take Vanek and Kopitar over Ovi though for sure. Have a look to rookie Johanson too, I expect big things from him this year in Columbus.

    • I'm not a big fan of 2 for 1 or 3 for 1 trades because you have to drop other players so you end up losing more than just the 1 guy...here's how I see it. For OVi, you should be getting back a TOP 10 forward at the LEAST...you're getting Kopitar so you got that. Vanek is a god pickup and should increase his point total with the summer pickups by Buffalo. Brassard to me is a through-in...I personally think he's over-rated.
      So Vanek takes OVi's place in your LW spot...if you can afford to drop a centreman, then it could be good trade but if you have to drop a top 20 centreman to make room for Kopitar, you might be giving up too much!!!! Too many variables, depends on the rest of your line up!

      If you have a second, give me some feedback on this one:
      In a 12 team ROTO league...stats are G, A, P, +/-, PPP, SOG, PIM and HITS. I need 2 out of the following Dman as my # 4 and 5 defencemen. Who would you take? Pleas rank them as 2 are on waivers and I may not get the best 2 players.

      Bieksa
      Corvo
      Carle
      Hamonic
      Leopold
      Staal
      Bogosian

      Thanks...

      • 2 Replies to A Yahoo! User
      • Vanek and Kopitar for Ovie you would be making out very well. Vanek is a lock at 30-40 and nearly ppg, Kopitar is a ppg guy. I'd get Brassard outa the deal and do the 2for 1 if you need a center upgrade. If your team has strong centers than I may keep Ovie. My rule of thimb is I only make trades to build my team up. I needed center badly in a league and it is dynasty so I wanted young too. I moved Perry for Kopitar and Eberle. All depends what you need.

      • Thanks so much for getting back to me with such a in depth response most people just say so little. I love Kopitar but I am not going to let go of Ovechkin for 3 players that I will have to drop people for.

        Now on to your d-men going by last year stats with PPG and PPP

        1. Corvo
        2. Leopold
        3. Staal
        4. Bieksa
        5. Bogosian
        6. Hamonic

        Your thoughts?

 

Expert Fantasy Advice

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Football